Thoughts?

Thoughts?

Which conference has produced the best crop of legendary QBs?

>Elway not super elite

Under-achieved his entire career and got carried to 2 owl wins in the last 2 seasons of his career by a ridiculously stacked team who ignored salary cap

Elway carried the fuck out of the Broncos those 3 Super Bowls.
Kill yourself.

>super bowls******
fixed ;^)

>Dan Fouts
>Warren Moon
>Len fucking Dawson

gee, one is a meme league and the other is the true national football league. I wonder which I'd pick.

Len Dawson was legitimate

>Le asterisk man
>Greatest
Top fucking kek

Les Dawson was the fucking man

>Dan Fouts

Led the most dominant offense of the late 70s early 80s. I would say he was elite.

Elway has more asterisks than Brady

>I will make this list

You can't spell elite without ELI

>rodgers ahead of eli
id even put troy ahead of rodgers

I wouldn't

No one brings up the broncos cheating for their Super Bowls because they weren't also dominant

Same reason everyone forgot Peyton took enough PEDs to kill a small elephant

>Rodgers an elite

No need to stat pad the NFC m8

Aikman was easily the most pedestrian player on that Dallas offense

>1 owl
>2 owls
>3 owls

>owls

Football is a team sport.

The ones Denver didn't win, dipshit.
Elway didn't carry shit in the last two, but he was a key part of those runs.

Lol Bradshaw elite.

No... Just..no.

...

Won 4 super bowls and he played well in them. Before the rule changes also.

>no ELI

top kek, the guy who absolutely destroyed """""The Greatest""""" is not on your list. butthurt pats fag detected

Eli has had 2 autism fueled seasons and the rest of his years he has been absolute ass.

It's even, post-merger. There are an equal number if QBs who won multiple MVPs in both leagues.

You aikman was elite in his time

Also, there are 20 QBs in the HoF post-merger and 7 pre-merger.

They are evenly divided between the conferences.

No Russell Wilson, shit list

If wilson's career ended today, he would not be legendary

Um Fucking Excuse Me?

>No Based Eli
>No Matty Ice
>Rodgers is Elite

Wew lad

matty ice hasnt done shit

eli is a lucky faggot

rodgers is elite

>rodgers is elite

who is tarell davis

>Matty Ice hasn't done sh it

Except be consistently good his whole career, win the MVP and lead his team to a Super Bowl

>Eli got lucky

You dont win 2 super bowls with luck.

>Rodgers is elite

Can this meme end pls?

>Can this meme end pls?

Rodgers is Rodgers. He's an elite player. It's getting really hard to distinguish the harmless shit posters who are bashing Rodgers because he lost a game from the actual retards who don't think he's an elite QB though. It's gotta be the hottest new meme on Sup Forums currently.

>Xeacuck fans actually believe this
Also put Montana in greatest for the NFC your a clown for not doing this at the start OP

Not true, he had a good year last year and they went to the playoffs this season. They have never had a run game to balance their offense out.

It's not a meme when you consistently choke in the playoffs.

And Rodgers does? The elites rise above that

That's a meme.

t. Rodgers fan

t. memer

Add Ryan and Eli anyways asshole

There is only one GOAT my dude.

Fixed

>no Aikman
Shitlist

>No Eli
>Peyton Super Elite

Wew lad

>the only 4 people you could logically argue for GOAT
>3 in elite, 1 super elite
kek

We are all forgetting the true elite.

Terrell Davis you illiterate fuck.

And that's relevant because....

Fixed it for you.

>tfw been noticing that overall Big Ben finally starting to get the historical recognition he deserves

Feels good man

Prepare to include Ryan and bump Brady down to Super Elite in a week and a half.

why is terry bradshaw on the list and not troy aikman?

>Fran Tarkenton included in a discussion of elites
>Fran Tarkenton remembered at all
Ty based OP, you are best ally

>there are franchises with fewer than 3 QBs on this list
Not real franchises IMO
Just remove them all from the league for being so shit

t. Patcuck
End your life

Kelly was better than Marino

>A FUCKING LEAF
Of course you would. Leafcucks are born retarded.

Terrell Davis wasn't on the team when Elway carried them to 3 owls.

He was on the team when the won 2 however.

>godgers
>super elite
Pick both

Also brady as greatest is ridiculous. The pats won 11 games without him, and won 3 of 4 without him this year

NFC and it's not even close.

Kill yourself.

>no eli

And it's the guy who never lost a Bowl.

You can't use the 2008 season to diminish him at this point, the man has just done too much. You're throwing pebbles at a lion.

if you don't recognize YA Tittle you don't have any business fixing anything, faggot

Terry won 4, Troy won 3

Terry played when it was completely legal to break peoples spines 30 seconds after the whistle was blown

And who are those 4?

i wish Kurt Warner had played for a couple more years earlier in his career. dude was supernaturally great for a couple years.

>win the MVP and lead his team to a Super Bowl

When did this happen?

> muh historical bias .jpg

Half those old timer QBs wouldnt last a season on today's league. They couldn't throw for shit.

>have highest passer ratings with a loss in playoff history
>chokes
Packers defense and horrible coaching have costed them playoff games, not Rodgers

Even at the end he was still amazing, I can't believe the Cards blew his (and Larry's) shot at the owl that year.

>tfw the cards have to win the owl next year or Larry will never get his ring

Seriously why do people think Tom Brady is so great? He isn't that athletic and most of his throws are simple check downs. He has a good football IQ and that's it. If it weren't for the rings (that are mostly attributed to good coaching) he wouldn't even be in the discussion.

> He's the best at knowing how to win the game
> Why is he so good

>montana is better than brady

did a 10 year old make this picture

He's a great quarterback and a mediocre athlete. You don't need to be very athletic to play the QB position well.

>his coach is the best at putting the team in position to win games
FTFY
But he's still a basic checkdown QB. I have not seen many throws from Tom Brady that wow me as much as the types of throws Rodgers or Brees can make.

Big Ben is not fucking elite. He's one tier under that./

Where's Troy Aikman??? If you have Young you need Aikman. 3 rings and lead the greatest dynasty of the 90s.

Unitas didn't play in the NFC, he played in the NFL and later the AFC.

>leader of the offense and QB
>pedestrian
>on one of the best ever

You literally make no fucking sense nor know anything about the 90s Cowboys.

There's only a fractional difference in career YPA/comp% between Brady and Rodgers. That said, Rodgers does make those "wow" throws a lot more often than Brady and if I had to choose between watching Brady or Rodgers play I'm choosing Rodgers every time, but Brady is the better QB. Just not as exciting to watch.

>doesn't know who Y.A. Tittle is
>has the audacity to comment on something NFL related

>Bart Starr
>Super Elite

You must be from Wisconsin. That's a shit pick.

I'd take Starr off entirely and put Sonny Jurgensen in the Elites. Also probably Brees into the Super Elites.

Eli didnt "destroy" brady
The giants defense did

Eli just played an average game with a lucky catch or two, Eli is a decent but not elite QB who was on the right team at the right time

>Cards blew

They got refballed out of an Owl and the Aints bountygated Kurt into retirement.

I was assblasted for a while afterwards but I made my peace. Warner left the field with a lead and the defense choked it away, no refball.

>no love for Kurt Warner

No otto graham in the greatest of the afc get out

>tfw still hurt

Just accept it

shut up dummy poopoo head

>no staffgod

Fuck off