Starting a new trend. We rate our favourite Musicians

Starting a new trend. We rate our favourite Musicians.
Here's the template

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/edmDN11BxCY?t=42s
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

I'll start, here's Yeezy

objective

>we rate our favorite musicians
>grimes

Seems about right

Here's Deaner

...

...

I would give him 5 stars considering he writes half of them, or at least is half of a songwriting duo.

...

>Creativity not a 10 and Personality not a 9

Also, autism is probably more like a 6

...

Why production skill only a 5?

user, you're supposed to rate your FAVORITE musician. Not yourself in the guise of your least favorite musician.

>Robert "ARE YOU PIRATING MY ALBUM" Fripp
>Music isn't on Spotify
>Didn't even allow King Crimson on iTunes until a couple years ago
>Only slightly a cunt

Sick burn! That user, BTFO!

Only some of King Crimson's work is produced by the band (and is credited to the whole band) and some of it sounds a bit shit (court specifically).
Fripp and Eno is probably leaning on Eno's side of production.
LOG is produced by Fripp I guess but it also sounds a bit shit at times.
Most of of his work sounds fine, but he doesn't strike me as a master of production.
that's why he has a 9 in autism, although maybe he deserves a bit more on the cuntometer fer that time he yelled at the audience and kept it on a studio album.

He writes the music/piano parts, not the lyrics.

Ok, I mean I don't know who was behind it, but I wouldn't rate the production on Red anything less than a 10.

Sounds like it came out 15 years into the future.

Need more english Artists

Anyone up for Aussie Artists?

...

Only a bit of a cunt? Isn't he a walking vagina?

you can't argue with this

I don't think that autism is high enough. The guy is basically rainman

...

Needs more stars on personality desu

The world's biggest cunt

Singing should be a solid 6. Instrumental skill should be 7. Lyrics a 5. Creativity a 7. Autism a 9

needs more singing and lyrics

how is his singing a 6? that's ridiculous man, go listen to Nude

>singing that low when Heroes exists
>lyrics that low

...

>.jpg
what de fuck

I agree

Do over

accurate but i think the autism is too high

...

...

...

kill yourself

...

lel

if you read Byrne's blog you'd realize he's actually a huge cunt

...

lyrics should be higher

damn I haven't read it. I haven't really even seen many interviews of him I just figured he was alright.

makes sense i guess

...

Singing is waaaaay too low. I'd give him at least a 7. 3 is well below average. Come on now.

...

...

While I don't necessarily mind his singing or his voice, he had a very limited range and wasn't really capable of anything other than the one voice he always used. I'm not basing that ranking on how much I like or don't like it, but just his ability.

...

...

...

Bjork scores pretty high on everything.


lol

accurate

Singing and lyrics should be lower

Singing and instrument skills should be alot lower, Playing like shit is apart of his charm.
Autism should be higher

die immediately

...

Singing too high. C'mon, he's not THAT good of an instrumentalist. Lyrics should be a 2 ("Xbox is a god to me"). Personality too high.

...

This is perfect except production should be low. He was unable to produce his own albums

He's a decent singer in my opinion
He has a lot of cringeworthy lines, but he's not that bad lyricist

Bjork... a 10 in singing? Are you shitting me

>singing that low

>waifufag
opinion discarded

If I had it any higher there would multiple posts about how shit her singing.

I love her singing, but the first time I heard it I thought she was super annoying. I think a 6-7 is perfect for unconventional singers that are an aquired taste.

Bjork should be on the same level as Joanna, for singing.

...

No I am not kidding.
Bjork, Elizabeth Fraser and Nico are the 3 greatest female vocalists of all time. Explain why I am wrong.

Just because someone posts something regarding Bjork doesn't mean its automatically waifu shit. All waifufags are annoying because they never discuss music.

Singing, lyrics and personality are too low imo

What if she is my favorite musician and I hate music?

Fuck off Grimes

Then you wouldn't be posting on /mu.

autism a 10

FAT

UGLY

How do you know?

>too contrarian to enjoy bold, powerful vocals - the post

DEAD

...

I'd prefer a 5 star system but whatever

I thought he was from Cornwall or some shit?

...

agreed

suck a pen15

Is this you explaining why I am wrong?
Try using green text another time.

Bjork's voice is THE MOST powerful and dynamic. The uniqueness of her voice is something nobody can deny.
youtu.be/edmDN11BxCY?t=42s

...

>singing that high

Why is his autism not maxed out?

>no sitting skills

...

Bjork is like Grimes. They're not praised because they're the only ones who can produce the music they produce, but rather because they're the only ones who do. I can really get into Joanna and other unique voices but I just don't see anything special about Bjork other than her exotic accent.

>panera bread not maxed out

...

...

is there any artist who would have every field maxed out?

Dan Barrett or Zach Hill would both be close desu

>bit of a cunt
>10
Why?

Or Jeff Mangum

this is fun

This takes me back to my Backyard Baseball 2003 days. Good times

Nice trips.

He's not a producer, he's a recording engineer. His "production" style is to do next to nothing at all to the raw recordings.

>comparing bjork to grimes
Man you completely lost me.
This comparison is totally unwarranted and does nothing to support why bjorks voices isn't great. You are totally off subject.

Also, I think grimes doesn't make good music or even have a good or unique voice, not like it has anything to do with bjork. Her voice is nothing like bjorks what so ever.