is Shine On You Crazy Diamond proto-post-rock?
Is Shine On You Crazy Diamond proto-post-rock?
Short answer - no
Long answer - no
Its prog. That's it.
No, but this is
This thread is retarded
Post-rock isn't a real genre
ur retarded
gottem boys
No.
Even this, , is a better answer.
even more retarded than OP
I love retarded threads like these.
but I'm not talking about WYWH as a whole, I'm talking about the track Shine On You Crazy Diamond, specifically the first part
Is this proto-post-grunge?
me on the right
haha your on fire
woah
>proto-post
are you trolling?
those cancel each other
that's not how genres work
alright your official the most retarded guy now
more than also more than
It's dad rock at best
no one actually answered the question yet
explain to me how SOYCD doesn't resemble post-rock
No, it's English Kosmische Musik/ Krautrock.
even quads cant save you from your faggotry
>proto: first; anterior; relating to a precursor
>post: subsequent to; after
genre tags aren't literal
Just having a slow buildup at the start doesn't make it post-rock, dumbass. Once the song properly gets going it's just a normal prog track.
The "post" in post-rock, actually comes from post-minimalism, a completely unrelated tradition, gaylord.
>words dont mean what they mean
hehehe prented to be retard epic :)
it's not just the slow buildup. it has a melancholic and ethereal ambience that reminds me a lot of stuff from the first wave of post-rock like Talk Talk
I also never claimed it was post-rock, I just implied it inffluenced the genre
post-rock is a genre
proto-post-rock is an informal term meaning, "this song was written 20 years before post-rock became a thing but it bears many resemblances to the genre"
No, the word post is a shortened version of the "post-minimalism" of Philip Glass and Steve Reich.
I personally dislike the term as it seems kinda pretentious, "chamber rock", or "minimal rock", would just make more sense honestly, but whatever.
is Antennas to Heaven post-proto-post-rock?
Is Piper at the Gates of Dawn proto-proto-post-rock?
well, it's def music
technically yes
Moonchild is THE first post rock track
I know.
No, it's post-proto-grunge
id say its closer to prog rock
No, its a pop song with a free improv track attached to the end.
Who gives a fuck just listen to it, does your opinion on something change after you listen to it because you find out it wasn't in your favourite genre? Fucking plebs
no but it's interesting to discuss influences and stylistic origins of different music genres
It's proto-art-pop
so... funk?
it's an insult to Pink Floyd to call them post rock
More like an insult to post rock