How did a generic buttindie song make #3 of 2003?

How did a generic buttindie song make #3 of 2003?

Other urls found in this thread:

urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Landfill Indie
byrslf.co/have-you-encountered-the-softboy-7e95e2c7f3e7
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

can you provide further examples of "buttindie"

and number one

Maps is god tier

possibly my favorite song from the point in my life where I was just starting to get into music

Arcade Fire
Clap Your Hands Say Yeah

Maps was a pretty mainstream song back in the day, believe it or not

Honestly Maps may have been the catalyst that led to the term indie decaying into meaninglessness

o word ok

>Maps is god tier
This

>the catalyst that led to the term indie decaying into meaninglessness

No, that would be the rise of legitimate buttindie like Mumford & Sons, The Lumineers, etc. that attracted half-transitioned brocountry fans to the 'indie' genre.

It's way better than cash's hurt and i love the guy

>buttindie
The correct term is landfill indie idiot
And YYH are not landfill indie

Anything I don't like.

>Maps
It's weird how that song stand so much above the rest of their discography
Sort of like the Walkmen and the Rat

YYH are so-so but Maps definitely is

i can relate to way too much on this chart

Damn that pic takes me 10 years back

does Sup Forums hate Costello Music? I like it a lot

Hey, The Yeah Yeah Yeahs are pretty good and their drummer frequently plays avant-garde free jazz in the New York area.

Holy graphic design batman
I can't read any of the text on the side

>landfill indie
That will surely take off.

That's the point redditor

It has been a term for a while

le Blackhawks goal song

the real question is how is #1 in the top 100

Avant-garde drumming is bullshit. It's like, "Woo check this out I'm about to hit the drum, with the BACK of the stick! ooh look now I'm gonna hold the stick on the drum and hit the stick with the other stick! Uh oh look out how he's hitting the drum with his hands! Now he's hitting the drum with a cymbal! Now he's rubbing his dick on the drum! What a fucking genius!"

god it has been so long since i've heard talking of keane

normally these charts have like 1 or 2 bait albums but "landfill indie" definitely describes all of these

cyhsy is not butt indie, because then you're calling our bands like wolf parade. I would reserve butt indie for bands like matt pond pa

The singer has a generic buttindie girl voice. She was the worst part of The Seer.

>carry me ohio
>not duk koo kim

>not Salvador Sanchez
Real talk that album is a masterpiece

>summer Sup Forums is too young to know basic terms that were invented 10+ years ago
kys

urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Landfill Indie

So going off that list, "landfill indie" is basically guitar rock from the mid 2000's that you don't like, even though it's literally no different from the non-landfill indie of the same era, like Arctic Monkeys or The Strokes?

arctic monkeys have one okay album and the strokes one really good one and are both borderline landfill indie
you sound upset

its all landfill shit faggot. buttindie is shit thats cringy alt-maculinity like sun kil moon.

Correct posts.

What's "alt-maculinity [sic]"?

This chart is actually mostly good albums. Good stuff

people who pretend to be alternative but still support conservative ideologies use the word "bitch", brag about sexual encounters, expect women to fuck them because theyre "nice"--- ie people like sun kil moon guy im forgetting his name

So a softboy?
byrslf.co/have-you-encountered-the-softboy-7e95e2c7f3e7

faggot

*yawn*
is sun kil moon a 'nice guy'?
wow, what an insightful, incisive piece of writing. 'softboy's (ie, the guy's who know the wire is problematic) put on notice lmao.

wow this hits too close to home. great chart.

japandroids don't belong there

Literally everything I liked as a teenager hahaha

Good shit. I should listen to some of these again.

Eh I actually think there are a lot of songs by The Walkman just as good as The Rat, though that is an incredible song.

All indie is landfill indie. Prove me wrong.

in the new year is the walkmen's best song, and its not close

I don't think landfill indie is necessarily a pejorative, just like with dadrock. It's more of a meme and in this case it refers to a music scene.

japandroids and klaxons shouldn't be on here but the rest is pretty much on point

Foster the People and We Are Scientists had God-tier debut albums though.

How was Johnny Cash in the top 10

Feel-inducing swan song with a moving videoclip.

I don't even recognize a damn thing on this chart (apart from Pumped Up Kicks).

Two Door Cinema was posted on here all the time back in the day. I've never listened to it but I remember the album cover.
SHould I listen to it?

Listen to Tourist History. That one is great.

I only know 3 albums on this chart and I haven't even listened to them.
Imagine talking to some indie normie guy, he'd think you don't know shit about music

>She was the worst part of The Seer.
Agreed.

>All indie is landfill indie. Prove me wrong.
I can't.

Literally 15 year old me the chart

And by worst part I mean the only bad part.

Perfect