The great debate
The great debate
Nolan Murphy
Other urls found in this thread:
Isaac Adams
SD >>>>>>>>>>>
Dominic Russell
Mellon Collie in the correct track order, not the CD order.
Dylan Morales
Mellon Collie has its charms but the trash songs add up really fast
Adam Bell
what is the 'correct' track order?
Grayson Campbell
Required reading: yuki.la
Adrian Murphy
Siamese Dream
Adrian Lee
What do you consider the trash songs?
Ryder Ross
siamese dream
Mason Hall
I love these 2 albums I can't really say one is better. They're just different.
However like said you need the original vinyl track list, it just flows a lot better.
I probably listen to SD a lot more though since I like to listen to MCIS from start to finish.
Joshua Walker
Mellon collie is the more ambitious creative endeavor, but Siamese Dream is a better cohesive whole
Overall I gotta go with SD. Both are amazing albums tho
Robert Jones
Gish>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>everything else
Robert Reed
Adore
Chase Sanchez
right is a 5/10
left is a 2/10
Wyatt Flores
Bad opinion
Hunter Gomez
Mellon
Jason Mitchell
Siamese dream is better but if Mellon Collie was cut down to like 13 tracks it would be 10/10.
Alexander Jones
Use the 1995 tracklist
Cameron James
Siamese Dream for those sweet sweet roaring electric guitars, Mellon Collie for the softer tracks.
Easton Green
Why do that? it's already a 10/10
What?
Sebastian Anderson
Holy shit this is stupid autism. It is very incorrect.
Eli Parker
This is wrong. The CD was released before the vinyl. The vinyl was an afterthought and had a different track list just to fit on the record and an incentive to buy it.
Landon Bailey
Wow, the original vinyl tracklist is pretty amazing
Gabriel Phillips
Eh, I don't think it's as good as the real tracklist. The addition of several crap bonus tracks bogs it down as well.
Daniel Diaz
Haven't listened to the bonus songs, but I like how they group the similar style songs together, sounds like it would flow well better. I'll have to give it a try next time I listen to the album
Xavier Robinson
Part of the charm of the album is the extreme dynamic shifts. Grouping the songs together destroys that, the original intent for the album.
Andrew Martin
Yeah I guess, but on the vinyl its a bit different with each side of the disc being a different theme, makes sense to group it together then. Which is your favourite disc of the cd version?
Andrew Garcia
BOTH
Colton Green
siamese dream easily
Easton Jenkins
>but on the vinyl its a bit different with each side of the disc being a different theme
The CDs have a theme as well, so this point is irrelevant
>Which is your favourite disc of the cd version?
The 2nd.