What is the best comeback album of all time?

What is the best comeback album of all time?

How the fuck is that a comback? If anything it was their commercial breakthough.

...

...

>last album released 2 years earlier
>comeback

...

Scott Walker - Climate Of Hunter

After years of irrelevance and critical deridement Scott Walker release Climate of Hunter as a way to express his musical endeavors after his "lost" period. It also gave him much needed critical reappraisal.

mbv
No contest

This

lol wtf

THIS is a comeback album

...

...

Bowie - The Next Day
Dylan - Time Out Of Mind
Neil Young - Freedom

The new atcq was better than midnight Marauders

Celtic Frost - Monotheist
Best album they ever made, best album of the year in their genre, one of the best meal albums of that decade.
No one else can say that.

ive given up on weezer after the red album, is this white one bring back any sense of their old stuff?

st. anger

...

How is Freedom a comeback album

you're wrong

>The record marks a return to the introspective and gloomygothic rockstyle the band had established in the early 1980s. As he neared the age of 30, vocalist and guitaristRobert Smithhad felt an increased pressure to follow up on the group's pop successes with a more enduring work.

still not a comeback. the cure were fucking huge and the disintegration singles continued that streak

After the death of Paul Raven, w/ their original bass player. Amazing return to form and AOTY 2010.

Yeah it pretty much sounds like a more modern version of the Blue Album. Definitely their best album since Pinkerton and I'm sad that Pacific Daydream goes back to being mostly dogshit.

This actually disproves the notion that it was a comeback

>Smith had felt an increased pressure to follow up on the group's pop successes

meaning they were already successful. Translated, it basically means he wanted to transition from disposable pop music to something more respected and critically acclaimed.

Does this count as a concept album?

this

They were almost irrelevant before this and this album revived not only them but the pop punk genre at that time.

No it's not, they hadn't left.

...

...

...

Not concept, comeback.

...