Why didn't they have a thief or a cleric in their party?

Why didn't they have a thief or a cleric in their party?

You mean Legolas? Hell the Hobbits are shown using stealth and deception (and luck) themselves in every movie.

well religion wasn't a big part of lotr, so there is no context for any sort of cleric

legolas, aragorn, and the hobbits fit thief roles

THE HOBBITS WERE THE THIEVES/ROGUES YOU IDIOT

FRODO LITERALLY TURNS INVISIBLE WHEN HE PUTS ON THE RING

The real problem was no bard

Clearly they had help because without a bard they should have been wiped in Moria

Clerics are dead weight anyways, Just stock up on pots.

Merry and Pippin both sing, cook, and are generally useless in combat, just like wom-err, bards.

They ran into Jolly Tom before everyone else and decided they'd rather die than listen to those nonsense rhymes the entire journey.

Aragorn was probably a Cleric/Ranger hybrid and spent all his spell slots on buffs and shields instead of heals.

My experience with Infinity Engine games proves that all-mage party trumps everything

it always triggers me to see him using a sword

> magic user employing a bladed weapon other than a 1d4 dagger
> jfmsifp

>My experience with Infinity Engine games p
You mean those Bioware and Obsidian games that don't try to be RPGs?

how do I into baldur's gate 1? I heard the enhanced edition is shit.

Frodo's uncle was a thief. He probably taught him a thing or two.

Is D&D the worst thing to happen to Fantasy? I'm pretty sure it is.

They did.

/thread

How long would Aragorn last in Lordran?

Honestly, why have a bunch of fat hobbits who have done nothing but smoke weed and drink ale, go on this really important mission? What was elrond thinking!?!

a lot longer than you

tell me m8s

was it vorpal?

Elrond knows the nights are cold, user.

no, i will not tell you.

I doubt it, I'm already depressed so I'd never go hollow because I'd have a huge fantasy world to explore. Aragorn would shit himself the moment he finds out there's dragons around.

Enchanted edition is fine if you don't want to use mods and avoid the new party members the devs decided for some god-awful reason to add.

>god-awful
>not gods-awful

faker detected

> watch so called "Lord of the Rings"
> few monsters and the ones we see aren't even in the manual

let's be honest here. GRRM wouldn't have made that mistake

>4 thieves
>3 warriors
>1 archer
>1 mage
>not a single priest or paladin
shit company tbqh famalang

>GRRM wouldn't have made that mistake

Yes. But be honest. That is the only mistake he did not make.

no, iqctcic tbqh. mydoaps.