Now that the dust has settled I think we can all agree that this is overrated for nostalgia and has aged terribly...

Now that the dust has settled I think we can all agree that this is overrated for nostalgia and has aged terribly. The only good one is Fellowship and its perfect.

FOTR 10/10
TTT 6.5/10
ROTK 4.5/10

FOTR EE 11/10
TTT EE 7/10
ROTK EE 5/10

Sup Forums, please.

Helm's Deep was best battle

Nice try but I'm only from here. Bad rebuttal

your opinion and your thread are shit

Why does the uruk hai who battles Aragorn at the end of Fellowship pull Aragorn's sword deeper into hits gut in order to get in Aragorn's face? Was he getting off on being mortally wounded?

furst

You Mother will die anyways

before reading the books:
>FOTR 10/10
>TTT 6/10
>ROTK 5/10

after reading the books:
FOTR 9/10
>no bilbo party
>no grave
>no tom

TTT 8/10
>made the whole ent thing not boring af

>ROTK 2/10
i dont know why bookfags didnt outrage after seeing rotk
>aragorn story absoltuly fucked up
>hobbit war removed
>JUST

Bilbo party is in FOTR

Stop dude

>i dont know why bookfags didnt outrage after seeing rotk
Because movie was great.

well
fotr had no battle and the other big battles were isengard and gondor.
gondor was terrible and isengard was just trees fighting.

The movie is worse and worse on every rewatch. It has some good moments. But is not in any way shape or form a good film

TTT also suffers on rewatches

Rato

bilbos book party was way better.
why and how he left.

Fuck you Peter and your filtered bullshit

I actually think the EE of TTT and RotK are worse than the theatrical cuts. Only good thing about RotK EE is Saruman's onscreen death.

not again

Immunity cat where?

bruh

You ruined the last thread with this shit you nigger.

FOTR is the best because so much happens, and you get to explore nearly all of middle earth, it's like you're really being drawn into this believable world

ROTK is just a shitload of battles

^ not know how blue ray work

This. EE really messed with the pacing and had some bad scenes, like when aragorn.summoned the army on the corsair's

Sick bait
Here's a (you)

Why did I click.

FOTR is the best because most of the time you hang out in comfy hobbitland or elrond's crib

that's because these threads are SHIT
just fucking awful

Stop posting these

>i guess that concludes negotiations

too many corny moments in return of the ring extended edition

Fuck you

ass

Replied

(You)

Fuck off

Anyone who doesn't love the charge of the Rohirrim, kys.

k

Fucckkk

Every scene that is does not involve Arwen or Gimli being comic relief is 10/10.

(You)