5 > 4 > R1 > 6 > 7 >>> 1 > 3 >>>>> 2

5 > 4 > R1 > 6 > 7 >>> 1 > 3 >>>>> 2

This is the objective ranking. There is no need to debate this.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=YnAvtozSnN8
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

>Anything Disney over the masterworks of the visionary George Lucas

lmaotbqhfam

>1 above 3

change that and it's solid

1 is better than 3. No need to change anything. You simply can't beat the comfiness of the phantom menace.

Objective ranking:

>5
>4
>R1
>7
>6
>Last 30 minutes of 3
>Holiday Special
>Ewok Adventure
>Droids: C3P0 comes out of the closet episode
>Kinect Star Wars dance sequences
>2
>This video: youtube.com/watch?v=YnAvtozSnN8
>1

wow, i mostly agree with you.

>You simply can't beat the comfiness of the phantom menace.

Let me guess, you were a kid when Phantom Menace came out so now you have fond feelings of nostalgia for it? Because it's crap

It doesn't make any sense and Jake Lloyd is terrible, but it at least has a few cool sequences like the Darth Maul fight and the pod race. I've really never understood the "rots is the good prequel" meme; it's honestly almost as bad as clones.

I second this.

5 > 4 > 6 > 3 > R1 > 7 = 2 =1

Simple as that

>shit, new star wars is coming out, we need a cool fight scene
>i know! will make the 2 jedi fight a mysterious sith who has little to no background and if he were to be cut from the movie, the movie would still make sense!
>we'll make them do cool flips and acrobatics to disguise this fact

Flip 3 and R1

About the size of it.

5 > 4 > r1> 6 >>> 1 > 3 >>>>> 7 > 2

You were close OP

4 > 5 > 6 = 3 > 7 > 1 > RO > 2

Revenge of the Sith is terrible and only worth watching for a few meme-tier moments.

How does anyone like the never-ending Anakin/Obi-Wan fight? It's all this flash but still incredibly boring.

7 is a Marvel flick and shouldn't even be in the ranking. Otherwise it's solid.

5>4>6>7>>>>>>=2=3

Haven't seen Meme One yet sorry faggots

5>4=6>R1>7>>>>>1

>1>3>>>>

?????

You got it pretty right, although 4 and 5 should be equal. 4 is the better movie unless youre looking at empire with the context of there being a whole trilogy

phantom menace deserves to be above ROTS for introducing one of the only good prequel planets (naboo) and actually having some real sets and practical effects. The last fight wasnt as ridiculously overdone as the rest in the prequels either so that was good

I dont know why do people consider ROTS the best prequel apart from hot anakin. It has a few good scenes (practically every time hayden christensen has to act with his face) and things with sheev in them, but apart from that its a weak movie that does more damage to characters like darth vader and obi wan than anything else in the prequels

>rating R1 over 6

Yeah, faggots said the same about TFA at least a month after it released, and now they barely rate it above the prequels.

I've never seen Star Wars, but seeing all these threads on Sup Forums have me interested. Which versions/editions are the best to view, and in what order? Is the Extended Universe worth getting into at all?

I grew up on Star Trek because my dad would talk about how Star Wars was for pussies and Star Trek had real stories and hot alien babes. Is this correct in the eyes of a SW fan?

>first and third point
>complains that his vidyashit is better than 1

>all these rankings with Rogue One in top 3

Nice

5>R1>4>7>6=3>1>2

If by "Nice" you mean "Lemming nostalgic schmucks and shills" then yes.

Episode 1 takes place so many years before anything relevant happens that I'm willing to give it a pass, whereas 3 shits all over characters that I love and Vader's transition seems forced as fuck. TPM also had the cool podracing scene, and the Darth Maul fight.

>objective
stay there next time newfag

Widely-accepted, standard ranking:
V > IV > VI > VII > R1 > III > II > I

My own ranking:
IV > V > VI > R1 > VII > III > I > II

5 > 4 > R1 = 6 = 3 > 1 > 2 > 7

This.

I rewatched R1 today after not really liking it the first time and I have to say...it's a fucking goddamn masterpiece compared to Force Awakens

how the fuck do people like 3. Episode 1 is the only prequel that's an actually a space/fantasy/adventure flick

>7
>rogue one

I'm not against disney as a principal but they could at least try with their movies.

This. ROTS fucking ruins Vader and the Emperor as characters. The Phantom Menace is the least offensive prequel.

>emperor can't even beat Windu

What the fuck was up with that. How was he so powerful with the force he could cloud the mind of the whole fucking council but he couldn't beat Windu

>inb4 he lost on purpose

You're telling me.... a guy melted his fucking face off, on purpose?

>Anakin's arc in episode 3

Not even worth talking about how bad it is.

6 > 5 > 4 > 3 > 2 > 7 > 1

>6 above 5 and 4
>3 above 7
>2 above anything
>he hasn't seen Rogue One
Pleb.

R1 and 7 are terrible films though.

>Rogue One is good meme

>worse than "I don't like sand"
>YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE
>UN LIMOHTED POWAAAAAH!!!
>Jar Jar
Are you even trying? Fucking wasted trips.

>5 above 4
If anything,they are equal

5>4>6=R1>3>7>1>2

Empire is full of absolute 10/10 moments.
>I am your father
>The cave scene
>Han lashing out and punching Lando after being sold out
>"I love you."
>"I know."

>I'm an edgy contrarian to objectivism meme

Please explain how R1 was "objectively good"

>solid visuals
>works as a prequel to the first movie
>great emotional pacing
>great emotional payoffs
etc...
Overall an enjoyable movie. You'd have to be mad at life to not even feel indifferent toward the movie but hate it.

5>4>3>r1>2>1>7>>>Objectively correct

>critical success
>commercial success
>audience success
Different poster but it's not that hard, user. It is "good" by any metric used to measure the quality of a film.
You can personally dislike it - but when the majority viewers of the film, professional or otherwise, like the movie, and it is a box-office success, sitting with your fingers in your ears chanting "nah it's not good you can't prove it" is just silly.

>calling people newfags on the 'chon
How's winter break?

>I'm old and blinded by nostalgia so anything new is bad

5 = 4 > 6 = 7 >>>>>> 3 >> RO > 2 > 1

objective fact

5>R1>4>7>6>3>dogshit dildo>1>AIDS>2

Its because they're fucking retards user. Pay them no mind.

>1. The Empire Strikes Back
>2. Star Wars
>3. Return of the Jedi
>4. Rogue One
>5. The Force Awakens
>6. Revenge of the Sith
>7. Attack of the Clones
>8. The Phantom Menace
>9. The Clone Wars (Pilot Film)

R1>4=5>6=7>3=1>2

Original trilogy is shit except for Empire. Prequels are objectively shit. Force Awakens is decent as long as you look at it as a basic retelling of Ep4. Rogue One was average, but gets bonus points for concluding the story in one movie instead of trying to turn it into a franchise.

From a pure enjoyment ranking, not an objectively good ranking because I know Empire is higher.

A New Hope
Return of the Jedi
Empire Strikes Back
Rogue One
The Force Awakens
Star Wars Holiday Special while stoned
Revenge of the Sith
Attack of the Clones
Phantom Menace

4 > 5 = 6 > 3 > R1 > 7 > 1 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 2

Oh, damn.

I forgot the Ewok movies and the Holiday Special.

Who cares, I only listed those which are part of the Disney canon and not those which are exclusively Legends material.

>Disney fanfiction over any of the originals

Can people in the thread explain why they enjoyed R1?

I just saw it and was late to the first week discussion.

4 > 5 >>> 7 > 6 > R1 >>> 3 >>> 1 >>> 2

I liked the last act where things finally got fun and everyone died.

Most of the movie is pretty bad if we're being honest. But still not prequels bad.

Every prequel is better than 7. you could maybe argue that R1 is better than 1 or 2, but that's pushing it

if you disagree, you're a redditor

3 = 4 = 5
Kino Star Wars Trilogy

6 if you want more comfyness and an ending

1 if you want to experience comfy Win XP kino era

2 if you want an absolute Kamino cinema

half of 1 = 2 = 3 = half of 4
Obi-Wan Kino

TFA, R1 if you're too desperate for SW fanfiction

This. I was actually surprised Disney had the balls to kill everyone.

5>6>4>1>3The rest I don't give a fuck about TFA bored me to sleep

>R1 > 6

Shill harder bitch

Objective af

Watch them in order of production, the Blu Rays are honestly fine but if you're autistic about watching the original historical cinematic versions, they can be found online

EU has a lot of really cool shit but a lot of really shit shit. Don't know where to start really

>this many buzzwords
You need to take a break from this site you fuckwit

5 > 4 > 6 >>>>>>>> R1 > 3 > 7 >>>>>>> 1 > 2

Don't even try to debate me

Anyone who liked Rogue One more than the prequels is a fucking idiot. It's prequel-tier. Better than one and two, but about the same as 3. Fight me.

Shill harder bitch

>inb4 he lost on purpose
But he did, user. And he didn't melt his face off, he melted off his Sith disguise which he used to mask the corrupted zombie face he had developed over years of using the Dark Side. The Emperor face was always the real face, whereas the Palpatine face was more or less a Force illusion to make him appear normal and draw suspicion away from him. This is canon.

4 > 5 >>> 6 >>> 3 > 2 > 1 >>> 7

How? The characters in Rogue One weren't characters. They were cardboard cutouts to fulfill a purpose. It wasn't ballsy because they all needed to die 8n order to make a New Hope make sense. Jesus fuck you fanboys are retarded.

OT > PT > Disney's SW

You can't argue with me.

>prequels are good
>Rogue One and TFA are good

Is this some kind of meme?

I was just expecting the ending to be as cliche as the rest of the movie. I almost fell asleep watching it.

>they're about the same but if you like one more than the other you're an idiot

This may be off-topic, but I didn't want to start ANOTHER Star Wars thread.

Is there any home release of the original 1977 Star Wars movie, without "A New Hope" in the title? Besides the stupidly expensive DVD version? I know every VHS release has it, and most laserdiscs do. I've heard about a laserdisc version that doesn't have it. Can anybody confirm?

5>4>6>7>3>1>2

This is fair in my opinion.

>Haven't seen Rogue One

4>5>6>R1>7>3>1>2

I haven't seen Clone Wars (nor do I expect that I will).

>he wasn't a kid in 99'

Jesus, how old are you?

Canon Series
The good seasons of TCW>5>4>3>6>1>2>The bad seasons of TCW(including the film)

Spin offs and ascended fanfics
Rogue One>Hollyday special>Rebels>Star Wars droids>TFA

5 > 4 > 6 > 7 > R1 > 3 > 1 > 2

Tier 1 - IV and V
Tier 2 - VI
Tier 3 - VII and R1
Tier 4 - III
Tier 5 - I and II

As long as your order follows those five tiers (and most in this thread seem to), you're fine by me.

Correct answers

Official ranking
4>5>6>Christmas special>Pornparodies>all other Star Wars content

4 >>> 5 > 6 >3 >> 2 = 1 haven't seen rogue one but probably near episode 7.

Pornparodies? What?
I need to see this, for purely research purposes of course. How many are there?

Yup.

1>4>5>2>3>6>R1>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

>and actually having some real sets and practical effects
hello, you need to go back.

How is Rogue One better than the prequels at all? Is this a brand new meme? it's fucking trash

someone explain please

VII was honestly the fucking worst

seriously screw that piece of shit

Kek spoken.