Why are Americans so shit at making decent post-punk?

Why are Americans so shit at making decent post-punk?

...

Why are the English so shit at making regular punk music?

>protomartyr
>dismemberment plan
>the fucking talking heads
hm. alright

american are shit at all punk music

some of the cringiest punk to ever been made has been american

Americans never had punk as a widespread cultural movement the way the English did, so there was nothing to react to.

What is no wave?

Who are Mission of Burma

What is the entire punk scene of Portland?

I think you meant to say "English".

*blocks your path*

Christian Death who?

Because regular punk is shit

americans are too feminine to make good punk music

Something about heroin and fish and chips just makes Post-Punk better.

>Black Flag
>Ramones
>Minutemen
>Television
>Minor Threat
>Fugazi
>Pere Ubu
>Dead Kennedys
>Big Black
>Minutemen
>Husker Du
>The Stooges
>Suicide
>Bad Brains
>Devo
>Gun Club
>Swans
>Melvins
>americans are shit at all punk music
t. the country that outlaws butterknives

Talking heads are amerifats?! WHAT THE FUCK!

America is the home of the worst and best of punk. Almost everything out of the UK except for a few select bands is soft as fuck mediocre drivel that all sounds the same.

t. police dont have guns.

>who is GG Allin?

because we dont know how to get out of our state into another place

You can be punk and feminine. Like the Slits and X-Ray Spex

Brexit nigga. Punk and blues is about the only thing we do right.

>two genres stolen from america are the only things the british can do right
lmao

>owning a gun makes me masculine

found you

Americans are too fat and lazy to have the self awareness necessary to write socially critical music that doesn't boil down to FUCK RIGHT WING PEOPLE. They also have no culture or heritage roots in their locations so they can't truly feel the sorrow caused by decadence.

Only nu-males need guns to defend themselves.

Technically New Wave

That was from an American viewpoint. Reading comprehension in this place has gone to shit. Bunch of faggots pouncing on keywords for shit wit retorts.

>implying being unabashedly feminine isn't the biggest counter culture today

You'd wanna buy a gun if you lived out here. Trust me bruh.

t. brainlet who cannt understand Pere Ubu

The Pop Group is literally the only good post punk from England...
who else are you even thinking of?

Cultural history has zip to do with current political events. It just leads to glorifying a past that no longer exists and attempting to preserve something solely because it's been there.

Euros always talk about their rich history if only because of their irrelevancy in today's going-ons geopolitically speaking.

Not enough history or culture
Unironically

>Cultural history has zip to do with current political events
Imagine being THIS much of an Amerilard that you actually believe this.