ITT: Overrated Albums
ITT: Overrated Albums
John Miller
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Robert Evans
Wrong
Sebastian Cox
...
Caleb Bennett
...
Camden Morales
desu.
Jaxon Long
Evan Cox
agree
disagree
Austin Torres
AJFA patrician Metallica
Scary Monsters patrician Bowie
Christian Hughes
any new swans, really
Dylan Jenkins
Agree. By far.
Jaxson Hill
tru. never saw the appeal of JD
Andrew Davis
...
Jacob Rodriguez
>It's an user doesn't like any Bowie that isn't Ziggy thread
Lucas Smith
Souvlaki
What a heap of shit.
Jason Wood
Ryder Williams
good drummer is about all I can say
Andrew Hill
Overrarted shite.
Austin Nelson
Untrue.
I love Berlin and Soul/Funk Bowie. I even think TMWSTW is leagues ahead of Hunky Dory.
Angel Clark
How come?
Mason King
you just aren't depressed enough
Joshua Jackson
Closer is objectively a better album
Cameron Long
Daniel Myers
...
Daniel Stewart
i dont get it
James Mitchell
and this one too
Charles Morgan
Posts like this are what ruin Sup Forums.
This is objectively true.
Brandon Torres
The Powers That B is better in my opinion.
Adrian Lopez
it's bottom tier as far as classic shoegaze goes for me, Pygmalion's better
Ayden Jones
Im a Depeche Mode fan who agrees. It's good, but it not the best record of the fucking 80's.
Matthew Perez
Easton Johnson
...
Levi Foster
Agreed. But be prepared for autistic screeching.
Jonathan Mitchell
Shaking The Habitual is objectively head and shoulders better than Silent Shout.
t. Someone who flew to Iceland just to see their final live show at the Harpa center.
Levi Bell
delet this
overrated as fuck
Zachary Rogers
>the closest rock has ever come to successfully integrating classical elements
>overrated
Camden Bailey
>le tibet throat singing over random ambience
>good
pick one
Brandon Miller
...
Tyler Johnson
Ok, how about
>good
That was easy.
Adam Turner
Eli Diaz
nah the glowing man was fucking fantastic
Justin White
I get irritated every time I see someone think they're patrician for preferring this to lysf. It's better than lysf but it's overrated, 4th best GY!BE album.
Evan Torres
wrong
Charles Howard
all true. none necessarily terrible but all overrated
Jason Taylor
...
Joshua King
This on the other hand is super underrated, it's because niggerthony faggotano gave it a 6/10 so people think it's their worst project.
Julian Wilson
I've been shilling that lately, I'm glad to see more people approving of it.
Ryan White
I want to say I agree, because going through the Sup Forumscore this one never clicked with me. I could be wrong, so I might give it another listen.
Liam Hughes
yawn! fucking hell mate it appears you've triggered me.
Ethan Ross
itt: Sup Forumscore
Andrew Smith
>tfw you agree with every album posted so far.
Eli Ross
Noah Peterson
...
Brayden Adams
I used to think they were overrated for several years, but in the past year, they've suddenly grown on me so much. Souvlaki is actually a perfect album to me now, while Unknown Pleasures is ridiculously close to perfect.
Eli Brooks
Oliver Rodriguez
Any album that's ever been on a critics top 100 list.
Jack Bailey
Nathaniel Cox
Blasphemy
James Kelly
Jonathan Harris
this is only overrated by Fantano, I rarely see people rate it as their favourite DG album on here.
Niggas on the Moon is their best full stop. I can take or leave Jenny Death though.
Jaxon Stewart
Yeah. I mean, it's pretty good but the artwork is trendy and the music is post-punk 101, not to mention Closer shits on it when you get over how it doesn't have all the iconic songs.
Uniroinically one of my all-time favorite albums and I never see people talk about it. It's acclaimed but rarely acknowledged it seems, it's always Turn Loose The Swans this and The Dreadful Hours that around here especially.
Agreed, I've only heard the run of albums from Black Celebration to Songs of Faith and Devotion but of the lot I liked Violator the least.
Nah, this is legit some next level shit for improvisational rock. This is the kind of shit post-rock should've grew more into.
This is the one GY!BE release that I've never really been able to get into. I can even fuck with Yanqui but I dunno, this one just doesn't quite hit home for me. Can't quite put my finger on why.
Jose Barnes
Not only are you wrong, but also a homosexual
Grayson Russell
I almost feel like there's some joke that I'm not in on when I see people talk about this album.
Colton Reed
the album is a joke, kanye has been on decline since 808's, his lyrics get worse with each release and this is just a rubbish experiment, Hold My Liquor, Black Skinhead and New slaves are the only good tracks
Luke Allen
I agree about the tracks except switch Hold My Liquor with On Sight - I think it's the one time the album's supposed rawness and energy actually manages to come through. But I do still like 808's and MBDTF, the former in particular being my favorite album of his. His lyrics have definitely gotten worse with the last two, though TLOP still had Real Friends out of fucking nowhere.
Grayson Stewart
Idk why you're demeaning Yanqui, it's easily one of their strongest works. The only one that handily surpasses it is Asunder; Slow Riot falls between slightly better and slightly worse, but it's such a short piece that I feel it's an injustice to put it above Yanqui.
Brody Edwards
Nigga you need to chill
Brandon Diaz
I didn't really demean it, but in my experience it is the GY!BE album that's most commonly put down, definitely moreso than F# and certainly the absolute last contender for an overrated GY!BE record. Well, maybe nowadays that's Asunder or Allelujah but I think it's all good regardless. F# is the only one I've got some issues with.
Dominic Ward
Alright, it's fine. I've had the opposite issue with F#. When I first listened to it I adored it, but the more times I've gone through the album, and the more time I've put into listening to the rest of GY!BE's discography, the less affected I have been by listening to it. The drone sequences aren't as interesting as Asunder's, and aside from those it feels to me to be a slightly better Allelujah (or more specifically, Mladic). It has some really exciting passages but as a whole I'd rather listen to some of their other stuff. Want to go into a bit more detail on what you thought of it? I'd be interested to hear
Benjamin Turner
ill kill u
good bait tho
Dominic Hughes
Not really much to say on my end, I've given it a couple of tries and it failed to make much of an impact. I do recall feeling like it marginally got better as it progressed but I'd have to sit down with it again to recall any specific details. It's one of those albums I just have a hard time remembering much of anything about.
Brody Scott
Definitely, I find this album a lot more tedious than a lot of his other works.
Agree, Closer is superior in every aspect, great album in the respects that Morris was the only proficient instrumentalist, though from an objective point of view it's very overrated.
I disagree with this one, its great through and through.
I agree to some extent, I find it the most enjoyable Death Grips album though its one of few albums where I find one can burn out on it if they listen to it too many times.
I think you could argue every Beatles album, let's be honest.
Used to think that, though it really does hold up if you listen to the individual sound layers, getting a good headset and playing at high volume is very important to the enjoyment of this album. That being said I wouldn't consider it the best shoegaze album.
Oliver Jones
yes, but its like a gateway drug
Gavin Flores
Ok computer
Noah Jones
These are great
Please no post
Thank you
Julian Wood
They'll never top NLDW