Woo boy one of these threads

>Best
Nobody Puts Baby In The Corner
>Runner Up
Dance, Dance
>Worst
I've Got A Dark Alley...
>Overrated
Sugar, We're Goin' Down
>Underrated
XO

Reminder that opinions are subjective

>Best
137
>Runner Up
Batter Up
>Overrated
Desert
>Underrated
No Control
>Worst
None

>Best
Mind/Body/Light/Sound
>Runner-Up
Celebrity Lifestyle
>Worst
Warm
>Overrated
Blood Promise
>Underrated
Mother's Milk

>Best
Feet Don't Fail Me
>Runner Up
The Evil Has Landed
>Overrated
The Way You Used To Do
>Underrated
Head Like A Haunted House
>Worst
Hideaway

>Best
A Better Place, A Better Time
>Runner Up
Failing, Flailing
>Worst
If and When We Rise Again
>Overrated
Point/Counterpoint

>Best
Pink Cigarette
>Runner Up
The Air-Conditioned Nightmare
>Overrated
Retrovertigo (still pretty gud)
>Underrated
The Holy Filament or Vanity Fair
>Worst
Golem II

>Best
American Dream
>Runner Up
How Do You Sleep?
>Overrated
Call the Police, I guess.
>Underrated
Oh Baby
>Worst
Other Voices. Its still enjoyable though.

>Best
(Coffee's for Closers)
>Runner Up
Headfirst Slide into Cooperstown on a Bad Bet
>Worst
w.a.m.s.
>Overrated
I Don't Care
>Underrated
The (Shipped) Gold Standard

>Best
On Another Ocean
>Runner Up
Mearcstapa
>Overrated
If You Need To, Keep Time on Me
>Underrated
I Am All That I Need
>Worst
I Should See Memphis

>Best
Same Logic/Teeth
>Runner Up
Can't Get it Out
>Overrated
137
>Underrated
Lit Me Up
>Worst
Out of Mana

bump

Good taste

>Best
Communist Daughter
>Runner Up
Two Headed Boy Pt. 2
>Worst
The Fool
>Overrated
In The Aeroplane Over The Sea
>Underrated
Ghost

>Best
Old Soul Song
>Runner Up
At The Bottom of Everything
>Worst
Land Locked Blues
>Overrated
First Day of My Life
>Underrated
We Are Nowhere and It's Now

>Best
Sober II (Melodrama)
>Runner Up
The Louvre
>Worst
Perfect Places
>Overrated
Liability
>Underrated
Green Light (despite being the lead single)

>Best
What Goes Around... Comes Around
>Runner Up
LoveStoned
>Worst
Damn Girl
>Overrated
My Love (still a great song)
>Underrated
Chop Me Up

>Best
Don't Let's Start
>Runner Up
Youth Culture Killed My Dog
>Worst
Chess Piece Face
>Overrated
Everything Right is Wrong Again
>Underrated
Boat of Car

pretty damn accurate man

>Best
Until the End of Time
>Runner-Up
Futesex/Lovesound
>Worst
Losing My Way
>Overrated
SexyBack
Underrated
Summer Love
Unironically love this album

>best
Crack-Up
>runner-up
I Should See Memphis or On Another Ocean
>Worst
Fool's Errand
>Overrated
Fool's Errand
>Underrated
Crack-Up

This is my honest opinion but it's weird and funny how it basically ignores the first two thirds of the album

>best
All of them because this is my favorite record

wrong
wrong
wrong
wrong
wrong

Swap Vanity Fair with TACN and its stop on

>Best
El Scorcho
>Runner Up
Pink Triangle
>Worst
Across The Sea
>Underatted
No Other One
>Overatted
The Good Life

>best
my name is jonas
>runner up
in the garage
>worst
surf wax america
>overrated
say it aint so
>underrated
no one else

>best
Flood 3
>runner up
Flood 1
>worst
Flood 4
>overrated
Flood 2
>underrated
Flood 1

user you may be retarded

>best
Don, Aman
>runner up
Breadcrumb Trail
>worst
Nosferatu Man
>overrated
Good Morning, Captain
>underrated
For Dinner...

>best
Miracle of Love
>runner up
Failure
>worst
Song for the Sun
>overrated
Love Will Save You
>underrated
You Know Nothing

>best
April 8th
>runner up
Gardenhead/Leave Me Alone
>worst
Three Peaches
>overrated
Naomi
>underrated
Pree-Sisters Swallowing A Donkey's Eye

>best
I Want It I Need It
>runner up
Spread Eagle Cross the Block
>worst
Blood Creepin
>overrated
Guillotine
>underrated
5D

>best
Heroin
>Runner Up
When the World Was on Fire We Just Kept Dancing
>Worst
Lust For Life
>Overrated
Love
>Underrated
In My Feelings

Agree 90% but would replace underrated with Klink. No one ever talks about that song but it's pretty fucking good

have you forgotten that I Slept With Someone is among the best tracks of that album

>Best
Cruel World
>Runner Up
Shades of Cool
>Worst
The Other Woman
>Overrated
Brooklyn Baby
>Underrated
Florida Kilos

>Best
Born To Die
>Runner Up
Off To the Races
>Worst
Diet Mountain Dew
>Overrated
Video Games
>Underrated
This is What Makes Us Girls

>best
Song For Dead Time
>runner-up
You Know Nothing
>worst
Will We Survive
>overrated
Power and Sacrifice
>underrated
Song for the Sun

>Best
In One Ear
>Runner Up
Ain't No Rest For the Wicked
>Worst
Lotus
>Overrated
Back Against The Wall
>Underrated
Drones in the Valley

>Best
Down in the Valley
>Runner Up
Lost in my Mind
>Worst
Cats and Dogs
>Overrated
Rivers and Roads
>Underrated
Winter Song

>best
Snowball In Hell
>runner up
Kiss Me, Sun Of God
>worst
You'll Miss Me
>Overrated
Purple Toupee, if I had to pick one
>Underrated
Cowtown

>Best
Until The End Of Time
>Runner Up
Lovestoned
>Worst
Chop Me Up
>Overrated
Sexyback
>Underrated
Damn Girl

>Best
The Only One
>Runner Up
Howlin For You
>Worst
Everlasting Light
>Overrated
Tighten Up
>Underrated (SEVERELY)
Black Mud

Fuck wish I noticed this when I posted Lincoln

>Best
Hide Away Folk Family
>Runner Up
She's an Angel
>Worst
Toddler Highway
>Overrated
(She Was A) Hotel Detective
>Underrated
Youth Culture Killed My Dog

>Best
Little Black Submarines
>Runner Up
Gold On the Ceiling
>Worst
Nova Baby
>Overrated
Lonely Boy
>Underrated
Run Right Back

>Best
No Other
>Runner Up
Silver Raven
>Worst
Silver Vial (Still great tho)
>Overrated
?
>Underrated
The True One

Naomi is basically part of April 8th...

>>worst
>the fool

>best
>not Oh Comely
what did they mean by this?

i would put culture shock as best but i agree with everything else

>best
Tinker Tailor Soldier Sailor Rich Man Poor Man Beggar Man Thief
>runner up
Decks Dark
>worst
Identikit
>overrated
Burn The Witch
>underrated
Glass Eyes

this

>Best
How Are You Getting Home?
>Runner Up
Looks, Looks, Looks
>Worst
Hospitality On Parade
>Overrated
Tits
>Underrated
In the Future

Good taste

I agreeee but
>Best
Following an Angel
>Runner Up
Put Your Hand Inside The Puppet Head
>Worst
Toddler Highway
>Underrated
Put Your Hand Inside The Puppet head
best is definitely Poison Oak
best is tired of sex,
worst is getchoo
shit, this.
except i'd swap the snowball for underrated and best for They'll Need a Crane

>Best
Pattern Against User
>Runner Up
Invalid Letter Dept
>Worst
Quarantined
>Overrated
Cosmonaut
>Underrated
Sleepwalk Capsules

>best
Out of Mana
>runner-up
Waste
>worst
Could Never Be Heaven
>overrated
137
>underrated
451

>best
Lock Your Doors
>runner up
Come Up and Get Me
>worst
Stockton
>Overrated
No Love
>underrated
Pop

>best
>not The Numbers
are you even trying?

>best
Videotape
>runner up
Weird Fishes
>worst
15 Step (if i was forced to pick lol)
>overrated
House of Cards
>underrated
Nude

>Best
Hard to Explain
>Runner Up
Someday
>Worst
Barely Legal
>Overrated
Last Nite
>Underrated
Alone, Together

When people talk about Blood Premise they're usually referring to the live version.

>best
you wont know
>runner up
jesus christ
degausser
>worst
handcuffs
>overrated
Limousine
>underrated
untitled

>Best
Landscaping
>Runner-up
Sorcerer
>Worst
The Young Man Has a Point
>Overrated
Yet Another
>Underrated
Take Advantage of the Naysayer

green light was generic studio pop garbage what are you on

>Best
Everything I Am
>Runner-Up
Flashing Lights
>Worst
Champion, Barry Bonds, Drunk & Hot Girls, Big Brother
>Overrated
Stronger, Good Life, Homecoming
>Underrated
The Glory

>best
I Should See Memphis
>runner-up
Cassius, –
>Worst
If You Need to, Keep Time on Me
>Overrated
If You Need to, Keep Time on Me
>Underrated
Crack-Up

>Best
Disposition/Reflection/Triad
>Runner Up
The Grudge
>Worst
Lateralus
>Overrated
Schism
>Underrated
The Patient

>Best
See You Again
>Runner-Up
Boredom
>Worst
Enjoy Right Now, Today
>Overrated
Who Dat Boy
>Underrated
November

>Best
Across The Sea
>Runner Up
Falling For You
>Worst
Getchoo
>Overrated
El Scorcho
>Underrated
No Other One

I like your list, thanks for being the only other person posting this album

>Best
Homemade Dynamite
>Runner up
Sober II (Melodrama)
>Worst
Green Light
>Overrated
Liability (I still love it)
>Underrated
Sober

>Best
That's Really Super, Supergirl
>Runner Up
Dear God
>Worst
Mermaid Smiled
>Overrated
Dear God
>Underrated
Ballet for a Rainy Day

> calling their only good song overrated
Kinda throwing the baby out with the bath water, there

>Best
None
>Worst
All of them

>Best
Picture of a Tree That Doesn't Look Okay

>Runner up
You'll Never Go to Space

>Worst
Gig Life

>Overrated
Heartbeat In the Brain (only cause I heard it too many times, it's a great opener desu)

>Underrated
Layers of Skin We Drag Around

>best
Guilty Partner
>Runner Up
Dream Attack
>Worst
Round and Round
>Overrated
Fine Time
>Underrated
All the Way

>best
Good Morning, Captain
>runner up
Nosferatu Man
>worst
For Dinner...
>overrated
Breadcrumb Trail
>underrated
Don, Aman

>Best
Schism
>Runner Up
The Grunge
>Worst
Triaad
>Overrated
Lateralus
>Underrated
Parabola

>best
Thru the Eyes of Ruby

>runner up
Porcelina of the Vast Oceans

>worst
Zero

>overrated
Bullet with Butterfly Wings

>underrated
Tales of A Scorched Earth

the very first song in the album was underrated too

Wew

>Best
Identikit
>Runner Up
Desert Island Disc
>Overrated
Daydreaming
>Underrated
Tinker Tailor Soldier Sailor
>Worst
Present Tense (Still a 9/10)

>Best
Run Away With Me
>Runner Up
Emotion
>Worst
I Really Like You
>Overrated
Boy Problems
>Underrated
Gimme Love

>Best
Venice Queen
>Runner up
Dosed
>Worst
Zephyr Song
>Overrated
Universally Speaking
>Underrated
Minor Thing
>Best
Xo
>Runner up
I Slept with Someone in Fall Out Boy...
>Worst
I've Got A Dark Alley...
>Overrated
Sugar, We're Goin' Down
>Underrated
Sophomore Slump...
>Best
What Goes Around... Comes Around
>Runner up
Sexy Ladies
>Worst
Damn Girl
>Overrated
Sexyback
>Underrated
My Love
>Best
You Won't Know
>Runner up
Jesus
>Worst
Luca
>Overrated
Archers Bows Have Broken
>Underrated
Degausser

>Best
The Willing Well II: From Fear Through the Eyes of Madness
>Runner up
Apollo I: The Writing Writer
>Worst
The Lying Lies and Dirty Secrets of Miss Erica Court
>Overrated
The Willing Well III: Apollo II: The Telling Truth
>Underrated
Welcome Home

Good taste (well, except for Handcuffs) and nice Trips.

>Best
MILK, WASTE, FAKE
>Runner up
STAR, FACE
>Worst
BANK
>Overrated
GOLD
>Underrated
TRIP

>Best
JUNKY, SWAMP, SWEET
>Runner up
SUMMER, GUMMY
>Worst
TEETH
>Overrated
QUEER
>Underrated
FIGHT, GAMBA

>Best
>Not Sophomore Slump

Damn I forgot about that... move tinker to runner up

WRONG

>Best
Ivory Tower
>Runner Up
Night of The Long Knives
>Worst
New Deep
>Overrated
White Whale
>Underrated
Ivory Tower (see above)


>Underrated
>Welcome Home
wut. Nigga, that's basically the only song that most people even know of theirs (and they usually couldn't even tell you the name of it or the band).

>Best
Luca
>Runner Up
Handcuffs
>Overrated
Jesus Christ
>Underrated
Archers
>Worst
Sowing Season

Agreed, except for me the most underrated one is Your Type. (I think Gimmie Love is better, but I never hear anyone praise Your Type)

i don't like any of this album - feels so bland

Classic pop-emo record pleased to see it getting some love
Probably the best on the album from a rock perspective

>nude
>underrated

>Best
Buried Alive/Raise the Dead
>Runner Up
Don't Burn the Witch
>Worst
Leave Me In Hell
>Overrated
Countess Bathory
>Underrated
Sacrifice

>Best
Sepulchral Voice
>Runner Up
Witching Metal
>Worst
Burst Command Til War
>Overrated
Outbreak of Evil
>Underrated
Sepulchral Voice

Blasphemer doesn't get a place on this chart because it doesn't fit in any of the spots

>Best
The Last Time
>Runner Up
Such A Shame
>Worst
It's You
>Overrated
It's My Life
>Underrated
Tomorrow Started

>best
disorder
>runner up
shadowplay
>worst
interzone
>overrated
she's lost control
>underrated
insight but candidate also doesnt get enough credit

queer aint overrated its the best and youre a bitch

>overrated song for one album is called "Burn The Witch"
>runner up song on another album is "Don't Burn The Witch"

Yes.

I thought I was the only one who had Ruby as their favorite track. Everyone else goes with 1979. The worst is definitely XYU and most underrated is Thirty-Three though

>Best
Carry That Weight
>Runner Up
Come Together
>Worst
Sun King
>Overrated
Here Comes the Sun
>Underrated
She Came In Through the Bathroom Window