I love this band so much, what made them so good and why could no one ever reach their level in the postpunk scene?

I love this band so much, what made them so good and why could no one ever reach their level in the postpunk scene?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=0TZbOz1Pz5o
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

>why could no one ever reach their level in the postpunk scene

Pornography is their best album but even then it's still nowhere near as good

Their secret best album is Bloodflowers.

^^^^^^This

:)

thecurefags please leave

Let Robert into your heart.

Martin Hannett

Let Robert into your anal cavity

It's the album cover.

But he is a married man.

>not realizing Porcupine is the best ever Post-Punk album

I want Tumblr normies to leave

Ian McCulloch ain't worth best anything.

Movement > Unknown Pleasures

Haha nice t-shirt bro i like Joy Division brand too good clothing

Objectively wrong.

Echo's Bunnymen are hacks, they just ripped off U2

But user closer is better

Nobody ever mentions And Also The Trees or Dead Can Dance, or even Black Marble in /dark/ threads and that saddens me.

Also I love Unknown Pleasures. Nice sex album. But Pornography has to take that cake, OP.

the wire made 3 albums better than any jd release
try again hunny

>nice sex album
Fucking lol

>the wire

Holy shit, I just looked this up on youtube and someone actually made a whole album about that one t-shirt!

that's not even the best joy division album

>why could no one ever reach their level in the postpunk scene?
>*blocks your path*

nah they didn't, if you look at art through a historical scope. the wire's biggest torchbearers were REM and U2, whereas joy division influenced everything from synthpop to grunge to goth

The Chameleons are better

but someone did reach their level, aand surpassed it.

These guys are basically lo-fi joy division, idk if that interests you

idgaf about influence. i care about what sounds good

Because Ian martyr'd himself

so joy division doesn't sound as good as wire? like how

The Wire is kind of mediocre my dude

like how?
in everything
instrumentally and lyrically they are better than JD. youtube.com/watch?v=0TZbOz1Pz5o
i'd advise you and this guy to stop learning about post-punk from netflix tv shows like 13 reasons why

Nigga, please, I learned about post-punk through shitty movies like Donnie Darko like all poseurs did once in my generation.

hahahah top fuckin b8. i cringed hard when joy division or the cure came on in that show. but i still kinda enjoyed it, just cause it pissed parents off

never seen donnie darko. is it good?

2 of the most overrated bands ever.
I've never enjoyed a single moment of their music.

"Hey ma look I did it again!"

Yes and no. It is not bad for what it is (dude deep teenager psychology lmao), but it is not great.

CLOSER IS BETTER

CHROME

That's not even Post Punk.

Objectively wrong. Closer has a couple good tracks, like Isolation and A Means to an End, but UP basically has gold with every track

>le shirt band

Objectively wrong. UP has a couple good tracks, like Disorder and She's Lost Control, but Closer basically has gold with every track

Objectively wrong. Closer has a couple good tracks, like Isolation and A Means to an End, but UP basically has gold with every track

you should go stabbing yourself in the neck, pleb :^)

this man gets it

Pink Flag is overrated and it's about time someone said it. Chairs Missing and 154 do have a few brilliant tracks each (French Film Blurred, Another the Letter, The 15th, Map Ref...).

Both had their weak spots. Day of the Lords was overblown, especially having come right after Disorder, and Wilderness is pretty much filler. Atrocity Exhibition is a good example of Ian trying to sound too profound or literary. The synths in the first part of Decades aged horribly.

>Nice sex album

>Wilderness is pretty much filler
What are you on Wilderness is a killer song. If anything the worst song is I Remember Nothing

all post punk from that era has signs of aging strapped to it. look at Killing Joke ffs

Dead Souls was their best song

Definitely one of the best. Most of their best songs weren't even on their two albums

>Dead Souls
>Transmission
>Love Will Tear Us Apart