One of these threads

But for an artist/band's discography

Best: Piper at the Gates of Dawn
Worst: The Wall
Overrated: Meddle
Underrated: Saucerful of Secrets

How is the Wall worse than the albums that succeeded it i.e. The Final Cut and Momentary Lapse?

>B: Origin of Symmetry
>W: Drones
>O: Black Holes and Revelations
>U: Hullabaloo

>B: Animals
>W: The Endless River
>O: Wish You Were Here
>U: The Final Cut

The Wall is just fun to hate. I listened to Final Cut and the rest like seven years ago and just don't remember them well.

Dont worry man I think OP is just meming

I was lol

this is now a "lets fight about Pink Floyd" thread

All things by this guy

Best: Down Colorful Hill
Worst: Common As Light and Love Are Red Valleys of Blood
Overrated: Benji
Underrated: Bridge

Best: Dream Evil
Worst: Strange Highways
Overrated: Holy Diver
Underrated: Dream Evil

Best: On Avery Island
Worst: In The Aeroplane Over The Sea
Overrated: In The Aeroplane Over The Sea
Underrated: Everything Is

Kinda agree but I still love ITAOTS

Best: Wish You Were Here
Worst: The Division Bell
Overrated: Piper
Underrated: A Saucerful Of Secrets

Fixed for OP

Best: The Mollusk
Worst: La Cucaracha
Overrated: Pure Guava
Underrated: The Pod

B:revolver
W:Yellow submarine
O:sgt.pepper
U:Beatles for sale

dont get me wrong, i do love itaots

>King Crimson
Best: Larks Tongues in Aspic
Worst: The Construkction of Light
Overrated: In the Court of the Crimson King
Underrated: Thrak and Beat

Best: Irrlicht
Worst: Dune
Overrated: Moondawn
Underrated: Cyborg

Best: Rust Never Sleeps
Worst: Are you Passionate?
Overrated: Harvest
Underrated: Comes a Time

Best: Islands
Worst: Thrak
Overrated: Red
Underrated: Islands

Anything from Meddle through The Wall stands as by far the most overrated Pink Floyd. No one could write actual songs like Barret could. Waters was a great lyricist and the band produced well, but great production bores me. Piper and Saucerful are the best for most interesting songwriting. I also like the psychedelic vibe better than their later sound.

>Best: Piper at the Gates of Dawn

When will this meme end?

Best: S/T
Worst: Humanz
Overrated: Demon Days
Underrated: The Fall

Saucerful was largely written by Wright and Waters and is substantially better than Piper

Coincidence? I don't think so

Fuck you. Meddle is spectacular, specially the last track. The Wall is great.

Best: Atom Heart Mother.
Worst: The Division Bell
Overrated: Dark Side Of The Moon
Underrated: A Saucerful of Secrets

Fix'd.

This is objectively correct, although I would say that the actual Beatles songs on Yellow Submarine could have been a pretty good EP.