Who was really better?

Who was really better?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=VGa8VWszuWo
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Arnold of course. Silly question

Arnold.

Arnold has never given a good performance, at least Stallone has rocky, creed, and Rambo

Stallone is the better actor and directed some great movies.

Arnie is more popular though.

Arnold

though Sly gets bonus points for writing his own shit

>Arnold has never given a good performance

Leave

Predator was pretty much the perfect film

this

sly

arnold
>successful brick laying business, became a millionaire on his own
>xth time mr. olympia
>movie star
>marries into the closest thing america has to royalty
>becomes governor of California

stallone
>movie star
>directed some

Competent actor and director vs bodybuilding action star turned governor.

Rocky franchise, Rambo, Copland, judge dredd, cliffhanger, demolition man, tanto and cash, cobra.

Commando, terminator, total recall, running man, predator, Conan, kindergarten cop, jingle all the way

>sly
good actor sometimes
good director sometimes

>arnold
shitty actor
shitty politician
couldn't direct his own penis to his wife and impregnated a mexican maid

>Stallone: 3 Oscar nominations
>Arnold: 0 Oscar nominations

Arnold easily.

>Arnold Olympia titles: 7
>Stallone Olympia titles: 0

I forgot to add that Stallone is the better actor and filmaker and writer though. Arnold was just good at life for the most part.

stallone is more talented when it comes to all things film, directing acting writing etc.

arnold is unique though.

Im going for stallone

oh im sorry, that makes his movies so much better

>arnold fans

DUDE PUMPING IRON LMAO

>stallone is more talented when it comes to all things film, directing acting writing etc
no

I think Stallone is a better writer, but that's because I know he wrote one good movie while I'm not sure if Schwarzenegger has written any movies at all. Schwarzenegger is probably a better actor though.

Some arnold fans are homosexuals, deal with it, it's 2016

posting a picture doesnt disprove me

what has arnie written better than rocky?

fuck all

I don't even recognize all those.

>combine every living action star into one movie
They're stupid and awfully written but fun flicks. I doubt anyone but Stallone could've gotten everyone in those films.

>the closest thing america has to royalty
>calling a political crime family royalty
never understood this meme

Arnold is a better actor.

Sly is a better writer and director. He also gets bonus points for having hot daughters.

You should leave then

why

>Doesnt know Arnold
>Posting

I'm aware of who he is I just haven't seen all his films.

expendables is by default a cheap nostalgia money-grabber, are you stupid?

arnold have done far more shit flicks than stalone, and he did it only for a paycheck, guys not even able to write a stupid flick. The difference is Stallone have the capacity to do more than that, he's not a limited peanut brain clown with charisma

Stallone all the way.

Stallone, since he has had good movies that didn't require putting all the acting responsibility on the rest of the cast.

Stallone was the better actor.

But Arnie had more good movies than Sly.

...

Dolph Lundgren

Schwarzenegger has higher peaks.

Stallone is far more consistent.

That said I don't think Arnie has been in anything quite as good as Demolition Man, and Cobra slightly edges Commando for 80's ludicrousness.

Stallone's easily the better actor and filmmaker, but Arnie's just so damn loveable. Also, a bad Stallone movie is usually just hard to watch, but even the worst of Arnie's filmography provides some entertainment value. A better face off would be Kurt Russell V Bruce Willis, imo

But Kurt Russell easily outshines Bruce.

Objectively incorrect.

Stallone did more than 'direct some.' He wrote Rocky as an unknown actor with very little credibility or reputation in the business, somehow got it made, and pushed it to great success, winning multiple Academy Awards including Best Picture.

I love Arnold and he is the best 'movie star' type since John Wayne but as a Hollywood figure, the totality of their careers taken into consideration, Stallone gets the edge for being more creative.

He *nose* crime

>creed
>good
kys

sly has achieved more desu

Arnie is our boy.

>arnies 10/10's
terminator
t2
predator
true lies
total recall
commando

>sly's 10/10's
first blood

Only in film. Arnold was a fucking governor

You forgot Conan the Barbarian

>not one rocky on sly's list
Don't be a complete faggot

Has Sly ever had an IMAGINE scene?

No Maggie screenshot

Arnold's greatest movies are Terminator 2 and Commando. Stallone's are Rocky and Rambo.

I would say Stallone is better, though as a child I liked Arnold more.

it does, both are supposed to be the big buff dudes and arnold is a bigger, buffer dude

>No Conan the Barbarian

>Arnold was just good at life
He did what it took to accomplish his goals and he aimed high

Pic related

I preferred demolition man to any of the rocky flicks and there's no way any of them are 10/10

...

Pretty spot on

>Arnold's greatest movies are Terminator 2 and Commando.
Maggie was his best acting

>rocky iv not 1/10
you must be too young to remember the Cold War

He can't act. There's a reason his best movies are where he plays the strong silent type. There's nothing wrong with playing to your strengths, not everybody has to fucking reinvent themselves. Arnold has immense physical charisma.

they're both manlets

but to answer your question: Stallone imo is more talented but I love Arnold more.

The first Rocky won more accolades than any of those other movies you listed.

It is a 10/10 film.

...

Rambo 4 is the best film of this century

Stallone is objectively a better actor, but Arnold is so charismatic and has amazing comedic timing while being able to choose movies that play to those strengths. I can't imagine Stallone saying "Fuck YOU, asshole" in Commando, can you?

arnold is literally rebdit. he posts there, they have a boner for him, you see all the little american faggots squirming around like fags while talking about him.
>oMg ArNie iS BASED!!1111UPVOTE

he is also a dredful politician, actor and mediocre bodybuilder. stallone at least has some classic kino under his belt.

Arnold is superior.

>judge dredd
>demolition man
but these were garbage

>stallone competed in mr.olympia

Kys famalam

>come from some nowhere town in Austria to become the greatest bodybuilder of all time, a successful businessman, an A-list Hollywood action star, and governor of the most important state in the most important country in the world

the answer couldn't be more obvious

I like arnold better as a person but sly really is the most talented of the two.

I mean he wrote a bunch of his most successful movies.

Arnold was also the most buffed of the two, so theres that.

I admire and respect both pretty equally.
Both are self made men who did the hard work, laid everything on the line and reaped the benefits for it.
Arnie obviously got that star quality but Stallone equals that out by being a true auteur by producing, writing and even directing his own shit.

>this will never be a Contra movie

kms

TIL: Sylvester Stallone has a 160 tested IQ.

I don't believe any of this IQ shit for actors.

>there are people in this thread right now that dont know rocky 4 ended the cold war

Anyone seen Escape Plan with Arnie and Stallone?
What a pile of wasted potential, such a cool concept but an awful movie.

Arnold has 135 iq. So obviously sly is better

>demolition man
>garbage
I can't believe I'm sharing my board with fucking plebes like this.

>not shooting Rocky on a Canon Sony A7ii

What a pleb

This shit is pure 90s kino

>Implying T2 was better than Terminator t

Stallone is capable of some quality dramatic acting.

Arnold is pure popcorn action and with serviceable comedy ability.

If you want a Big Guy(4u) doing popcorn summer action movie things. Arnold is the best choice.

If you want your big guy to give you some feels. Stallone is the pick.

What makes them fun kike

>Stallone is the better dramatic actor
Uuh
Ever seen the Rambo breakdown?
Sucked out all the emotion of the scene. I mean I like Stallone but come on

Wtf dude, total recall is clearly superior than denolition man

Rocky didnt win Best Picture because of its fighting

Stallone is a film-maker and this is a film board so he wins. If this were /fit/ arnie would be better.

The Governator

Stallone has more creative talent and is a better actor but arnie made more entertaining movies

Better than both of them every were.

Arnold in his prime was a demigod with an incredible streak of movies tailored perfectly to him.
My impression though is that Sly is more intelligent and more talented. He is the one of the two that wrote and produced most the movies that made himself iconic.
And he is the only one of the two that didn't wash up with the old age and still maintain his charisma.

>couldn't direct his own penis to his wife and impregnated a mexican maid

Funny but the episode of Tales from the Crypt that he directed was great.

Terminator was the GOAT physical performance.

>Schwarzenegger has higher peaks.
"Rambo: First Blood" is the only film in their entire combined filmographies that can truly be said to be kino.

arnold had better roles
stallone was the better actor

youtube.com/watch?v=VGa8VWszuWo

It really isn't.

>Leave Sup Forums for 5 minutes

>Rocky is suddenly not kino

what'd I miss?