Is she objectively the best female musician of all time?
Is she objectively the best female musician of all time?
shes not even the best female harp player in popular music. alice coltrane owns/owned her.
Kate Bush
this
she's a singer first and foremost
damn kate was sexy back in the day.
it's not like she's the best singer either
Yeah. Amazing footwork
^songwriter and lyricist
Grimes is.
/thread
this desu
i came to post Kate too.
fuck yeah she was.
Not even the best from the 2000's (or 2010's).
Joanna's lyrics are better than Kate's t bh.
She's also more talented instrumentation wise - very underrated pianist. Kate Bush is a far better singer but that's it.
>muh reverb
>muh whispery vocals
nah
putting muh in front of something doesn't automatically mean its a bad thing
LOL
Prove me wrong.
> Kate Bush is a far better singer but that's it.
not forgetting that Kates albums are about 100x more interesting than Joannas.
How are they more interesting? I feel Joanna is superior in terms of arrangement, harmony, counterpoint/melody, etc. as well as thematically and lyrically.
that's subjective
music is subjective, more at 11.
Yeah, definitely the best of the last decade, musician and song writer
Welcome to Sup Forums, a board for the discussion of something that is inherently subjective
Here are some that are just as good or better than Joanna just from this decade.
>Julia Holter
>St. Vincent
>Fiona Apple
>Janelle Monae
>Bjork still
>Xenia Rubinos
>Jenny Hval
So if she wants to be the best of all time, she has her work cut out for her. Here are some from the past just to put some more perspective on this claim:
>Nico
>Alice Coltrane
>Nina Simone
>Stevie Nicks
>Patti Smith
>Dolly Parton
>Kate Bush
>Joni Mitchell
Nah but she's objectively the qtest harp player that ever lived.
best male artist too, she transcends gender
Definitely the best female songwriter. Top 5 songwriter all time, probably.
They still are
Vashti Bunyan
Yoko Ono
Annette Peacock
Carla Bley
Sheila E
step up indie boyz
Implying
>ignoring the best one, grimes
True patrician female musician.
ITT: no one who has ever read Joannas lyrics
ITT: People who think lyrics matter
came here to post this
The only one I'd say comes close to Kate is Joni Mitchell. Other than her Kate is in her own league.
ur wrong kid
>st vincent
>janelle monae
>jenny hval
>nico
>stevie nicks
>PATTI SMITH
>anywhere in joanna's vicinity
loving every laugh
Joanna is incredible technically speaking but Bjork remains my favorite musician of all time.
Still love Joanna though, even if Divers kinda sucked.
What is wrong with Joanna's voice? How could you enjoy that annoying voice?