Times when Scaruffi was right

Times when Scaruffi was right

He was right about these dubs

...

opbp. Also with Good being the best Morphine album.

Why is it dat good?

...

except for those that are higher than 5.5

pic unrelated

why doesn't he like it?

Why would he?

Holy shit is he deaf?

*tips*

nah
bowie was always mediocre

finally, some bowie ratings i can get behind

obligatory
OK Computer is too high though

How can anyone sincerely feel that The Bends isn't an improvement over Pablo Honey?

...

it's the same shit except for on Bends they've got a more 'serious' image, and Scaruffi doesn't review image

>Kid A the same rating as Pablo Honey
Wew lad

Disgusting

...

yeah, that's exactly what I think about radiohead fans

>it's disgusting to not consider an artist's image in music reviews

radioheadfags are really the worst

How is Loveless better than every Radiohead and Beatles album?

>a mediocre album has the same rating as another mediocre album
what's wrong with that?

>How is pop album better than some other pop albums?
Loveless was more interesting, since it was more innovative

stop

>innovative

Wow scaruffidrones actually believe this?

>stop expressing your opinions
go back to you can downvote opinions over there

and how wasn't it not innovative?

This would be right if mbv was rated higher, 7/10 atleast

why?

>quirky guitar effects
>innovative
How is it more innovative than OK Computer or Sgt. Pepper?

nom nom nom

He's not wrong.

Just because there was a 22 years gap doesn't mean that the album should be bad. With mbv they had free hand instead of being on a label. I still like loveless more, but mbv has more darker sound, and it still manages to keep it's pop roots.

>quirky guitar effects and production can't be innovatine
who told you that?

>OK Computer
same as Loveless, but released 6 years after and way less quirky

>Sgt. Pepper
how is any psych pop album of the 60s innovative?

>5 = bad
ok...

5 isn't bad, it's average, and mbv deserves higher score than average

nah he really wasn't

>an average shoeagaze album deserves higher score than average just because that band made some great music in the past
ok...

true, he was shit

>Pablo honey better than In Rainbows
>Amnesiac and OK Computer tied for best
Holy shit this guy is out of his mind

shoegaze*

...

But I'm just expressing my opinion!

that's fine, but radioheadfags are more welcome on there than on Sup Forums

>I'm just gonna say things that aren't true and hope I'm talking to a newfag

>implying it wasn't true
sure you aren't new

>how is any psych pop album of the 60s innovative?
The Doors

it's psych rock

oh didnt read the pop part

I agree with scaruffis rating of everything from OKC onwards but you know that Radiohead is Sup Forumscore and the majority of the board still think they're the most amazing band of the last 20 years

>majority of the board
[citiation needed]

look at any muchart (there was recently a popular voting for favourite album on mu and OKC ended up Top 4 or so) or go into any 3x3 thread/etc. I was at that point too, Radiohead are a good introduction to music

Absolute shit opinions everywhere

>look at any muchart (there was recently a popular voting for favourite album on mu and OKC ended up Top 4 or so)
death grips and grimes are also considered Sup Forumscore but it's been confirmed that there lots of samefaggotry about these artists on Sup Forums, how do you know radiohead is not similar?

>go into any 3x3 thread/etc
literally /normie/ general as well as all the chart threads
there are lots of people that aren't normalfags, they just dont visit such threads, and don't use music as fashion

This needs to be investigated

the only way it isnt better if you have immature taste and mistake lyrical concepts / lyrical resonance for musical quality

>immature taste
Massive Kek. As if you are more mature for listening to whiny vocals drowned in flashy reverb and simple pop hooks.
Mbv is trash

...

>simple as a criticism
immature taste. . . .

He likes it you plebs, never actually read a scaruffi review have you

>every of the tmes

jesus christ why do people actually listen to this man, his reviews are clearly shitposts

there is absolutely no way that Pablo Honey should be equal to Kid A and higher than In Rainbows

this is objective fact and anyone who has listened to the albums, even people who aren't Radiohead fans, should understand this

Holy shit I know of this guy but never actually looked into his reviews. I legit don't agree with anything that's been posted here

>this is objective
funny way to discard your own opinion

How many albums have you listened overall?

Obviously much less than him, but I'm not saying I'm more experienced or more correct than he is

...

...

...

his website is too dense to navigate, the basic web format really does it

Couldn't agree more about a Significant Other.

no way this is real

...

wtf i hate scaruffi now!

why this surprised but not this ?

...

Sorry Divers, Scaruffi is right

>8.5
Holy shit.

didn't you see the rubber soul dubs thread
kek has btfo scaruffi

>a limp bizkit album got the same rating as sgt pepper and abbey road

if you think that loveless is quirky guitar effects I seriously hope youre not pursuing a career in music

...

I like scaruffi and stuff, but his contrarian spirit has gone full autistic on this one; if he only gave 5 or less to pablo honey these ratings would have made a little more sense

HOLY FUCK!!!

YES! But honestly should've been an 8.

>Blackstar
>4/10
disgusting

I never got why Pablo Honey is hated, but Bends is praised. Is this just a meme everyone fell to?
Those albums aren't that different.

you're going to forget about that album in a few years and realize how right scruffles was.

I don't like Scaruffi, but his Bowie rating are correct

it's just cool to hate Pablo Honey
in fact it's just as mediocre as most of their stuff

...

d i s r e g a r d e d

I'm sure you've heard that album all the way through and didn't let yourself be biased towards thinking Limp Bizkit is a bad band because of what your peers all regurgitate, r-right?

I still cant get over the fact he gave that shitty BTBAM album a 8

...

Give Kid A an 8.0 and Pablo Honey a 5.5 and it's pretty accurate.

(OK Computer used to be a 7.5 before he changed it recently by the way)