Are we meant to enjoy this movie? What's the point of watching something if we're not meant to be entertained by it?

Are we meant to enjoy this movie? What's the point of watching something if we're not meant to be entertained by it?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=o_huIjlV6Go
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ministry_of_Public_Security_(Poland)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amon_Göth
youtube.com/watch?v=RHzWo79dCHs
youtube.com/watch?v=47rbRNSGQUs
youtube.com/watch?v=RddqP0ABzwM
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirosław_Hermaszewski
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

pleb

I found it very entertaining. Best comedy of that year.

max plebbing

I'm a huge fan of anything in the fiction genre but this movie was a huge suspension of disbelief

So you literally watch movies to not feel entertained, but to feel shitty afterwards? What's the point?

just the shots (and I mean Spielberg's camera shots) are alone more than enough to make this movie great
It is the best character movie since citizen kane and nothing topped it since.
You can meme all you want about
>le jews
>hitler dindu nuffin
>the holocaust never happened
And movie aren't always made to make you feel happy

do you only watch movies if they're in the imdb top 100?

haven't watched it yet, is it just pure propaganda or

I never go to imdb
I only know that shawshank is like the number 1 right? And I find shawshank mediocre but the Brooks scene

>Hello everyone I'm a pleb

dark knight is 4, this should say enough

It's a genuinely good movie if you aren't a turbo polfag.
Even if you take out the holocauts, is still the story of a single man trying to do good.

It's good but it's not the best character film since Citizen Kane. That's a massive exaggeration

>What's the point of watching something if we're not meant to be entertained by it?
Plebbest of plebs

>pure propaganda
Yes, the Germans did nothing wrong. Sup Forums said this and I believe them because they quote articles from the most objective newspaper in the history Der Stürmer.

>Are we meant to enjoy this movie?
>Are we meant to enjoy the greatest comedy film of all time?
Well, yes. Idiot.

>This is the mind set of a capeshit fan
Top fuckin pleb

What are you talking about? It's a comedy. Of course it's meant to be enjoyed.

youtube.com/watch?v=o_huIjlV6Go

which one is then?

i never said that the germans did nothing wrong, but obviously the winners write the history books.

thanks, will watch

>but obviously the winners write the history books
I supposed this is the reason why there are so many books about Allies war crimes and even more about Soviet Union crimes.

It's stupid to try and definitively state which is the best. TWBB or the Master are both fantastic off the top of my head.

>PTA
I love TWBB but come it is not as great as Schindler
Daniel was shit from the get go, Schindler has a clearly an arc and a change of heart, he has much more depth to him

Character studies are not necessarily about an arch, and Daniel Plainview has a pretty clear decline regardless.

>one kinda good German
>let's make a film about him!
>thousands of Poles helping Jews, many of them murdered by the Nazis for this
>Polish death camps! Poles were worse than the Germans!

Darth Vader's character arc.

t. Zdzisław Nowakowski

>Sup Forums

I dunno I still finding Schindler better, it is 3 hours long and it definitely doesn't feel like while TWBB definitely does
The fake brother sub plot is weak as fuck, Dano was good but having him playing two characters is just confusing
The cinematography is great in both movies but I think Schindler has more good stuff in it

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ministry_of_Public_Security_(Poland)

>was a postwar communist, secret police, intelligence and counter-espionage service operating from 1945 to 1954 under minister for Public Security general (Generał brygady) Stanisław Radkiewicz, and supervised by Jakub Berman of the Politburo. Its main goal was the eradication of the anti-communist structures and socio-political base of the underground Polish Secret State as well as, the persecution of soldiers of the Polish Home Army (Armia Krajowa) and Freedom and Independence (WiN) active during World War II.

>From January 1945 (or, July 22), the surviving members of the Home Army laid down their arms, granted an official amnesty (lasting till October 15). Most were arrested by MBP on the spot, tortured and tried for treason.[9] The MBP carried out brutal pacification of civilians, mass arrests (see: Augustów roundup), as well as makeshift executions (see: Mokotów Prison murder, Public execution in Dębica) and secret assassinations.[10] According to depositions by Józef Światło and other communist sources, in 1945 alone the number of members of the Polish Underground State deported to Siberia and various labor camps in the Soviet Union reached 50,000.

Most notable MBP personnel:
Antoni Alster (Jew)
Jakub Berman (Jew)
Józef Bik (Jew)
Julia Brystiger (Jew)
Józef Czaplicki (Jew)
Anatol Fejgin (Jew)
Julian Kole (Jew)
Julian Konar (Jew)
Mieczysław Mietkowski (Jew)
Salomon Morel (Jew)
Józef Różański (Jew)
Roman Romkowski (Jew)
Leon Rubinstein (Jew)
Józef Swiatło (Jew)
Helena Wolińska-Brus (Jew)

are you denying that there were many, many polish collaborators?

>On March 30, 1943, the SS Headquarters refused to create Polish units, citing among the reasons that thousands of Poles fled both the German and Austrian armies in 1917–1918; that the creation of Polish units would mean that Poles and Germans should be officially treated as equal; and the fact that the Poles themselves were not willing to fight for Germany.[11]

my dad always gets really pissed about this shit

so you're saying there were no poles complicit in the holocaust?

that's ridiculous

I thought the ending was good, but there was a lot of poetic license taken that I thought detracted from the actual story.of what happened

There were, but they weren't that common.

>The imposition of the death penalty for Poles aiding Jews was unique to Poland among all German occupied countries, and was a result of the conspicuous and spontaneous nature of such an aid.[72] For example, the Ulma family (father, mother and six children) of the village of Markowa near Łańcut – where many families concealed their Jewish neighbors – were executed jointly by the Nazis with the eight Jews they hid.[73] The entire Wołyniec family in Romaszkańce was massacred for sheltering three Jewish refugees from a ghetto. In Maciuńce, for hiding Jews, the Germans shot eight members of Józef Borowski family along with him and four guests who happened to be there.[74] Nazi death squads carried out mass executions of the entire villages that were discovered to be aiding Jews on a communal level.[28][75] In the villages of Białka near Parczew and Sterdyń near Sokołów Podlaski, 150 villagers were massacred for sheltering Jews.[76]

>a person life's worth a fucking pin

It's pure fiction that they showed us in high school presented as fact.
It's nothing more than an indoctrination tool.

test

No, you're supposed to feel like the jews are good people that dindu nuffin and immense amounts of white guilt.

Reminder that Amon Goth (played by Ralph Fiennes) was removed from his position and arrested by the Nazis due in part to his mistreatment of prisoners.

>Dismissal and captureEdit

On 13 September 1944 Göth was relieved of his position and charged by the SS with theft of Jewish property (which belonged to the state, according to Nazi legislation), failure to provide adequate food to the prisoners under his charge, violation of concentration camp regulations regarding the treatment and punishment of prisoners, and allowing unauthorised access to camp personnel records by prisoners and non-commissioned officers.[34]

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amon_Göth

Why are there so many people here who are holocaust deniers?

Sup Forumsacks and people brainwashed by them.

to think, you dumb faggot.

you losers only watch easy, shallow trash like capeshit and transformer, or stuff that will trigger you so you can whine about it later (like the polblerinas are doing itt).

Because this is an open, anonymous discussion forum.

If you're interested in Holocaust revisionism I suggest checking out these documentaries:

>David Cole in Auschwitz full documentary 1992

youtube.com/watch?v=RHzWo79dCHs

>The Treblinka Archaeology Hoax (2014)

youtube.com/watch?v=47rbRNSGQUs

>Questioning The Holocaust - Why We Believed (Part 1 of 2)

youtube.com/watch?v=RddqP0ABzwM

>it's only brainwashing when it's an opinion held by a minority of people

You definitely weren't brainwashed into believing anything via the media or education.

""""documentaries""""

If you're interested in Holocaust I suggest reading books, not watching Youtube videos.

it was such a cheap movie. emotionally manipulating people, especially the scene with the girl in a red coat.

>denying physical video evidence

And the makers of those documentaries wrote such books, ya jackass.

Not an argument.

Stay ignorant pal.

this is why I don't find strange people forgetting the jedi in 40 years

>wrote such books
Not really, revisionism isn't real history. Also, I bet you haven't even read their books, let alone good books about the holocaust.
Watching shitty videos on Youtube is easier than reading a book about the extermination of Jews.

Let me guess, you also watched Hitler: The Greatest Story Never Told and now believe the Nazis did nothing wrong?

You're unaware of the arguments put forth in these documentaries, yet you criticize them.

You refuse to even consider to challenge your views.

You're a closed minded fool.

>You're a closed minded fool
No, you are. You're too lazy to learn the official story of the holocaust, because I doubt you've read a single book about it. Books are boring, right?

Great comeback, faggot.

Nice non argument you got there.

So I'm right. You don't know the official story and "refuse to even consider to challenge your views".

No you're not right.

>HURR DURR I BET X

isn't an argument.

How many books about holocaust have you read then? And what kind of books?

You do realize that holocaust education is a mandatory part of every school curriculum throughout the entire western world, right?

And that the Holocaust is a constant topic of television programs, movies, documentaries, news articles, etc.

>How many books about holocaust have you read then? And what kind of books?

None of your fucking business.

How about you stop criticizing materials you have no knowledge of, you closed minded faggot?

>The official story
>Muh six million
>No physical evidence actually existing of ovens capable of burning that many bodies in that span of time, and functioning gas chambers that could safely pump in and extract the poisonous gas
>Multiple "eye witnesses" being exposed as frauds ("It was real in my mind")

Good goyim. Don't question what your Masters tell you.

good historical fantasy

I refuuse to believe you're a real person with this actual opinion

>You do realize that holocaust education is a mandatory part of every school curriculum throughout the entire western world, right?
>mandatory

Gee, I wonder why that is. I guess you don't know indoctrination when you see it.

>you closed minded faggot

Pot, meet kettle.

>not enjoying good performances

Faggot.

>and functioning gas chambers that could safely pump in and extract the poisonous gas
See, you don't even know how the gas chambers worked.

>Gee, I wonder why that is. I guess you don't know indoctrination when you see it.

I agree that the purpose of mandatory Holocaust education is indoctrination.

>Pot, meet kettle.

You've yet to demonstrate how I'm being closed minded.

just a reminder that the JIDF are getting paid to post in this thread

Is this your first day on Sup Forums.

Can you imagine that you're replying to a different user?

Moron.

Neither do you if you think a proper "gas chamber" would be fitted with wooden doors and floor drains and no way to remove said gas.

Your mandatory holocaust education is irrelevant. Read academic books about the destruction of European Jews. School education is good for kids.

You agree that the Holocaust education is indoctrination, but you disagree that the stuff they're indoctrinating you with is false.

It's a Sup Forums meme. You don't know the official story. Apparently even reading the Wikipedia page is too time consuming for people like you.

>tfw there's always some kinda of black pillar between them to symbolze that Schindler is not the same as your regular nazi

What the fuck are you talking about? Have you ever seen a photo from an actual gas chamber? They have (non-airtight) wooden doors, glass windows, floor drains, and no extraction systems.

>Your mandatory holocaust education is irrelevant.

It isn't irrelevant as it addresses your original point:

You said:

>you're too lazy to learn the official story of the holocaust, because I doubt you've read a single book about it. Books are boring, right?

The official story of the Holocaust is learned by every school aged child in the West.

>Read academic books about the destruction of European Jews. School education is good for kids.

I've read plenty of books regarding the Holocaust.

You're not aware of the arguments presented in the documentaries I provided therefore you cannot be certain that the claims are ever addressed in any "academic books" regarding the Holocaust.

You haven't even bothered to consider the position of Holocaust revisionists, which is why I'm ridiculing you.

If your response is something like:

>NO I BET YOU HAVEN'T READ ANY "GENUINE" BOOKS ABOUT THE HOLOCAUST

Then don't bother as this conversation is going in circles. I'll end by saying you're a gigantic faggot with a closed mind.

Art is about conveying emotion, not mindless entertainment, you fucking pleb.

Schindler's List is the heart wrenching tale of the persecution of a completely blameless innocent who does nothing wrong.

first day on Sup Forums?

ebin response, maybe it will become a meme

>Schindler's list thread
>you could be talking about the wonderful performances
>you could be talking about the wonderful music
>you could be talking about how Schindler evolves as a character without having that especific point where he says "teehee now i'm goody!"
>you could be talking about the killing shots of prime Spielberg
>NO LET'S DISCUSS IF THE HOLOCAUST HAPPEND FOR THE GORILLION TIME

fuck you fucking shitheads

maybe you will

Amon Goth was a really evil man, even the Nazis thought so.

See:

>Test audiences thought the violence in the film was over the top and unrealistic.
>The violence was actually toned down from reality to film.

rude

muh holocaust mothafucka!

>I've read plenty of books regarding the Holocaust.
Please name them.
>You're not aware of the arguments presented in the documentaries
I actually watched them.

Fuck you, SJW nigger, we don't like to watch movies. We don't watch movies--period. We only observe Jewish influence in media.

>people actually believe this

...

...

...

...

>this nigger got so triggered he is going to post a fucking book

But Poland can't into space

>The stupid fucking red jacket on the little girl

Literally fedora tipping college film student tier

>he can't sit and watch a great story

literally autistic

It was written in a book, so it must be true.

No photos, drawings, etc. of such a device? And one for each prisoner, no less? Wow, those Germans sure were efficient in their killing methods.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirosław_Hermaszewski

>a person life's worth a fucking pin