What did Scaruffi mean by this? Is Syd's solo work really that good?

What did Scaruffi mean by this? Is Syd's solo work really that good?

Other urls found in this thread:

web.archive.org/web/20010617011237/http://www.scaruffi.com:80/vol4/talking.html
youtu.be/ZyhrYis509A
web.archive.org/web/20011107034305/http://www.scaruffi.com:80/music/best100.html
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

no, scaruffi a dumdum

it really isn't imo
pretty boring

>Is Syd's solo work really that good?
If you like it, it is.
Stop putting Scaruffi's opinions on a pedestal.

What did Scruff mean by THIS?

Yes. I would switch those two ratings around but yes Syd's solo stuff is fucking amazing. Get Opel as well.

what did scruffy mean by this

He's right, but in typical Scaruffi fashion he's steal been contrarian by giving each rating to the wrong album

are these old ratings?

yes
web.archive.org/web/20010617011237/http://www.scaruffi.com:80/vol4/talking.html

damn. i wonder what other ratings he changed

"Barrett" feels like it was recorded by a schizo

it's probably the purest psycho-folk album in its form i've ever heard

it is definitely worth checking out

What did Scaruffi mean by this?

fake news

OP who's opinion will you take more seriously, some 19 year old art school incel faggots, or a master connoisseur of not only music but of all the arts and their histories?

Good meme, let me grab my popcorn for this.

test

>a master connoisseur of not only music but of all the arts and their histories?
Oh what instrument does he play again?

...

damn...what did he mean by THIS?

the brain

damn...

Holy shit, this is fucking real. Think of all the albums that he's given a lower score to, what the fuck.

he actually gave Kid A a 5/10 when it first came out, not even memeing

patrician

...

So he's not a very good musician then ;_;

literally better than anything that the Beatles released
youtu.be/ZyhrYis509A

oh nooo an unemployed italian man has different taste than me wahhhh what do i do help meeeeeeeeeee

Does a film critic need to be a director to critique film?

bayar

decent bait, made me go to read the review before i realized it was fake

Go back to bed, Scaruffi.

WTF

>In the end it turn out that Scaruffi is a talentless hack.
Literally no better than a RYM user.

the doors s/t used to be 9.5/10

To claim he is an intellectual critic, yes.

OH GOD I didn't realize they were the ones who did THAT song

fuck fuck fuck I don't want that stuck in my head

Oh shit
web.archive.org/web/20011107034305/http://www.scaruffi.com:80/music/best100.html

I don't see what's wrong, this is a much better pop song than anything The Beatles ever put out.

>"Barrett" feels like it was recorded by a schizo
That's because it almost certainly was

fuck what, listen to it.

scruffy is literally the best music reviewer. the only one worth listening to

agree

Stained, glaucous, glycerine, gold, goat, clover
Gold, local stocks, type, food, wild, national, lake, flag,
Valve, gyroscope, sect
Heat, helium, lead, bare, state, invention, medieval
Refraction, faction, ultra-action,
Hunter, interest, bullet, market...

Loads, liquids, neon, heater, jaws, jungle
Mains, signal, knives, kitchen
Ingot, lovely, mirror, mold
Mycenaean, moat, poppy, rubber,
Radar, rags, sugar, teak
Silver, poke, tin, beetroot,
Carrot, ebony, fruit, copper, silk...

Carpet, distant, pigmy, hid, pack,
Timber, pudding, straw
Raindrops, spattering, ramps
Chameleon, prairie, pods, trigger
Museum, scales, square, ultra, out of map, vent
Volcano, vain, wreck, tactic
Tidal, arches, valley, hand
Inflect, impression, loom, last, molten
You gamma, meeting
Lighting, signal, island, coral-cold
You seem to have confused Syd's solo albums with your life

that was actually a really good album if you can square yourself with the aesthetic, no bad tracks and a lot of ones way better than the singles