Can God create a rock he cannot lift?
Can God create a rock he cannot lift?
Gabriel Jones
Jason Rivera
...
Nicholas Barnes
...
Jaxson Powell
He can create everything and can do everything, so it's impossible for him to lift it while it's not impossible
Eli Wood
yeah this guy gets it
u suck OP
Michael Williams
...
Camden Perez
>Imagines a limitless being
>"Could that being put limits on itself?"
Dumb question
Jason Sanchez
maybe you are a dumb person?
Wyatt Rivera
Philosophy 100 question, lol
Justin Watson
God doesn't exist
Nathaniel Morales
Where is the rock?
Samuel Nguyen
Yep.
Thomas Gomez
dat guy looks like osama??
Camden Wilson
God would also be the rock, so whether it was lifted or not God would be the victor
Logan Rivera
>implying
Angel Clark
doesn't really matter. but if you really wanna you can prob find the answer in the bible.
Lincoln Price
Yes and he won't be able to lift it until he wants to lift it.
Jordan Richardson
...
Carson Kelly
>god is all powerful
>god creates a rock he cannot lift with power
Option 1 >god creates universe where the rock can be lifted
>god lifts the rock
Option 2 >god creates a universe where he has more power
>god lifts the rock
These scenarios are just thought experiments
Benjamin Green
Yes, because God can be omnipotent when he want (not always).
Angel Ward
That means it is not limitless since it does not have the power to limit itself
Nicholas Rogers
If God wills it. Allah Akbar
Leo Long
this. its a basic phil100 question
Jacob Flores
no it's false
Zachary Martinez
God's probably weaker than you think he is. It's gonna be hard to meet your expectations.
Carson Phillips
A rock is something that exists on the physical realm.
A rock that exceeds the limits of what a rock is, is no longer a rock. Therefore, God cannot create a rock he cannot lift because a rock that exceeds the limit of God would no longer be a rock.
Christian Martin
Everything that was in existence, was created by God. The realms God inhabits, are hard to define but we can assume they are not physical realms. If they were physical realms, we could detect God. Also by being a part of the physical realm, God would be subject to thing that happen to all things that exist here. Atoms are atoms.
So with all this mind, it is safe to assume God exists on a non-physical realm. Does weight exist in non-physical realms?No. Therefore, a rock cannot exist nor be too heavy that it cannot be lifted.