ITT: Overrated Albums

...

>pic unrelated

>pic semi-related

How come? I think it's overrated because it's way too light and poppy. I don't understand why Changes gets praised, I think Life on Mars? is too "grand" and dramatic, I think Kooks is shit. The only enjoyable song is Quicksand

>this is what passes for critique on Sup Forums

this album fucking sucks ass,

Ziggy Stardust is a 7.8/10
Young Americans was by far his best record at the time, fight me.

>it's not valid because i don't agree with it

I remember when I was a child

Station to Station is his best

I think it's the wide arrange of styles that makes it great and although it might be a little poppy it's not that light. I also think most albums need a cheery, "goofy" song like Kooks (Or Octopus' Garden or Doctor Robert)

>Ziggy Stardust is a 7.8/10
That edge cuts hard

Without Kooks it's a 10

young americans is his worst 70s album

It is light and poppy, it's too friendly, sweet, and flamboyant.

Why do people hate on silly songs like Kooks and Octopus' Garden

OK Computer

Come at me

The only part of Hunky Dory I hate is the part at the end of The Bewlay Brothers. "Lay me place and bake me pie" etc. It's just grating. Otherwise, it's a really amazing album. Not his best, but it deserves its classic status.

Because it's bad and shouldn't be on the album?

It's just fun, goddammit. Who cares if it's not up there with his sprsrsbizniz songs?

Well I don't find it fun, it's an extra heavy dose of cheese right in my lap along with the rest of this album

Wrong, Hunky Dory is the only David Bowie album that isn't overrated.

Kooks is one of the best songs on the album

it's true though

it's just a shitty sgt peppers clone

lmao

This

>this is what beatlefags actually believe

embarrasing

earthling best

...

...

...

This album

STOP comparing the vile squirt of cum that is Octopus' Garden with Kooks, a legitimately good song

What a fucking awful opinion

:/

Agree

...

as well as my pecka

I'll raise you a Kid A

this and self titled

his ""soul"" period is horrendous, an insult to Black music & Rock

Agree completely
It's like a 7/10
I used to think I was missing something but now I've come to the conclusion that there's a mass conspiracy to get me to obsess over some slightly above average alt rock

Are you including Station To Station when you say that?

inb4 autistic faggots who should have been aborted and edgy teenagers

Amen. Fuck slint.

agreed, both hunky dory and ziggy stardust are like 5 /10 for me.

How do you determine tenths of a point and how did you conclude that Ziggy Stardust has eight of those tenths past a score of 7? Why not a 7.7 or a 7.9?

This is the level of autism we are dealing with.

:(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((

...

Pleb detected

every bowie, beatles, Biggie smalls, eminem, radiohead, jay z, post 60's pink floyd album ever

properly rated
>Young Americans was by far his best record at the time, fight me.
cool, an actual retard
agreed, and i love the radioheads
slightly
no
probably, but i love it
fuck off
the only reason i've seen this album for the last few days is faggots like you saying this shit
no

BOI if you wanna talk about a little bit overrated let's talk about the Ziggy Stardust album

p i n u p s