Best: Only in Dreams

>Best: Only in Dreams
>Runner-up: Sweater Song
>Worst: Holiday
>Overrated: My Name is Jonas
>Underrated: No One Else

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=YHU99chOX1M&feature=youtu.be
youtu.be/2V2abwkiRvk
youtube.com/watch?v=dQVNQVvyDWg
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

>SAY IT AIN'T SO

>listen to this and pinkerton for the first time in probably a decade the other day
>laugh about the fact that Rivers Cuomo is a proto soy boy who feminists would probably accuse of being a male feminist solely to get pussy

Good shit though. Pinkerton especially was pretty much daily listening for me back in high school. Glad he had the guts to come out with an album that cringingly honest, but god damn as an adult I can't help but be embarassed on his behalf for thinking that songs about daydreaming of little japanese girls masturbating were what 'the kids' wanted back in 1997. Glad the album is recognized as a classic now, but I definitely don't blame people for thinking he was a creepy nerd faggot back then

>Best: Only in Dreams
>Runner-up: My Name is Jonas
>Worst: Holiday
>Overrated: Say It 'Aint So
>Underrated: The World Has Turned and Left Me Here

fixed

>2nd best the sweater song
>worst is holiday

>holiday is worst track
very wrong

Naw that acapella break. The build ups are so good and so powerful.

He absolutely is that kind of guy. Pinkerton is a gross album in parts, it’s on this very thin between unsettling honesty and lacking any self awareness while full of self pity

Oh and the best part, he was like 25 when he made Pinkerton, writing about the woe is me feels a college freshman would.

Yeah that compounds the cringiness, especially when you consider the fact that most of the lyrical content not focusing on personal experience is just talking about shit he was learning in class at the moment or whatever. It'd be like if some young novelist went back to school and in his next novel self-inserted as a guy who got woke af after reading Seneca in Western Civ or something.

>Worst
>Not Surf Wax America

>best
the argus

>runner-up
if you could save yourself (you'd save us all)

>worst
the fucked jam

>overrated
among his tribe

>underrated
hey there fancy pants

>best
tried and true
>runner-up
the argus
>worst
the fucked jam
>overrated
if you could save yourself...
>underrated
chocolate town

Best - Happy Colored Marbles
Runner Up - Chocolate town
Worst - Captain
Should've been on the album - Pot Luck, You Can Go Shit In Your Hat Matt (way better obligatory "brown" throwaway song than Fucked Jam, weirdly addictive)

>Best
Siberian Breaks
>Runner-Up
Brian Eno
>Worst
I Found A Whistle
>Overrated
Congratulations
>Underrated
Someone's Missing

objectively right

>Best
Lotta Years
>Runner-up
Tuff
>Worst
Molecules
>Overrated
Kirby
>Underrated
Mystery Fish

Sweater song is objectively the best song on the album

>Best
Intent And Purulent Discharge
>Runner up
Grave Within A Grave
>Worst
Compliance (still really good tho)
>Overrated
Grave Within A Grave (still really good tho)
>Underrated
Columns

>Best
Breadcrumb Trail
>Runner up
Don, Aman
>Worst
Nosferatu Man (still really good tho)
>Overrated
Good Morning, Captain
>Underrated
For Dinner...

ディックで吸う

youtube.com/watch?v=YHU99chOX1M&feature=youtu.be

>Best
For Dinner...
>Runner up
Good Morning, Captain
>Worst
Nosferatu Man (still really good tho)
>Overrated
Don, Aman
>Underrated
Breadcrumb Trail

>Best
April 8th
>Runner up
Someone Is Waiting
>Worst
Three Peaches (still decent)
>Overrated
Naomi
>Underrated
Pree-Sisters Swallowing A Donkey's Eye

Replace underrated with The world has turned and you got it

>Best
Flood 1
>Runner up
Flood 2
>Worst
Flood 4 (still decent)
>Overrated
Flood 2
>Underrated
Flood 3

>Best
Pree-Sisters Swallowing A Donkey's Eye
>Runner up
Naomi
>Worst
Three Peaches (still decent)
>Overrated
Someone Is Waiting
>Underrated
April 8th

king flex
youtu.be/2V2abwkiRvk

>Best
Flood 3
>Runner up
Flood 2
>Worst
Flood 4 (still decent)
>Overrated
Flood 2
>Underrated
Flood 1

Why not talk about their best album instead?

>Best
Just A Little Boy (For Chester Burnett)
>Runner up
Bring The Sun/Toussant Louverture
>Worst
To Be Kind (still decent)
>Overrated
Screen Shot
>Underrated
Kirsten Supine

>Best
2/2
>Runner up
1/1
>Worst
1/2 (still good)
>Overrated
1/1 (still great)
>Underrated
1/2

I love weezer but hate pretty much all other pop punk.
Is something wrong with me or is weezer the only good pop punk group?

>Weezer
>Pop punk
what senpai?

>Best
1/2
>Runner up
1/1 (still great)
>Worst
1/2 (still good)
>Overrated
1/1
>Underrated
2/2

>Best
Angry Son
>Runner up
Aren't You An Angel?
>Worst
Truman
>Overrated
Aren't You An Angel (still good)
>Underrated
Touch The Wings Of An Angel... Doesn't Mean You Can Fly

>Best
Lazy Comet
>Runner up
Thermal Treasure
>Worst
Stinger (Five Wings)
>Overrated
Tilebreaker
>Underrated
Time Isn't On My Side

>Best
Helpless Child
>Runner up
Animus
>Worst
Volcano
>Overrated
Yum Yab Killers
>Underrated
YRP

>Best
New Dawn Fades
>Runner Up
Insight
>Worst
Interzone
>Overrated
Disorder
>Underrated
I Remember Nothing

still best shirt tho

>Best
Knight
>Runner up
Guild
>Worst
Centurion
>Overrated
Chum
>Underrated
Pre

>Best
Cosmonaut
>Runner-up
Invalid Letter Dept.
>Worst
Sleepwalk Capsules
>Overrated
Arcarsenal
>Underrated
Mannequin Republic

>Best
Piss In Your Grave
>Runner up
90210
>Worst
I Can Tell (still good)
>Overrated
Antidote
>Underrated
Oh My Dis Side

>Best
Flames Of Ice
>Runner up
Enter The Mirror
>Worst
Memory Is Distant
>Overrated
Enter The Mirror
>Underrated
The Last One

This guy gets it. Tried and True is god tier

>Best
Faucet
>Runner up
Huey
>Worst
Mantra
>Overrated
Grief
>Underrated
DNA

>Best
Piano Space For Marimo Kitty
>Runner up
I'm Coming To The Garden..... No Sound, No Memory
>Worst
Akashiman
>Overrated
I'm Coming To The Garden..... No Sound, No Memory
>Underrated
Frozen Guitars and Sunloop/ 7E 802

>Best
High Why
>Runner up
I Don't Resist
>Worst
Two People
>Overrated
Loneliness
>Underrated
She Was A Visitor

>Best
Heart Cooks Brain
>Runner up
Teeth Like God's Shoeshine
>Worst
Long Distance Drunk
>Overrated
Cowboy Dan
>Underrated
Out Of Gas

>Best
Self Control
>Runner-up
White Ferrari
>Worst
Godspeed (Still a fucking great song though)
>Overrated
Ivy
>Underrated
Pretty Sweet

>literally the best vocal output gener has done in his whole career
>absolutely great lyrics and instrumentation

how is if you could save yourself overrated again?

>Best
I Felt My Size
>Runner up
Map
>Worst
The Moon
>Overrated
I Want Wind To Blow
>Underrated
My Warm Blood

>Best
The Sun
>Runner up
Solar System
>Worst
Universe
>Overrated
Solar System
>Underrated
Mt. Eerie

This is spot on

overrated album. Inspired two decades of soy-rock.

>Best
In a Jar
>Runner up
Poledo
>Worst
Lose
>Overrated
The Lung
>Underrated
Raisans

>Best
Parabol/Parabola
>Runner up
The Grudge
>Worst
Mantra
>Overrated
Schism
>Underrated
The Patient

GOOD post

Very accurate
youtube.com/watch?v=dQVNQVvyDWg

>Best
Nightcrawler
>Runner up
90210
>Worst
Pray for love
>Overrated
Antidote
>Underrated
Apple Pie

>lazy eye

>Worst
>The Moon

But it's actually shit

Perfect

exactly
went 0-5
lol
youre just retarded actually
pretty accurate
notbad out of gas is maybe the 3rd or 4th worst song on the album though
really weird picks
poledo wasn't relevant then and definitely isn't now
its super hard to pick an overrated song for this one honestly i think its raisins though

...

>worst: holiday

its the only song keeping it from being a 10

>poledo wasn't relevant then and definitely isn't now

its almost the equivalent to what bowie was doing with the second side of low but worse

>Best
Falling for You
>Runner Up
Why Bother
>Worst
Across The Sea
>Overrated
El Scorcho
>Underrated
Getchoo

>Best
Only in Dreams
>Runner Up
Undone
>Worst
Surf Wax America
>Overrated
Buddy Holly
>Underrated
Holiday

But the second side of low is great? Thanks for confirming that you're baiting I guess.

thanks for confirming that you're dumb as fuck and have no taste

>Best
Across The Sea
>Runner Up
Falling For You
>Worst
Why Bother
>Overrated
El Scorcho
>Underrated
Pink Triangle

Those lyrics tho? Easily the highest point lyrically on the entire album. Git gud, user.

This is SO true. Good taste OP.

no way my friend

agreed.

>Best: Shunned
>Runner-up: Wisdom
>Worst: Low Expectations
>Overrated: Lilly
>Underrated: Oxygen

>best: just a little boy
Mah man

Finally a true For Dinner... patrician

>Best
All My Friends
>Runner-Up
New York, I Love You But You're Bringing Me Down
>Worst
Watch the Tapes
>Overrated
Someone Great
>Underrated
Get Innocuous!

>Best
Non Zero Possibility
>Runner up
Rolodex Propaganda
>Worst
Invalid Letter Dept
>Overrated
Arcarsenal
>Underrated
Cosmonaut

>Overrated
>Someone Great

Pleb, that track is an anthem.