Hey Sup Forums Lets start a We Rate Musicians Thread

Use This Template and post rating of musicians

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=SPuVy65V1uQ&t=320s
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

...

grimefu fags btfo

exactly 61 seconds between posts (cool down time)

2 / 1 / 2 / 2

...

no cool down on threads

grimefu fags btfo dawg

That image makes me physically sick.

there aren't cool downs between starting threads and posting lad

How do you make these?

MS Paint

right

BTFO
T
F
O

...

actually accurate

I'm sure lots of you will disagree

It's 8 across the board besides the obvious 10 for lyrics

okay musician but really nice person

the one and only

her instrumental skill should be 6 or 7, other than that yep pretty much this.

i guess i underrated her, shes kinda good at guitar, but not exceptional

Wanna start listening to his stuff. Where do i start?

Purest Feeling demos, then go chronological through the major releases, if you enjoy try out the halos in between. Listen to him evolve over 28 years

Pretty Hate Machine followed by Year Zero.

You think the demos are the best place to start? imo it's interesting to hear what it could have been but it's too raw to get a good idea of what made him NIN

It's an important first step in the development of what would become PHM and his early to mid 90's sound nineties sound. You really get a full display of how much Depeche Mode influenced him, and then moving on to PHM you see him crafting his own sound.

youtube.com/watch?v=SPuVy65V1uQ&t=320s

...

...

>production skills 9/10
lmao

...

what does autism even mean anymore

...

bump

bmup

instead of bumping why dont you try making one you fucking nigger

I made the MF DOOM one. kek

...

...

Cunt should be AT LEAST 9 for Fripp. Have you heard of how hard it is to work with the guy?

...

...

I'd put more on the cunt-o-meter because he's infamous for now showing up on his own shows

this and his lyrics are def not 9/10

bump

his singing should be a 7

Have you ever listened to his "singing"? He doesn't sing, he yells out

I'd give her lyrics another star, other than that I agree
Production too high, autism too low
Cunt need to be higher
singing should be higher

yes i have, yeah he shouts sometimes, have you listened to two headed boy part 2?

...

What a coincidence!

I'd put his creativity and instrumental skill a lot higher
I just want Blixa to rejoin the Bad Seeds :(
Apparently he was slated to perform on Push The Sky Away but it fell through or something

>I'd put his creativity and instrumental skill a lot higher
I totally forgot that he was a guitarist lmao
I agree, I'll fix

>I just want Blixa to rejoin the Bad Seeds :(
Same but at the same time I want him to tour with Neubauten and make new albums... I don't think Blixa would fit in that style of music what The Bad Seeds are doing at this moment. Nick said that Blixa had a huge influence on his music and without him leaving the band that band would've not evolve


>Apparently he was slated to perform on Push The Sky Away but it fell through or something
Yeah I heard the same

very correct

>Same but at the same time I want him to tour with Neubauten and make new albums
Me too, are they on hiatus or something? There last record was in 2014
>Nick said that Blixa had a huge influence on his music and without him leaving the band that band would've not evolve
I can see where he is coming from but Blixa was there for all the other transformations so it doesn't seem too far out of the realm of possibility for him to to fit into the groove of the current band's sound, I mean he was able to fit into their changes in sound before.

>Me too, are they on hiatus or something?
Idk, probably busy with tours. COME TO HELSINKI
>I mean he was able to fit into their changes in sound before.
Yeah you're probably right but question is would they turn again into more rougher stuff if Blixa comes back? I doubt but that would be cool

>tfw EN are doing one show in Australia and it is in fucking Tasmania (the small and almost empty southern island) feelsbadman
>turn again into more rougher stuff if Blixa comes back?
Although I like the minimal sound they have atm I would love for a more aggressive sound to make its way back into the Bad Seeds

Continue here

Yes chase

i mean he hasnt been spotted in almost 20 years now

Take Me To Your Leader is an entire album from the perspective of a rap collective of kaiju from Godzilla movies, he deserves at least a 7 in creativity because who else would do that? I mean sure plebs like Blue Oyster Cult may write a song about Godzilla but who besides DOOM would write a song about King Ghidorah?

...

>not 10 for every category but "Bit of a Cunt"

...

...

Instrumental should be at least a 5, and production is too low

>Phil Elverum
>Instrumental skill 8/10

More like 1/10, he fucks up so fucking much when he plays live, constantly loses rhythm and what not

Also
>Autism
probably somewhere around 7/10
Have you seen how he sometimes moves his head like he has tourettes?

I love Phil though

evry musician sings lol!

...

calm down

Where is FJM?

...

...

>bit of a cunt that low

Isn't Win considered a massive cunt by most people who know him?

does "songwriting skill" fall under instrumental or production or did you just forget about that very important aspect?

>Isn't Win considered a massive cunt by most people who know him?
i'm pretty sure there were loads of rumours coming out about how arcade fire were cunts a few years ago but they turned out to be bullshit made up by their friends. they seem like pretty nice people and Win seems cool and charitable and is good at basketball.

...

Nice, would have liked to see -ah on all categories-ah

...

...

Can't be arsed

>Instrumental skill not 10
>Lyrics not 10
>Creativity not 10

You're a dumb fuck.

Thom York

Singing 10
Instr 6
Prod 10
Lyrics 8
Creativity 9
Personality 5
Bit of a Cunt 6
Autism 6

>lyrics
>10

¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿

>personality 10
>bit of a cunt 3
¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿¿

Y'all suck dick

I'm sorry user, I was worried I was letting my Sufjan love show a bit too much so I toned it down.

...

Have you heard Efrim's lyrics in Silver Mt. Zion?

I'd switch creativity and personality but otherwise accurate
Way too inflated
His singing is better than 1 and production is in no way a fucking 9
Personality should be way higher since the guy literally has like 5 of them. Bit of a Cunt also higher.
Almost accurate but the guy is a total cunt
I'd lower the production and personality. Also raise autism to the max. He's literally the definition of autism
Wouldn't say his lyrics are 10. Raise the singing though
Pretty accurate
Instrumental higher and production way higher
Singing way lower. I don't think he plays any instruments or produces. Cunt and autism can be lowered. He's pretty normie
Very accurate

no idea who they are. are you posting yourselves?

she is super autistic have you heard any of her songs?

over-rating Jim O'Rourke is a hallmark of being autistic yourself

hilarious

most accurate one so far

sufjan is a massive cunt. source? Holland, Michigan, here

...

autism need to be 10 and it's good

Are you memeing?

Instrumental skill should be 3/10 he's just good enough to make records. Prod skill should be higher and autism should go up as well.

real yeezy chart

accurate as fuck

Production and instrumental skill should be higher and lyrics lower

kekkkk

...

Accurate desu
People will say "Bit of a Cunt" should be higher because of shit like when she attacked the reporter but if you actually hear her talk about it it kinda makes sense. She's really a sweetie.

Also singing should be 10 tho

His lyrics are not that bad. Maybe a 6/10

>Singing: 10
jesus christ

modest mouse is one of my favorite bands and i fucking love isaac but there is absolutely no way he's above a 5 at singing

also not a 10 at instrumental skill, though he is a pretty good guitarist

personality and autism should both be 10's as well. lyrics a bit higher also

as others said, cunt higher

instrumental lower, singing higher

singing is above average at least and instrumental skill should be at least a couple stars higher