If it had been finished, it'd have been better than Pet Sounds? (Based on the 2011 version)
If it had been finished, it'd have been better than Pet Sounds? (Based on the 2011 version)
Grayson Powell
Grayson Davis
nah theres o a lotta duds on here desu
Jace Reyes
It would've been even better than Sgt. Pepper.
Grayson Scott
...I thought it was finished.
David Rodriguez
It will NEVER be finished.
Easton Young
>(Based on the 2011 version)
There's the problem
Grayson Turner
obvi. is it really a discussion?
Austin Long
The 2011 version is the most finished version of the 60's with The Beach Boys. You can have an idea
Jack Hall
Absolutely. That's a big if though. In a way I'm glad it was never released in any kind of definitive edition so we can all make our own 'perfect' versions and argue about which is best.
Evan Morgan
Sounded pretty finished to me, it’s a great album.
Anthony Smith
Some Youtube versions of SMiLE are fucking amazing
Kevin Ramirez
>The 2011 version is the most finished version of the 60's with The Beach Boys.
It's also the least accurate
Isaac Parker
Pet sounds already is better than Sgt. Peppers
Blake Gonzalez
Like what?
Sgt. Pepper isn't very good to begin with.
This.
The 2011 version is fantastic.
Connor Turner
dated trash
Tyler Turner
>The 2011 version is fantastic.
It's also unrealistic
>Sgt. Pepper isn't very good to begin with.
Why?
Jack Gomez
Nah PS is a good album to just chill to in the background while Smile has too much cerebral tracks.
Elements Fire is still my all-time favorite BB song though
Jordan Ross
>Elements Fire is still my all-time favorite BB song though
Its not a song though
Lucas Sullivan
listening to that song makes me understand what a bad acid trip feels like
Chase Turner
~movement
Zachary Price
>It's also unrealistic
This. It's very good, but SMiLE realistically would have been a single album that looked something like the SLN reconstruction.
That's probs a big reason Brian had such a hard time fashioning it into a finished product. Too many ideas.
Chase Bennett
The true best album (after pet sounds)
Owen Hughes
What's the accurate representation?
Cameron Cruz
To an album that was never even close to being completed?
Xavier Adams
start here: albumsthatneverwere.blogspot.ca
that's one of the better attempts.
Kevin Wright
>albumsthatneverwere.blogspot.ca
yeah SLN's version is pretty close to how it wouldve ended up back then. its different after hearing the 2011 version because SLN would cut out extra choruses or tags from songs slimming them down to 60's length.
lastly, and not really SLN's fault, but hearing The Elements:Fire without the Ooooh Ooohs just feels lacking
Joseph Sanchez
>but hearing The Elements:Fire without the Ooooh Ooohs just feels lacking
That's shit that was digitally pitch shifted into the song in the first place though. It was never recorded for Fire. It doesn't belong.
Cooper Barnes
I know, thats why I understand why it wasn't included. Anachronistic or not, I think including it in there (whether the 2011 mix or inspired by the 2004) really enhances an otherwise repetiive track
Jacob King
By digitally stretching the wavforms of the vocals to fit an unrelated track? It sounds bad.
Alexander Flores
I don't like the Heroes and Villains mix he uses
Zachary Walker
Why not? That's the best one and probably would have been on SMiLE.
Carson Hernandez
good opinion
Julian Hall
Post reccs bls
Sebastian Bennett
MOK is a good one
Ryan Nguyen
Too short
Juan Wilson
>twelve songs
>40 minutes
>too short