The Great Debate

The Great Debate

The Black Parade: 8/10
American Idiot: 4/10

The Monitor

/thread

Black Parade not even MCRs best album and still better than American idiot fight me

they’re both shit. stop shilling mcr on Sup Forums

this.

both are for faggots.

not to say there is anything wrong with that, but at least accept an own it, you faggots.

American idiot is a perfect slice of suburban early 2000s. I don't care if I'm blinded by nostalgia, it's a 10/10 from me.

Three cheers> American idiot> the black parade

>The Great Debate
I already seen like 4 of this threads you dumbass

0/10 and 0/10, /thread + finally proceed to kys for fuck ake

Bullets > Dookie > Three Cheers > American Idiot > Black Parade

BP: 2/10
AI: 1.5/10


It's like comparing 2 turds.

How can a man be so wrong about something holy shit

Go back to your cringe indie pop nu-male

has to be one guy spamming his pop punk/scene core phase right?
dude grow up

you like them both stop trying to look edgy on mu dont lie to me

Too late, doesn't count. However, Pat Stickles is on record as stating that Say Anything is A Real Boy is the best mid 00s pop punk album

pretty much this.

How the hell can people say the Black Parade is better than American Idiot? Granted, they're both the greatest Art Punk records of all time, and the Black Parade is a solid 9/10, but any album that has both Jesus of Suburbia and Homecoming, along with Boulevard of Broken Dreams and Wake Me Up When September Ends, beats the Black Parade by at least tenfold.

Never liked MCR - 0/10
American Idiot brought me into rock - 10/10

Liking MCR gets you laid more by 25 y/o qts.

>art punk
kek

AI has Whastername so it wins.

American 2000s music is fuckin trash. Stop shilling your shitty taste here

The real debate should be Three Cheers versus Dookie

pop punk is the epitome of numaleism you nu-male in denial