Is it possible for Nazis to make good music?

Is it possible for Nazis to make good music?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=z8O2ToQ_Dok
youtube.com/watch?v=Ux_j06K-4_Q
youtube.com/watch?v=GPzvcBFHnI0
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

with these rules it would be hard

no

Erica is a good song

Horst Wessel Lied was pretty good

>So-called jazz compositions may contain at most 10% syncopation; the remainder must consist of a natural legato movement devoid of the hysterical rhythmic reverses characteristic of the barbarian races and conductive to dark instincts alien to the German people (so-called riffs)

>devoid of [...] so-called riffs

>devoid of riffs

>no riffs

>NORIFFS

>N O R I F F S

NAZIS CONFIRMED FOR WORST TASTE

NSBM CONFIRMED FOR NU-MALE NORIFF ATMOSHIT

easy: Wagner.

>Jewishly gloomy lyrics

christgau's review of bridge over troubled water

>dude this guy held the common views of the time let me judge him using modern values oops he i a fugging nazi :DDD

such Sup Forums tier posting should be outlawed
kill yourself

yes, it's entirely possible. Doesn't mean I have to like them as people though

it's /metal/ posting

He didn't just share common views of the time, if he did how would we know about it. He wrote essays setting out his view, not just bar room gossip and he based his entire career on trying to eliminate jewishness from music. He wasn't just a casual racist therefore nazi. A political organisation wouldn't adopt much of the ideology of a man just because he said kike occasionally.

Yes.

you can't make good art without empathy.

right wingers, conservatives, nationalists and Sup Forums manchildren will never create anything of value.

What about empathy towards white children and their future?

that's a bit stereotypical and arguably unempathetic don't you think

Can antifa make good music?
No

>Jewishly gloomy lyrics
>Negroid excesses in tempo
>dark instincts alien to the German people (so-called riffs)
ironically sounds like a lot of extreme metal

>
youtube.com/watch?v=z8O2ToQ_Dok

youtube.com/watch?v=Ux_j06K-4_Q

Did I upset jew?

nice bait

You tell me.

Haha, good one

youtube.com/watch?v=GPzvcBFHnI0

>nazis can't make good mus-

lmao

>you can't make good art without empathy
>I cant find empathy with people who want to preserve their country's history and culture therefore they are lower than me
That's pretty fucking pathetic of you m8.
>shitty uninspired punk music
Lol you have fucking terrible taste.

Nico made great music

...

I feel sad for the far-right.

Not being able to make any meaningful art must suck : )

check these digits

no, it's these

23 is strange

>he hasn't read Sun and Steel

Shostakovich was antifascist
so were 90% composers

Leftits here

Nico was a right wing racist, Moe Tucker likes Tea Party and Lou Reed called Bob Dylan a "fucking kike devoid of talent", and the produced some of the most influential songs in the last 60 years

If you are talking about antifa now, the answer is no. But there're a lot great artist that were anti-fascism.

There is a difference between Antifascist and the whiney trust-punks that call themselves "antifa."

Mmm, he was forced into being a tool for the government and couldn't freely speak his mind like he'd wanted to. In either case I imagine he meant it in a more contemporary sense like antifa.

He's a medium-tier composer anyway. Has nothing on Stravinsky and Wagner.

>antifa
ever hear of this genre called "punk"? check it out

Burzum is pretty good so yeah

black metal is to music what video games are to art

Leftists denounce the idea of right-wing art because they're afraid to acknowledge the humanity of those whose ideology is in contrast to their own. It's a measly and pathetic self-defense technique that's all too common from the mental cowards on the left.

>but dont you THINK THAT KLJGHFDSKJFHDKSJHFDSFDS

You're utterly braindead Sal

The Templars are SHARP senpai they had black members.

>black metal
>bad

Go back to listening to Vektor and Pantera you nu-male

you shouldn't close your ears to dissent, you should welcome it.
put your shiny ideology to the side for a second and actually think about what you're saying next time.

>YOU'RE the real nazis!!!1

v

Is this the Nazi art thread?

All of the people in that picture are worm food collecting mud dust :^)

unless of course you're totally convinced your position is the correct one and nothing outside of it can exist in which case you're textbook brainwashed and i feel very sorry for you

Sure

So are your great-grandparents. What's your point?

sal... nazis are bad... okay?

As opposed to the honorable far right who advocate literal genocide of those whose ideologies/race/faith don't match their own.

i agree
doesn't mean you should be selectively critical

>1488
heh
and no, that's not the "opposition," as it's not just left vs. right.

so much ordnung, it's beautiful

Arghoslent is pretty great band if your into that style of metal.

Joy Division, Though completely overrated and hated for their shitty fanbase, Made some pretty decent music.

>Lou Reed called Bob Dylan a "fucking kike devoid of talent", and the produced some of the most influential songs in the last 60 years
...which one had a Nobel again?

t. lead singer in a punk band that is going nowhere and/or coffee shop India ink """artist"""

seems to me the left is going down the tube

more and more music and underground people are realizing that it's cool to be far right and they dont care what the leftists in their community think

kek... CNN a gigantic corporate entity is now the "underdog" of the left wing

funny stuff

right wing music is no doubt the future

What I don't understand is why people come to Sup Forums of all places if they're going to get triggered. Do people secretly enjoy getting triggered? Like a Masochistic type of thing?

One word: Germs

"it's cool to be far right"

Of course, triggered has long stopped having anything to do with traumatic things causing a mental breakdown. It's all about finding something to be self-righteously annoyed about. It is why people enjoy rollercoasters to be scared and people enjoy the feeling that the world is shit, out to get them or going to hell because people are doing things they don't agree with.

>insert alt right is new punk rock meme

Why are Germans so autistic

left wing:
-CNN is cool!
-Beyonce is cool!
-JK Rowling is cool!
-SNL is cool
-Reddit is cool!
-Clinton is cool!
-SJWs are cool!
-A Tribe Called Quest is cool! They called him an orange!!

Hey, looks like a bunch of very old, out of touch, unfunny, lame, sellout crap! Or outdated played out hip hop! Or corporate media garbage that became evil 10 years ago but suddenly... is considered leftist... heh

right wing:
-Youtube is cool!
-Sup Forums is cool!
-Burzum is cool!
-Alex Jones is cool!
-Milo Y is cool!
-Sam Hyde is cool!

Hey, looks like new technologies and ideas and the cutting edge of thinking instead of unfunny old TV shows that are only relevant to 60 year old women who still watch TV!

Oh, I forgot all the hipsters who circle jerk on Facebook about how "evil Trump" is - guess what faggots, even that isn't cool anymore. You all have nothing going for you and you don't even realize it anymore!

Artists with right-wing beliefs can make good music, just look at hip-hop or country. There are a few good fash novelists and composers but this new wave of far-right shit will never produce anything except memes. These goons cry all day about postmodernism ruining art but know nothing except vidya and a few .jpegs of paintings from the 1800s for online argument purposes. I'll never forget the guy I saw on Stormfront who wanted to get his child into the beautiful white tradition of classical music to immunise them from degenerate art, but couldn't think of any Western art music to show to his child except Brahms's Lullaby. A lot of reactionaries want to quash everything not tot their liking in the world of art but don't know anything about what came before and are incapable of making anything to come after.

Sup Forums and youtube are new technologies only liked by the cool right wing? But facebook is old tech? Is you mind really this rotted pasta of stupidity, think you've had too much 'experimental' Sup Forums.

>National-socialism
Richard Strauss (1864–1949)
Wilhelm Furtwängler (1886–1954)
Carl Orff (1895–1982)
Herbert von Karajan (1908–1989)

>Fascism
Pietro Mascagni (1863–1945)
Francesco Cilea (1866–1950)
Umberto Giordano (1867–1948)
Franco Alfano (1876–1954)
Ottorino Respighi (1879–1936)
Francesco Balilla Pratella (1880–1955)
Ildebrando Pizzetti (1880–1968)
Gian Francesco Malipiero (1882–1973)
Alfredo Casella (1883–1947)
Luigi Russolo (1885–1947)
Giorgio Federico Ghedini (1892–1965)
Luigi Dallapiccola (1904–1975)
Goffredo Petrassi (1904–2003)

Are you trying to tell me all punk is made by antifa? Good one. Maybe you never listened to Oi! or RAC? Are you going to convince me those aren't punk because they don't support your ideals?

punk is inherently left-wing

right-wing "punk" is by definition not punk

>new technologies and ideas and the cutting edge of thinking
Sup Forums, for the most part, is stupid and has always been stupid
Burzum is the RuneScape soundtrack reinterpreted by a man who worships trees
Alex Jones is a cynical huckster who sells lizard people stories to guillible paranoids
Milo is a bizarre laughing stock
Sam Hyde is an irony-poisoned Something Awful vet who preaches about masculinity and truth despite being Sam Hyde

It's boring establishment shit versus incredibly stupid anti-establishment shit, none of it is good

I've started noticing that the most loud, proud, and excited left wingers who are buying into the left right now are like 40-60 year old people who used to be relevant

I mean yeah they used to be cool but every great group has to become lame as fuck sooner or later

>Reddit
>Left wing
Have you ever been there? It's even more demented than Sup Forums.

By the way if you think that Beyonce is left wing you know nothing about politics

Ideologically it would be empty-muzak examplar of elder stage capitalism, regardless of quality of tune.

Are you seriously using some fucktarded Nobel Prize in Literature to justify Dylan? Nigger they hand Nobels out like McDonalds Happy Meals now. Even Dylan didn't have a clue why they decided to award him, what a pathetic non argument.

Says who?
Sid Vicious wore a swastika shirt, should we call the anitfa?!? Might be nazis, I think we should shut their show down using terrorist methods.

>trendy corporate capitalist icons like Beyoncé and le Harry Potter woman
>left wing

read a book

Is this the new Ruby Ridge for you shook bitches

rofl 90% of punks with nazi memorabilia back then were just being edgy

"alex jones is cool!"
Sup Forums is for 18+ users only

>What is shock value

god you fucking dolt, the pistols were using it to shock old establishment British nationalists who jerked off about saving the world during WWII

If you think a junky anarchist like vicious has anything to do with someone like Paul Joseph Watson you're dull

>muh true leftism

Bravo user. Bravo

J.K. Rowling hates Corbyn and loves Tony Blair
Not really a great example of a leftist

>I know I'll use memes to hide my illiteracy

americans were a mistake. if you think the democrats and billionaire identitarian corporatists in any way reflect the ideology of Marx, Hegel, Zizek, Derrida, etc. you're just showing off your lack of education and brainwashing into the capitalist machine.

...

Communism > feudalism > capitalism

Those are not good examples of leftist thinkers brother

Capitalism is sekrit feudalism don't tell anyone

>muh French enlightenment

go away, neoliberal capitalist

as is my grandfather who was a guard at the nuremburg trials. what's your point

Only correct answer in this thread.