Should Disney remake the prequels?
And who would you cast?
Should Disney remake the prequels?
Liam Nelson
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Xavier Allen
Same people, except this time we should give them a better script
Matthew Thompson
Do a Star Trek remake alternate/Mirror Universe.
Vader is the most compelling character in Star Wars. Aside from the bots ;-)
Austin Richardson
No. If Disney does anything to the prequels I will absolutely REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE
Sebastian White
No, but a special edition upgrading the CG elements and some extensive ADR work to smooth out the clunkier line reads would be welcome.
Noah Walker
this
Joshua Sanders
Disney will wait until Lucas dies.
Jeremiah Adams
Should Disney recast you with a more appealing, enjoyable person, and how should they dispose of you in the process?
Sebastian Turner
Fuck this. Leave Lucas alone. The flaws are a part of history now. There is still plenty to appreciate.
It's already stupid that they had to explain the deathstar weakness in Rogue One.
Ian Roberts
I don't think they're good at all, but no.
Joseph Jackson
the prequels can be fixed with better editing
Owen Gomez
Disney will wait until they can stop printing "new" star wars films and make mad profit off it
Ian Gonzalez
I never had a problem understanding why the Death Star had a goddamn exhaust port, even when I was eight. It's the most obvious thing in the fucking world.
>If you shoot a missile down the exhaust port, it blows up the core
>It has an exhaust port to release all the energy it uses BLOWING UP PLANETS
John Lee
Nothing can save these movies. Search your feelings. You know it to be true.
Robert Baker
No.
They shouldn't even have made TFA or agreed to make a new set to begin with.
Gavin Reyes
This. Pisses me off that they have to say "whatever Lucas intended was bad, therefore we are going to put on this fedora hat and explain it as an intentional flaw by a rebellious engineer"
Parker Thomas
Listen you turd, the exhaust port makes perfect sense. What doesn't make sense is why an explosion would cause a chain reaction that'd blow up the entire station. Same thing happens in ESB, Luke throws a grenade in the AT-AT and the entire fucking head blows up. It doesn't make sense. We give it a pass because nostalgia, but it's stupid writing.
Asher Brown
But it does make sense. It was a one in a million shot that made using the force. Luke is a hero. He's the only one who could make the shot.
The AT AT is nitpicking. It's only bad writing because you are a contrarian and will always find something to bitch about.
Lucas is one of the greatest film makers of all time. Rogue One's attempts to fix these things shows how Disney just doesn't understand Lucas.
Lucas likes to show and not tell in his filmmaking. He wants things open to discussion. He doesn't want to explain everything away. This is why when he went into midichlorians it was horrible.
Jonathan Baker
I started replying to your post then realized you were joking. You got me. 8/10
Wyatt Richardson
Even if the exhaust port's flaw was intentional, it still took a good pilot with force sensitivity to get the shot off. The other guys couldn't do it, even with a computer! Galen Erso could have never predicted that.
Jaxson Richardson
I'm not joking.
Daniel Ramirez
>other guys couldn't do it, even with a computer!
It's not impossible, I use to bullseye womp-rats in my T-16 back home, and they're not much bigger than 3 meters.
Isaac Thompson
Well, you should be. Anybody that says Lucas is one of the greatest film makers of all time unironically is mentally ill.
Luis Hughes
No, you're just an underage faggot.
Lucas revolutionized the filmmaking and special effects in the OTs... as well as made science fiction popular on the big screen.
Lucas revolutionized CGI in PT and began the largest studio in that field.
Brayden Edwards
>Fuckin' sandy haired desert dwelling twink thinks he can talk to me like that.
John Collins
>Lucas revolutionized CGI in PT
Asher Ross
This isn't even one of the major CGI scenes you nitpicking faggot
Colton Myers
>one of the major CGI scenes
Samuel Garcia
This proves my point. This scene was groundbreaking for 2002.
Ethan Morales
Nah. This was groundbreaking 2002 CGI. Not that cartoon crap.
Chase Long
Not really fare comparing the two because they both were groundbreaking.
Lucas' CGI was much better than anything done in LOTR though.
youtube.com
Josiah Edwards
>Lucas' CGI was much better than anything done in LOTR though.
nah
Michael Evans
This isn't shit compared to the PT. Sorry.