ITT: bands that never topped their debut
ITT: bands that never topped their debut
Carter Jenkins
Ryder Allen
Why the fuck is it always the same with these threads? OP always starts with a request but is never able to provide an example to start off with.
Henry Carter
>inb4 pinkercucks
Jacob Nguyen
What's the best pink floyd then
Jose Collins
Wish You Were Here says hello
Aaron Powell
Slipknot
Gavin Clark
interpol
Jayden Clark
As much as they never recaptured those energy levels, Iowa is so much leaner and meaner
Nicholas Anderson
Primus, although it’s definitely debatable. Tales from the punch bowl, sailing the seas of cheese, and pork soda are all contenders.
Brody Howard
Unpopular opinion but I don’t think Anthrax ever topper fistful of metal
Jacob Morgan
Wyatt Price
100% true
Joseph Morris
King Crimson
Mason Johnson
meddle, dsotm and animals
red and larks' tongue in aspic
Gabriel Reed
>red and larks' tongue in aspic
nope
Jose Clark
the illusion is an effortless providence and epitaph aged like milk
Ian Perry
Maybe could give you meddle, but dsotm is a retread of meddle and animals ia retread of dsotm, so definitely neither of those.
Justin Hall
so right
no
William King
nope
Jose Thompson
Zachary Brown
larks, red and discipline exist, user
Eli Rivera
DSotM
The Wall
Animals
Wish You Were Here
Pick One Brehffer
John Reyes
Camden Sanders
pic related unironically it's just misunderstood
Kayden Morris
Correct.
*chugs soymilk*
Humbug.
Nolan Howard
Woman is better
AM is unironically better
Close between Larks & TCOTCK
Correct
DSOTM and WYWH are better
Leo Adams
Sebastian Perez
if you count le secret, then you're wrong.
Julian Green
TheeEEeEe ParTyyyy underated track
Camden Stewart
That's an EP. So I don't.
If we're counting EP's and mixtapes & shit, I nominate Death Grips.
Exmilitary is unmatched
David Russell
versus is better in every way
Cooper Nelson
Prove me wrong
Logan Flores
Their next two albums, + SBS, are all better.
Master of Reality is their masterpiece.
Brayden Richardson
it can't be done.
you are 100% right.
anyone who disagrees can be genuinely considered as having bad opinions.
Kayden Williams
see look at this newb - so young. so uncultured. but talks like he knows anything!
Angel Roberts
>Protip: That's not an argument
Try again.
S/T is good, and essential for everything that came after.
But it's also forgettable in the current landscape where metal has existed for decades.
Mason Turner
look at this redditfag
he says "newb" unironically, but talks like he posts on Sup Forums all the time
Jayden Cruz
>Black Sabbath's self-titled is forgettable.
Jack Morales
WYWH is the only one that is debatably better.
Ummagumma is fantastic and could also be debated as their best.
Logan Sanchez
whats to understand? the live tracks are good for what they are. the studio tracks however arent good at all. sysphus 2 and beginning of 4 are good but the others are shit cacophony pointless druggie nonsense. grandchester medows is good as well as grooving with a pict. narrow way 1 is boring, part 2 is more cacophony bullshit, and part 3 is alright, david gilmours first song afterall its not bad. and finally grand vizer is pointless just the drummer messing around barely even a song
Brandon Perez
OP is correct
Justin Rodriguez
>the wall
>good
Camden Wilson
been here since 2007 newfriend, though a lot of my language is influenced by all the videogames i get paid to play. as if i needed to jsutify anything to you lmao.
proof you're over the age of 18 and not american, otherwise your opinion is so void it is not even funny.
Caleb Hill
Cooper Miller
The Wall is a great album whether you pretend not to like it or not.
Matthew Watson
why is the wall great? its got so much padding and its some of rogers weakest songwriting (in comparison to the 4 records prior). the only saving grace is Gilmore's solos.
Lucas Parker
Sebastian Smith
these
Blake Davis
Well that's just like your opinion man
Elijah Rogers
The album tells a story. The "padding" builds up the character traits and storyline. I'm probably biased because it's the Pink Floyd album I listened to the most as a kid.
Christian Peterson
>go to RYM
>literally every band never topped their debut
I dare you to find an exception.
Alexander Collins
I’m 21, however I am American and I fail to see how nationality plays into this
Andrew Flores
The Beatles
Sebastian Ramirez
>literally the highest rated album on RYM
Ethan Butler
>your opinion is so void
Keep going to those ESL classes.
Luke Smith
If the story was more interesting it'd give the music a bit more of an excuse, but it feels really egotistical to me and I almost always get bored halfway through it. A good album shouldn't sacrifice the quality of its music in order to tell a story, like Animals. Even with the political coat of paint that roger put on Animals the music was still really solid (though incredibly unsubtle), but that's not something I can say for The Wall. Do I really need to hear Another Brick 3 times to understand its message? I think if it was narrowed to 40-50 minutes I would like it a lot more.