Pure brilliance or pretentious schlock?

Pure brilliance or pretentious schlock?

cant it be both

comes off as pretentious schlock nowadays

The first one.

PORQUENOLOSDOS

Has like 4 interesting tracks, rest is boring self indulgent wank

It's a good album.

Album brilliance

Not necessarily inherent particular musical brilliance. The album is far greater than each individual song picked apart.

Somewhere in between.

gahbage it ain't good

>Pure brilliance or pretentious schlock?
half and half probably

Niether. Just buttprog

Two word review: SHIT SANDWICH!

Damn good tasteful 80s dadrock. The live album is great and includes "What Shall We Do Now?" that was in the film but not in the studio album.

nu-male hipster cocksucker detected

It should have just been

1. In The Flesh?
2. The Thin Ice
3. Another Brick In the Wall
4. Mother
5. Hey You
6. Comfortably Numb
7. The Show Must Go On
8. In The Flesh
9. Run Like Hell
10. The Trial
11. Outside the Wall

rest should have just been the movie soundtrack.

Fantastic album.

Protip: people who say "wank" / "pretentious" aren't actually saying anything negative about the music and are largely just socially signalling

>Not including Young Lust

Contrarians like to hate, but it's brilliant for its time

apart from In The Flesh the lyrics dont really interest me

no Goodbye Blue Sky or Young Lust?
other than that this is perfect