Well, Sup Forums?

well, Sup Forums?

wot

Stop it.

Both are great films.

I love both, but I've got to give it to The Thing.

The Thing

Hands down

What's the question OP?

You just posted a picture of 2 movie and asked "Well?"

How in the living fuck are we meant to know what you talk about?

I don't really get why everyone likes The Thing so much

Evil Dead isn't even as good as its sequel.

This is tough.

The Thing obviously outclasses Evil Dead in the production department, but I can't help but feel a little for the underdog. I've read Bruce's book "If Chins Could Kill" and I know how hard a couple of young kids had to work to make their dream come true.

It's tough. In that regard, I'd say they're almost incomparable to me. I love both movies dearly.

characters
dialogue
acting
plot
practical effects
atmosphere

I dunno either

Actually, I just thought of a way to sum up my feelings:

The Thing for the art, Evil Dead for the heart.

Thing hands down

The first Evil Dead isn't that good.

I mean, it's good but it really doesn't reach my feelungs

This

This

>Had remakes where the protagonist was changed to be a girl?

I love Evil Dead more but The Thing is the better movie. Sam Raimi was just getting his feet wet while Carpenter was in his goddamn prime.

I don't want to choose, fuck off op

>thinking feels are the most important aspect of a movie
Any movie can kill a puppy and make you feel. It isn't hard to manipulate people's emotions.

personally I preferred the evil dead, but I could see why you'd choose the thing.