Pats: Brady, obviously Jest: Vinny Testaverde? Chad Pennington? Mark Sanchez? Bills: Jim Kelly Dolphins: Brian Griese? Bengals: Boomer Browns: Derek Anderson? Ravens: Flacco lmao Steelers: Terry Bradshaw Jags: Brunell Titans: McNair or Moon right? Colts: Pey-Pey, even though his best years with the Broncos Texans: Matt Schaub Chiefs: Joe Montana? Even though he was a shell of his former self, he took them to the playoffs Chargers: Rivers Broncos: Elway Raiders: Is it Carr already? or is Plunkett or Starr? Lot of room for debate here imo Giants: Has to be Eli now Cowboys: Aikman Redskins: Theisman? No idea desu Eagles: McNabb Panthers: Delhomme? Derek Anderson AGAIN lol? Saints: Brees Falcons: Ryan Bucs: Jameis already, right? Or is it Jeff Garcia or something? Don't really know Packers: Favre Lions: Stafford right? Bears: Cutlel? Or does McMahon get an honorary GOAT because the SB Viking: Favre again? Seahawks: Ruslel clearly Cardinals: Kurt Warner Rams: Kurt Warner 49ers: Montana
Any corrections? Discuss.
Austin Price
>Jets >Anyone but Namath
Brandon Rodriguez
>Panthers: Delhomme? Derek Anderson AGAIN lol? >implying it's not Jimmy "Pickles" Clauson
Benjamin Edwards
Cam is already the best QB in Panthers history tbqh.
Hunter Edwards
Idiocy.
rRaiders Stabler Chiefs Len Dawson Dolphins Marino Cowboys Staubach Chargers Fouts Almost every club in your list is wrong.
Jacob Evans
...
Juan Nelson
Fuck how did i forget Namath, good catch. Eh, Delhomme had more success than Cam so far.
Matthew Brooks
Tbqh a lot of it was questionable to inspire debate.
Plunkett had more superbowls than Stabler Totally spaced Marino, good call
Aikman won 3 superbowls, he's the GOAT of that franchise.
Fouts was great, especially for his time. But I feel you could argue Rivers
Lucas Edwards
Put Bernie Kosar or Otto Graham
Isaiah Evans
RAIDER QB POWER RANKINGS 1. Stabler 2. Gannon
POWER GAP 3. Lamonica 4. Plunkett 5. TYBCarr
POWER CHASM 6. Palmer 7. Hostetler 8. Schroeder 9. Jason Campbell
POWER VOID 10. Kerry Collins 11. Jeff George 12. Bruce Gradkowski
JESUS WEPT 1002. Charlie Frye 7084. Rick Mirer
ETERNAL DARKNESS 1x10^92. JaMarcus Russell
Grayson Diaz
>Aikman won 3 superbowls, True
>he's the GOAT of that franchise. Not even close.
Luis Rogers
Roethlisberger is better than Bradshaw
Carson Carter
was my boy PeyPey actually better than Unitas?
Isaiah Parker
But Cam has broken records Delhomme wishes he could. Cam also hasn't had a season as shit as some of Delhomme's.
Grayson Richardson
for the ravens? :^)
Jayden Morales
I would argue that Michael Vick was more of a franchise player for Atlanta than Matt Ryan is, but Matt Ryan is perhaps the better player?
Jaxon Murphy
Bobby Layne is the Lions'
If Stafford wins an owl he instantly is. But Layne won 3 NFL titles with Detroit and is a Hall of Famer.
Nolan Brooks
Bears is still Sid Luckman 4x Champ 5x all pro All decade team
Nolan Diaz
>Chiefs: Joe Montana?
YOUVE DISRESPECTED SMETH FOR THE LAST TIME
James Miller
> tfw 3 Hall of Fame quarterbacks
Feels good senpai
Juan Martinez
>Lions Yeah it is Stafford they didn't have any QBs between Layne and him.
Easton Bennett
>Dolphins: Brian Griese? really? >Chiefs: Joe Montana? Even though he was a shell of his former self, he took them to the playoffs might be a reach back but Len Dawson was great in his time >Panthers: Delhomme? Derek Anderson AGAIN lol? Cam will rebound with a 30~ total TD and 90+ passer rating season doesnt scream GOAT but I think he will take it >Bucs: Jameis already, right? Or is it Jeff Garcia or something? Don't really know Garcia but I like winstons chances >Packers: Favre maybe as of now but Rodgers is almost a lock to overtake him >Viking: Favre again? tarkenton obviously Favre > tark all time but if 1 great season makes you a franchise GOAT then Cunningham might have a say
David Mitchell
This list is so uneducated
It's sad!
Dominic Cooper
Dolphins is clearly Marino.
Browns is either Otto Graham or Bernie Kosar.
Steelers is Big Ben.
Chargers could be Fouts. It's debatable.
Raiders is Stabler without question.
Cowboys is Staubach (or maybe Romo).
Redskins could also be Sonny Jurgenson or even Sammy Baugh, but I'd go with Theismann
Panthers is unironically Cam.
Bucs is tough but I think Brad Johnson definitely takes it.
Packers is very difficult between Favre and Rodgers.
Lions is either Stafford or Bobby Layne.
Bears could be Cutler, could also be McMahon or Luckman.
Vikings is Tarkenton, although a case could be made for Culpepper.
Henry Ross
Some of these are good, but others are just contrarian for the sake of being contrarian.
Adrian Bell
>Marino yes >Graham or Kosar so Ravens, right? >Big Ben Bradshaw won 4 owls, nope >Fouts probably but Rivers is right there >Stabler agreed >Staubach No, it's Aikman >unironically Cam Unironically Delhomme >Brad Johnson So far, all Jameis has to do is be average or better for a decade to pass him though >Packers Definitely Favre >Tarkenton agreed
Dominic Fisher
>implying
OFFICIAL STARTING PANTHERS QB RANKING:
1. Jimmy Clausen 2. Kerry Collins 3. Brian St Pierre 4. Vinny Testaverde 5. Rodney Peete 6. Josh McCown 7. Matt Lytle 8. David Carr 9. Chris Weinke 10. Randy Fasani
Oh shit nigger-tier 11. Steve Beuerlein 12. Jake Delhomme
Swag fag-tier 13. Cam Newton
Xavier James
Manning is the GOAT. Dioporco
Noah Baker
>>Big Ben >Bradshaw won 4 owls, nope And roethlisberger owns literally every steelers franchise quarterback record along with two owls of his own
Joseph Jackson
delet this, I can't read half those names without wanting to kill myself
Delhomme was my QB growing up and for all his showboating and showmanship, I like Cam and think he'll do much better with a QB coach to fix his passing mechanic/footwork
Michael Cruz
Bills: Jim Kelly Dolphins: Dan Marino Patriots: Tom Brady Jets: Joe Namath Ravens: Joe Flacco Bengals: Boomer Esiason Browns: Otto Graham Steelers: Terry Bradshaw Texans: Matt Schaub Colts: Peyton Manning Jaguars: Mark Brunell Titans: Steve McNair Broncos: John Elway Chiefs: Len Dawson Chargers: Philip Rivers Raiders: Ken Stabler/Jim Plunkett Cowboys: Roger Staubach/Troy Aikman Giants: Eli Manning Eagles: Donovan McNabb Redskins: Joe Theismann Bears: Sid Luckman Lions: Bobby Layne Packers: Bart Starr/Brett Favre Vikings: Fran Tarkenton Falcons: Matt Ryan Panthers: Cam Newton Saints: Drew Brees Buccaneers: Vinny Testaverde/Brad Johnson Cardinals: Kurt Warner Rams: Kurt Warner 49ers: Joe Montana Seahawks: Russell Wilson
Jonathan Cooper
Here's the real one to stroke my autism
Pats: Brady Jets: Namath Bills: Kelly Dolphins: Marino Bengals: Ken Anderson Browns: Otto Graham Steelers: Big Ben Ravens: Flacco Jags:Brunell Colts: Indy: Manning, Baltimore: Unitas Titans: McNair Oilers:Moon Texans:Schaub Chargers: SD:Fouts LA:Rivers Broncos:Elway Chiefs:Len Dawson Raiders: Oak: Stabler LA: Plunkett
Eagles: McNabb Cowboys: Staubach Giants: YA Tittle Redskins: Sonny Jurgensen Bears: Sid Luckman Packers: Bart Starr Lions: Bobby Layne Vikings: Fran Tarkington Saints: Brees Falcons: Ryan Panthers: Newton Bucs: Winston 49ers: Montana Seahawks: Wilson Cardinals: Warner Rams: LA: Norm Van Brocklin STL: Warner
This is objectively the best list
David Thompson
>missing Flores and Marc Wilson otherwise 11/10
Luke Gonzalez
>Ken Anderson wrong >Otto Graham he's a raven, wrong >Big Ben Terry Bradshaw won twice as many owls, wrong >Staubach Aikman, wrong >Bart Starr Favre, wrong >Newton Delhomme
Fix those and it's the best list
Adam Young
Pennington for Jets is accurate.
Namath was a thoroughly mediocre quarterback who only became famous for guaranteeing the win in SB III.
Pennington was great though.
To put in perspective, the Patriots have only lost the AFC East twice in the Brady era... Pennington quarterbacked both of those teams. Granted one of them was the year Brady was out all season. Still... he is totally alone in that category.
Michael Gonzalez
He's been in the league forever and you're still talking about the potential for improvement with mechanics/footwork improvement. that's what they are saying about >our qb. Shit I thought that might actually amount to something.
Jace Campbell
It's steve young for the buscs
Isaiah Flores
>Ken Anderson led the league in passer rating 4 times
>Otto Graham is counted in Browns history not Ravens. I'll feed your autism though and say that Derek Anderson was the best of the reborn Browns
>Bradshaw was carried by teams Big Ben was too though, you might be right on that one
>Staunch worked with less, Aikmin was just a glorified game manager
>Bart Starr won 5 titles if you're using the title argument. Favre got 3 MVP though, tough call
>Newton won MVP and led his team to a super bowl Delhomme was an average qb that lucked into an appearance, though Newton might have as well, but his resume is better.
Robert Gutierrez
>no Blanda ITTTIG.
Michael Green
...
Levi Jackson
Okay, we agree on everything now. Ken Anderson is better, thanks for acknowledging my autism that Otto Graham isn't counted in Browns history, Pittsburgh is a toss up, Aikman had the most loaded offense in league history and still underperformed, Pack is a tough call, and I'll concede that Newton slightly edges Delhomme.
Jonathan Russell
Namath played very well in the Super Bowl though, and won the MVP
Dominic Martin
Checked. Based Smith will show them.
Jason Richardson
>He's been in the league forever and you're still talking about the potential for improvement with mechanics/footwork improvement. he just wrapped up his 6th season faggot, but somehow that's forever? He can and likely will improve over this year, he bounced back from the 2014 injuries all the way to an owl appearance and MVP in 2015
>that's what they are saying about >our qb. Shit I thought that might actually amount to something. speak English, what the hell are you referring to you mouth-breather?
Noah Parker
Aaron Rodgers is already better than Favre. In fact I say he's already top 5 ever. 1 or 2 more super bowls and I'll put him number 2 behind Brady. He's that good
Parker Richardson
For the Lions its definitely Stafford, he is elite just lacks a team
Elijah Nelson
packers should be bart starr
quality of play != greatness. if it did, aaron rodgers would be the undisputed GOAT, and even as a packer fan I don't think he's top 5 in terms of greatness.
Juan White
>mcnabb Ron Jaworski is goat nigger
Luke Brown
>Browns: Derek Anderson?
jesus christ that is stupid, it is Otto Graham or MAYBE Sipe/Kosar
Asher Nguyen
do you mean ravens?
Ryder Cox
Ravens history is a clean slate from the moment of the move, there are no Browns stats in their record books.
Gavin Taylor
>Chiefs: Joe Montana? Even though he was a shell of his former self, he took them to the playoffs
it's Trent Green you plen
Logan Clark
Sammy Baugh was the best QB the Redskins ever had.
More modern would probably be Sonny Jurgensen.
Theismann was the last time the Skins had a solid year-in year-out QB, though.
Nathan Ramirez
Len Dawson was the best Chiefs QB
Andrew Campbell
Bradshaw got carried to 4 Superb owls Ben owns ever Steelers passing record
Tyler Wood
Autism
Isaac Jones
>i just started watching football and have no idea about of its history: the post
Not your finest post I'm sure
Andrew King
I'd like to go drinking with the POWER VOID division.
Luke Hughes
>>Graham or Kosar >so Ravens, right?
Browns kept their history
Kevin Ward
Passing is a lot easier in today's game, user
Plus, Big Ben didn't do shit in their win against Seattle
John Rogers
Not even gonna waste my time with irrelevant franchises
Pats - brady Steelers - big Ben Packers - agod Eagles - mcnabb Giants - eli Cowboys - aikman Broncos - peyton
Oliver Parker
only in your autistic mind post a better one, friendo the only ones that are right are pats and cowboys
Brayden Ward
Staubach over Aikman. He's a god in Texas as opposed to a guy who rode Emmit Smith and Irvin
Liam Thomas
Jaworski was a meme
Ryan Reed
Lenny the Cool is the GOAT chiefs QB.
Jaxson Phillips
>le 7 good seasons mayne
he was shit bro, smeth is better. and montana is better than smeth
Juan Rodriguez
>only in your autistic mind
And according to the NFL. Lol I was right about you knowing fuck-all about football
