It really isn’t that good

It really isn’t that good...
Also what a stupid name

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=JnPntwwxuq8
youtube.com/watch?v=7Rr7th61VOk
youtube.com/watch?v=O4kUt0u1qs0
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

I agree on both counts. So many cuts bleed into each other as generic buttrock.

The definition of an album that's more than the sum of its parts.

The singles are good. Probably would have been a solid 8/10 if it was one disc. Siamese Dream is their only great album.

they could have cut out half the songs and had a really good single-disc album.

Yes! You all get it!

Ditto on SD being their only great album. Mellon Collie is overweight.

what a terrible group of people you all are.

oh and you too. Pisces Iscariot and Gish shit all over SD

>It really isn’t that good
You're right, it's even better.

itt: soyboys

It's pretty good. But what I like about it the most is it's relatable, not necessarily because it has many "fuuck can't believe they just did that" moments. There is something to be said about simplicity

>Mellon collie is melancholy turned into a name
I can’t believe I only realized that just now

...

double albums are a mistake to be honest

It is kinda bloated but still doesn't have a bad song on it

adore was a commercial failure because it wasn't as grandiose in scope as mc. had they released mc as two separate albums adore would have fared better in sales, and as a result machina would have been better fleshed out due to not having any record label pressure. releasing mc as a double album effectively killed the band's career

It does, though.

Name them.

We Only Come Out At Night for starters.

Siamese Dream has always been the better album

This, but unironically.

that one is good. the only song I don't like on Mellon Collie is Love

You're the one being mean and condescending

Bodies is a great track

It's great but Billy's nasally, irritating voice drags the whole thing down.

>tooooooNIIIIIIIIIIgggHHHHTTTTTTT

YOu are condescending as hell if you are shitting on this album FYI

Smashing Pumpkins are about as far from buttrock as you can get

I have Jellybelly, Fuck You (An Ode to No One), Love, Bodies, Stumbleine, and By Starlight deleted.

>hating Bodies, Stumbleine, and By Starlight
Not even mad just shaking my head

This, how can people like these vocals

Mellon Collie is an album full of embarrassing moments, but the "LOVE IS SUICIDE" part of Bodies is the worst. Stumbleine has great lyrics but the singing ruins it. By Starlight is like the even more overwrought cousin to Tonight, Tonight with its arrangement.

I do, though in retrospect I also like this
youtube.com/watch?v=JnPntwwxuq8

Pisces Iscariot all the way

that's a good hot take. kill yourself.

Sounds like I struck a nerve. Go on and keep your filler tracks, no skin off my nose.

Nigga Jellybelly is like top 5 MCIS songs. All those other songs are great too.

fixed it

>Crossed out Jellybelly, Bullet With Butterfly Wings, Muzzle, Porcelina of the Vast Oceans
>Kept Zero, Cupid De Locke and Here is No Why

Shame on you

Pisces Iscariot is amazing but SD is still the GOAT.
Gish is good but it's not even close to as good as SD, this one is just pure contrarianism.

>doesn't understamd that to truly love one must kill the self...

Hi pleb, maybe this is not the place for you, please go back to r e d d i t

Zero is pretty bad desu.

You're opinion isn't very good either faggot.

Siamese Dream SHITS all over this fuckin album.

This, only unironically.

...

Cupid De Locke is awesome??? and Zero is good not great but it wasn't worth crossing out. also the guitar solo is tight as fuck

Jellybelly and Bullet with butterfly wings are dumb horrible edgy 90s rock songs, Muzzle is boring and Porcelina is unlistenable drawn out fake prog rock garbage, to me anyway

Thanks for your opinions but I disgree and will not call you dribbling retards because it is unhealthy to do things like that haha

Mellon Collie has so much going for it.

I find revisiting and loving tracks that I used to hate after getting tired of the songs I used to like. And vice versa. Sure Siamese Dream is great and better in some parts and all, but for me the sheer variety of Mellon Collie is what makes it a winner.

I hate this cover so damn much

For the longest time I avoided this album because I thought it was some ITAOTS-tier indie cuckmusique because of the fucking cover

the vinyl cover is much nicer

(spoiler alert: the vinyl tracklist is also much better)

I always thought Mangum totally cribbed the aesthetic of the ITAOTS cover from Mellon Collie.

Machina and PI are my favorite Pumpkins albums desu

why even listen to SP if you don't like songs like these?

stop posting this image. nobody fucking agrees with it

>ITAOTS-tier indie cuckmusique
The actual fuck did he mean by this?

youtube.com/watch?v=7Rr7th61VOk
Best Pumpkins era coming through.

Not using guitars would automatically make one further from buttrock

80s Pumpkins were peak patrician

Billy needs to fucking remaster that shit and release an 80s Pumpkins comp

He really should, but most likely won't.

Also, Machina most underrated Pumpkins era

youtube.com/watch?v=O4kUt0u1qs0

I really hope the remasters eventually come out. Corgan hinted it was label cuckery that was holding it up.

Listen to the vinyl version

I remember when Sup Forums posted the share file of the vinyl rip. It was a different overall feel with the track order. I don't know which I prefer since I grew up with the original order.

The vinyl order is interesting but I think the album works better in it's 2 CD tracklisting. It's a constant push and pull of emotions that I think is more indicative of what the album meant to convey