Roger Waters is what made Pink Floyd good and the later albums without him are awful
Roger Waters is what made Pink Floyd good and the later albums without him are awful
Elijah Cooper
Other urls found in this thread:
Caleb Thompson
by that logic, his solo albums should be great but nooooo they are dogshit
Levi Jackson
In other news: fire burns and water is wet
Blake Cox
Agreed but is absolutely right. Waters-era Floyd is godlike, but his solo material is a bit too "let's all change the world".
Gilmour just wants to make quality music. For these reasons Gilmour>Waters in terms of solo material. Although both obviously pale in comparison to any era Floyd.
Asher Harris
The Wall, The Final Cut, and his solo albums were almost solely made by him and they were awful. TFC was ok and The Wall had some ok music that he didn't even write. He has writing credits for most of Floyd because he wrote the lyrics so often but really he's a horrible musician.
Gabriel Bailey
Your Mom is a horrible musician when she tried to play my Skin Flute last night.
Blake Walker
>The Wall
>Awful
Isaiah Cox
na
Aaron Gonzalez
Yeah but some people still think High Hopes is a good song
Liam Green
>the wall
>awful
Can this meme just fucking die already
Justin Sanchez
this
The Virgin Waters vs The Chad Barret
David Hughes
This is wrong.
What made Pink Floyd good is the junction of Waters and Gilmour.
Waters's solo albums lack Gilmour's mellow, soft voice and guitar playing.
Gilmour's solo albums (and Pink Floyd's later works) lack Waters's raw playing, compositions, and lyrics.
However, Waters's Amused to Death, Radio KAOS, and Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking are very good albums.
Levi Price
dude my dad died when I was young:the album fucking sucks
Brayden Butler
Richard Wright was the best member of Pink Floyd and every album they released after WYWH sucked
Jack Martin
C H A D B A R R E T T
Jason Hall
Reminder that people only hate The Division Bell because it shows that Pink Floyd doesn't need Roger Waters to make a good album.
Tyler Johnson
all the best songs have richard wright as the main composer faggot.
Benjamin Taylor
this is basically what i was getting at My favorite song of theirs anymore is Summer 68.
Saucer to Dark Side is best floyd
Chase Gray
Animals and WYWH are both better than DSotM
Ayden Hughes
dude I judge albums by oversimplifying its lyrical themes:your opinion sucks
Gabriel Kelly
it's pretty bland though, there's only two good songs in it
Owen Parker
THIS. Waters and Gilmour together are what made Floyd. Even though a majority of The Wall was written by Waters, the album wouldn't be what it is without Gilmour.
Matthew Campbell
>Poles Apart
>Marooned
>A Great Day For Freedom
>Wearing The Inside Out
>Coming Back to Life
>High Hopes
>only two good songs
Wyatt Anderson
Marooned and High Hopes are the only good songs. Everything else ranges from bad to mediocre.
Carson Brown
>not liking Wearing The Inside Out
what's it like being a faggot?
Xavier Young
Dogs of War is a good song, though.
Isaiah Perez
lol
Logan Cruz
forgot Lost For Words
youtube.com
it's even about waters
Brayden Butler
Popular things are bad >:^(
Adam Morris
What about Meddle? Dark Side? WYWH?
All the early 70s albums are the best PF has to offer and it's because there was creative input from all band members.
agreed
rick wright was a druggie
Juan Gutierrez
Pink Floyd was at its peak with equal controlinution from each of the members. I will agree that Waters leaving was the killing blow to the band, and thet weren't able to maintain their quality with his departure.
Angel Martinez
*contribution
Fucking phoneposting
Owen Morris
Syd Barrett is what made Pink Floyd good and the later albums without him are awful
Jonathan Allen
>chad
Thomas Miller
>>>/deviantart/
Landon Cook
*tips fedora*
Ryder Gutierrez
Syd Barrett is what made Pink Floyd good and the later albums without him are awful
Christian Campbell
both correct, but let's not the forget the magic ambience rick provided.
Christian Rivera
agreed. also, I googled controlinution.
back to Sup Forums
Juan Rivera
atom heart mother is the best
madcap laughs is the best solo album, better than most PF albums
Christopher Perry
Agreed
Levi Bailey
>beats the shit out of gf with music instruments, gets pussy anyways
>doesn't even know how much LSD he is on
>refuses to conform to studio etiquette
>has no clue whether he's still in the band or not
Joshua Hall
And yet, the only thing Mr. Waters here is going to be remembered for is starring in that movie with Cher and those bikers.
Aaron Perez
Spotted the virgins