ITT: 10/10 debut albums
ITT: 10/10 debut albums
Matthew Williams
Parker Edwards
Death From Above 1979 - You're a Woman, I'm a Machine (2004)
Juan Thomas
...
Ryder Ortiz
wonder what Syd would think about every so often when the smoke cleared for a few moments
William Fisher
...
Caleb Anderson
...
Christian Price
Kek
Jordan Martinez
...
Cameron Rivera
this and this
/thread
Matthew Price
...
Wyatt Parker
...
Zachary Powell
Drone Logic
Gabriel Anderson
...
Josiah Hernandez
...
Brayden Gonzalez
...
Sebastian Mitchell
Scott 4
Adrian Davis
...
Mason Russell
...
Carter Carter
kicking roger's ass, probably
Asher James
op said 10/10 not 11/10
Nathan Baker
so tru
Closer, better or inferior?
Adrian Gonzalez
depends on my mood but now i'm gonna say better
Benjamin Fisher
hahahah same.
do you enjoy the works of New Order or nah
Camden Williams
i do yeah. i think it's the melancholy of their music that appealing to me for both bands
it's incredible how influential joy division and new order managed to be in quite separate ways
Logan Rogers
imo New Order's different in the way that half the stuff they sing about is absolute shit, it doesn't have to have a meaning if you don't want.
but it definitely reflects Joy Division and Ian Curtis, e.g. Bizzare Love Triangle could depict Curtis' affair and relationship with his wife.
Asher Long
how cute you two should have sex
Easton Sanchez
ty ty
Nolan Ross
yeah that's true, they'd all be the first to admit none of them are nearly as good at writing songs as ian
apparently they found it really difficult initially to write songs after ian died because of how important he'd become to the band. peter hook compared said he was kind of like a conductor for them during rehearsals and jamming sessions. and not only that he seemed really important for the band's actual style and persona
Alexander Reed
yeah i read that Curtis didn't write the music, he 'spotted it'. he sat on the sidelines and knew what worked.
Liam Fisher
...
Robert Murphy
yes
Hell yes
If you added Half the World Away and Whatever it would be 11/10
Jack Long
Piper is an 8
Andrew Lewis
Sometimes I wonder what kind of songs they would have to put on Be Here Now to make it acclaimed by the critics.
Gavin Bell
COME ON, GET IT NOW
Brayden Lee
...
Brayden Torres
Honestly most of the songs aren't that bad (DYKWIM and The Girl in the Dirty Shirt are actually pretty good, especially the 2017 edit of DYKWIM), just remove the 15 million overdubs and shorten them. Maybe add Stay Young, and definitely cut All Around the World and Stand by Me.
Owen Campbell
AND THE SUNLIGHT SHINING THROUGH THE CRACK IN THE WINDOW PANE
Bentley Parker
Also, the GMEX version of Fade-In Out is a masterpiece.
Jaxson Cruz
Oasis sucks.
Jack Jones
That's your opinion. I'm cool with that, d'you know what I mean?
James Morgan
Wish Noel re edited the entire album like DYKWIM.
>more reasonable length
>audible bass
>less overdubs
I reckon he could easily cut around 25 minutes off and make it a single LP, if he did that it'd easily be the third-best oasis album.
Grayson Davis
No. Fuck you.
Aiden Hall
I'm shocked, you're such a grown-up dude.
Levi Ramirez
Frances the Mute is their 11/10 though
Jaxon Wright
...
Lucas Hughes
Lol this is in no way a 10
Nathan Hall
...
Nicholas Lewis
these kids are geeks but they have a vision
Isaiah Gomez
YUP
Dylan Watson
Fucking SMASHER 12/10 and in 1966 at that.
Gavin Perez
...
Charles James
Not their debut
Levi Parker
definitely yes
probably the only Sabbath album I keep coming back to and relisten
Anthony Myers
...
Matthew Martin
Fucking SMASHER 12/10 and in 1966 at that.
Robert Flores
Great 10/10 who cares what says.
Angel Green
SOMEDAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY
Elijah White
...
Hudson Gutierrez
Pleb.
Nathaniel Watson
It's actually gotten better with age. At the time I felt like it sounded like every other Indie band around at the time and swerved it when it was all the hype but as the years have gone on I've grown to appreciate it more. It's certainly miles better than that shit that was their last album.
Camden Ross
Sup Forums is clogged with threads about Oasis and The Smiths on a daily basis but gives no love to the GOAT Manchester band. Sad!
Samuel Turner
tricky question
not a single album in existence deserves 10/10, debut or not
Isaiah Gutierrez
...
Michael Butler
t. le intellectual
Nicholas Murphy
His only good album
Bentley Morris
13th lins
Angel Ward
...
Gabriel Gomez
Yea
Wyatt Morales
all these
Isaac Rivera
...
Noah Sanchez
...
Leo Phillips
Kansas' debut and Blue Öyster Cult's debut were the shit
Andrew Torres
...
Joseph Ortiz
>2 good song
>10/10
Mason Roberts
...
Robert Reyes
>plebs and pseuds will deny this
Kayden Morales
...
Aaron Johnson
True.
Samuel Bell
go away, pop
Brandon Wilson
RE QUI EM
Josiah Harris
...
Chase Bailey
...
Anthony Ortiz
This was garbage compared to Astral Week and Moondance
Gavin Torres
...
Easton Jackson
These
Tyler James
SHE WAS 16 AND YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN
Jonathan Clark
i've always wondered if that is a girl bending over or a knee
Jace King
...
Jason Cooper
Do you not know what nardwuar is
Jackson Fisher
Contrarian twat waffle.......
> has the hits
> must suck
> must be more obscure to be any good
foff
Bentley Reyes
i know of him, why is that relevant?
Austin Powell
He's got an interview with JC and Nick Valensi talking about this. It's a gals bum n that art wasn't allowed for the cover art releases outside of Europe
Aaron Perry
...
Brandon Roberts
oh, i never saw that one. Gonna check it out
Ryder Harris
I'VE GOT A BIKE YOU CAN RIDE IT IF YOU LIKE IT'S GOT A BASKET A BELL THAT RINGS AND THINGS TO MAKE IT LOOK GOOD
Joshua Williams
that's kind of cheating
Thomas Murphy
yes
no
Asher Clark
not their debut, they had an album or two before saturation, which is an 8.9, not a 10 btw.
Hunter Carter
Not 10/10 but very good nonetheless
Hudson Hernandez
...