Would TFA have been better if it has directed George Lucas?
Would TFA have been better if it has directed George Lucas?
Ryder Gomez
Other urls found in this thread:
Christopher Torres
Probably
Henry King
He wrote an episode 7 treatment that they didn't use.
It revolved around young kids.
Fuck you all, George is a genius and i'd kill to see his episode 7.
Bentley Nguyen
Yes
Nolan Parker
It would've been less bland. Possibly worse, but certainly more worth the watch. Especially if we're just talking about him directing the same script that we got.
Jace Sullivan
what?
assuming you mean "if he directed, would it be good", the answer is an obvious no to those who understand anything about film making.
He's a shit director hack who lucked into his best creations due to the teams surrounding him.
He's a shit writer; no one should have to look harder than the prequels and their plots/dialogues, though I do enjoy a lot of the over-arcing plots he designed.
He's a fantastic creative idea man.
But he's a shit director. He's horrible with actors and crew, and the mess of the prequel films, like em or not, prove this.
Mason Ramirez
>But he's a shit director.
'no'
amazing visual storyteller
Angel Sullivan
That has nothing to do with him.
The behind the scenes of any Star Wars film demonstrates he hardly constructed any of the imagery responsible for the placement in our hearts. He just kinda had ideas like "let's do a funeral scene, they'll cry here", then other artists you're neglecting came in, designed and animated everything on CGI.
Oh and that has very little to do with what a director's real role is.
So the answer is still no, he's a shit director, but nice try.
James Evans
>He's a shit writer
People say the same of Joyce and Shakespeare, it really is the ultimate plebfilter.
Jacob Gray
Yes it wouldn't have been an SJW advertisement.
Lucas Allen
>That has nothing to do with him.
stopped reading there
learn what a director does
Carter Ramirez
>Would TFA have been better if it has directed George Lucas?
not necessarily, TFA's script is completely inept. Completely.
At the very least it would have had a better art direction but you can't really make a better TFA while keeping it's script.
Better packaging sure, but with the same shit product inside.
Colton Price
...
Grayson Ortiz
youtube.com
Even after two years, I still find it shocking how accurate this is.
Matthew Green
Directed? Probably not.
If the story, characters, and worlds were all created and overseen by him? Absolutely. Star Wars was at its best (the OT, TCW) when Lucas was heavily involved, but not actually directing.
Caleb Watson
>It revolved around young kids.
>Fuck you all, George is a genius
lmao
There's no studio in the world, not even his own, that would have let him make another movie, he's fucking cancer
Jeremiah Campbell
...
Jacob Moore
I hate to break this to you, my ANTIFA edgelord friend, but Star Wars is a franchise primarily made FOR KIDS despite the current management caring way too much about demonizing white men.
Levi Wilson
It could not be 'worse' than TFA since TFA is nor bad nor good, it's literally pure business void.
It would have been some shity wild ride anyway.
Jacob Peterson
>He wrote an episode 7 treatment that they didn't use.
>It revolved around young kids.
No.
Aaron Bell
thats babby tier though
Chase Hill
RIP society 1977-2013