So what are your thoughts?
BRAND NEW
The deconstruction of the music genre
Unironically their best and most mature album. Literally a masterpiece
Forgettable. Which is sad since I know their other four albums and demos almost by heart.
AOTYSF. Batter Up and 137 are the best tracks.
If you find this album forgettable, you clearly havent listened to it enough
I'd agree that it's their most mature album, but TDAG is their magnum opus.
I felt a little too much Modest Mouse influence on SF, and while I do like Modest Mouse, I don't think it works as well for Brand New.
It's still in the running for AOTY for me
>God Tier
Batter Up
Lit Me Up
451
137
Desert
Out of Mana
No Control
Same Logic
>Great Tier
Cant Get it Out
Waste
In the Water
Could Never Be Heaven
mediocre, a little better than what came before it though
brand new is forgettable and you should be over them if you're over twenty two or so
If you think this is the same level of lyrics as Deja or TDAG you need to listen again
i can't tell if you're just replying to the wrong post or your reading comprehension is actually this bad
Naw im just autistic and mixed up your sentences. Fuck
Waste deserves more than that, its a great song
I mean every song is a 9 id say
Fair, I'd probably put No Control and Desert as the weakest on the album.
No control is the weakest. Album is a fucking masterpiece though. Has more and more depth every spin.
No Control has the best outro on the album
This, its an album that gets better every day
Yeah but what about the 2 minutes before it?
Thats another bit of a peeve with the album, there's something lacking in the length of the songs, maybe its cause I saw the lengths before I listened to it as seeing 6/7 minute songs which turned out to be 3-5 minute songs + other bits made me a bit sad. I really like it if they'd jammed out some parts like they do with You Won't Know and Sowing Season live, Same Logic seems perfect for something like that after the 'you look so lovely, but you sound so ugly' part.
I probably agree, but I still do like No Control
>listen to it on release
>"It's okay, but not their best"
>listen to it now
>It might even compete with TDAG
Honestly this is a great album.
Under the ocean
Next to a boiling vent
He's none the wiser
Earth's only resident
It piled up
Man, it was wall to wall
Blink of an eye
And all the problems solved
Let's all go play Nagasaki
We can all get vaporised
Hold my hand, let's turn to ash
I'll see you on the other side
Before the garden
When you were all alone
You made the atom
Was that some inside joke
Open the gates
And then conceal the path
Let's load the gun
And see how long they last
Let's go ring and run the bunkers
Baby won't you come outside?
Across the sea the birds are free
Let's watch them scream across the sky
Let's all go and meet our maker
They don't care whose side you're on
We're so afraid, I prayed and prayed
Before I learned to love the bomb
Let's all go play Nagasaki
What a lovely way to die
A final show and we all go
So no one has to say goodbye
Lets all go and meet our maker
Won't matter whose side you're on
We're so afraid, I prayed and prayed
When God told me to love the bomb
I'd give that title to Out of Mana desu
Still love No Control
>That Atom/Adam wordplay
This, definitely an album that gets better every listen
It makes me sad this is their last album, because this is perhaps their best work, much more complex than what came before. This is gonna be my AOTY, that depends how third NIN's EP will be and if it will came out this year of course.
Its January im pretty sure
boring album. what's worse: the pretentious fans or waiting this long for this album?
this
Imagine being so butthurt you complain