When does a film stop being cinema and become pornography ?
I remember a lot of people ( mostly americans) getting really triggered over the sex scenes in La Vie d' Adéle, saying it went too far and made the rest of the movie irrelevant.
If you ejaculate while watching it it's not a film. I think the difference in intent is clear.
Samuel Perez
Her rubbing her pussy goes over the pornography line easily.
Josiah Torres
source
Lincoln Ramirez
Clearly porn
Blake Jackson
What film
Henry Butler
Pornography has no definition. Anything that contemporary considers smut is called so. In a 100 years every DP scene will be considered art.
Charles Nelson
She seems to have some sort of modesty thing over her pussy though
Owen Roberts
>When does a film stop being cinema and become pornography ? As defined in US obscenity laws the key word is "prurient interests." Which is to say "is there any artistic merit to this, or is it just there to be sleazy."
Christian Diaz
>a white dude No thanks
Cameron Bennett
what tv show and/or pornography is this?
David Lewis
Depends on the culture If that was American i'd say its porn If it was from mainland Europe i'd say its some artsy type movie
Jacob Cox
If her tits are that big its absolutely porn, cinema only features small breasted women. Its a simple and clear distinction really.
Kayden Hill
It's a movie
Camden Ross
It must involve a black man to be considered pornography.
Liam Mitchell
80 iq post
In 100 years a simple kiss on tv might be considered indecent, don't try to predict the future
Michael Ward
Everything is fucking
Noah Edwards
Nigger. Fight me.
Austin Cruz
this is a dumb answer. many would ejaculate at emma stone in lalaland or any other regular "film"
Brandon Bailey
and it's called....?
Luis Carter
>golden shower on the right Oh mama
Carson Bailey
In the OP's scene it's a flashback of some student's life in the sex industry. Out of context you could just say it's porn though.
Noah Evans
Erect male penis. As soon as it shows up, it's a porno.
David Torres
First of all if its for a Film Festival they can get away with twice as much nudity and sex than your typical American R rated film.
Then on top of that your movie is French. Like come on dude, have you seen Blue is the Warmest Color? Im sure theyre gonna be the first ones to show actual penetration.
Nathaniel Garcia
Can we please get sauce on OP's webm before the thread goes 404
Colton Walker
In context too. It is clearly unnecessarily graphic Don't be so pretentious
Jaxon Torres
5 days has been added to your BLACKED subscription. Thanks for #BlackingTheRecord!
Nicholas Gonzalez
>In context too. It is clearly unnecessarily graphic no penis is shows vagina is hidden, it's very not that explicit
the piss and spit are what triggers you
William Flores
Is it La Vie d' Adéle, the movie mentioned in the OP?
Justin Cox
for real the answer is acting and overall production aspects but mainly acting.
You can tell this webm is acting - the crying, the makeup, lighting etc.
real porn is either too gaudy (cheesy; bad acting because the focus is sex) or it's like porn gone wrong (efukt; legit crying etc. Even when someone is a good actor, you can tell when they're being legit. it's subtle and to do with reading expressions and nuance of collective behaviour ie/ something autists struggle with)
yeah the brackets in this post are fucked but I shan't be editing it.
Angel Moore
There really isn't a line, and pornography can have artistic merit.
Noah Lee
Are you confessing to this?
Luke Flores
Is that hannah hilton?
John Murphy
Yeah, is there some sort of rule that states these things must be shown? No, I'm sure with some creativity they could have implied these events without showing them.
Nathaniel Clark
>he never saw the sex scenes of Blue is the Warmest Color
No they aren't the same movie
Blake Robinson
What fuck is wrong with you OP! Give us sauce already!
Owen Carter
no. just pointing out how strange it is to make your comment on Sup Forums of all places
Kevin Long
Context is the answer, but I don't think there's a discernible line exactly.
Brayden Foster
those are some sexy semicolons
Luis Rogers
The only people to ever jerk off to Lalaland are Hollywood faggots and their ilk.
Matthew Sanchez
No, that's the french name for blue is the warmest colour.
Ryder Kelly
>the piss and spit are what triggers you Well yeah. And the pussy rubbing as someone pointed out. In fact I consider the entire scene unnecessary. There are other ways to show this. This is for entertainment purposes only
Christian Allen
>what is an example
found the aspie
Charles Lee
Obviously it depends on the intentions of the project itself.
Joshua Price
The context IS the key to establishing if its prurient or not. Of course it ultimately comes down to the judges decision. I can't think of any actual trial for indecency in a long fucking time though. Not since the Tipper-sticker became a thing with music.
Easton Green
Her spitting on his palm is probably the hottest thing about this
Evan Hughes
>This is for entertainment purposes only
So is the movie faggot
Chase Ramirez
Gotcha. Sounds like I've gotta check that movie out.
Cameron Smith
Joanna Kulig
Elles
Robert Sanchez
So all of Sapphic Erotica and Viv Thomas is art.
I agree.
Bentley Turner
Top lad
Grayson Torres
thank you
Carson Young
Are you retarded?
Grayson Reyes
>calls someone a nigger >proceeds to resort to violence like a nigger 2/10 really who is the nigger?
Robert Johnson
I think sex is always a distraction but it can't destroy a good story.
I still think the worst part of 9 songs is not the sex. That made sense. It was the other mediocre parts that were boring.
Grayson Martinez
Such low ratings. Meh
Kevin Miller
>34 throw it in le garbage
Tyler Hernandez
mah nigga
Ayden Ramirez
>the girl isn't Japanese garbage
Oliver Cook
Any more pisskino?
Owen Miller
did she really let herself get peed on? wtf
Carter Nguyen
A pornographic film is meant for sexual pleasure. A cinematic film with lots of sex is a visual pleasure. Please watch "Caligula", nothing will ever be the same. I saw it when I was 12, now I'm a male prostitute.
Xavier Mitchell
I thought there was an unspoken agreement that we wouldnt spoonfed them the source ?
Jordan Bell
I don't think there is a clear line. Every person, country and culture has it's own rules. I can list countless porn films that have better stories and sometimes acting that some Hollywood crap they shovel today. In the same way I can list creative projects that are just an excuse to show off naked women on screen. I think the goal is to project children and those who do not wish to see this kind of art from seeing it and give an avenue to those who do.
Andrew Brooks
Sex can enhance and climax a story (no pun intended)
Tell me Blue is the Warmest would be as good without the sex scenes
Watch more European cinema, we're quite relaxed about nudity here
Parker Brown
Some people aren't faggots.
Brody Roberts
Those tits are fucking amazing.
Josiah Murphy
She looks so horny
Samuel Davis
This is definitely in porno category, I think it depends on how graphic the sex is
That being said making sex graphic like this is something edgy euro filmmakers like to do
Matthew Cooper
You're such a faggot, that pun should have been intended
Dylan Johnson
>mfw massive piss fetish
Thomas Harris
le nonymoose is legun!!11!11
Jayden Johnson
See
Jeremiah Walker
cinema and porn are not mutually exclusive
Jayden Sanders
>Tell me Blue is the Warmest would be as good without the sex scenes it would be as good as it is with the sex scenes that is not good at all, but there would be even less reasons to watch it without porn
Levi Brooks
there's no line
Aaron Martin
Well i guess Schindler's List isn't a film after all.
Logan Turner
I never got piss fetishes
My gf wanted me to piss on her, not only was it weird and forced me to change sheets afterwards, it's fucking HARD to piss with a boner
Michael Jenkins
you are an stupid edgy kid,Sup Forums is for dscussing tv related things not to be the edgy champion autist of your supossed secret club.
Jackson Jones
Probably a plastic bladder taped to his torso with a tube going down to his dick. They use them in japanese porn, they hide them with the censoring
Leo Butler
Keked and again
Jacob Perry
look at those jugs
Bentley Campbell
do it after you cum then
Josiah Wilson
fucking sneaky slants
Oliver Jones
It's hard to explain fetishes, lad. I'd like nothing more than to have a line of sluts borderline drown me in piss, but feet fetishes gross me out. Makes no fucking sense to me, but there it is.
Nolan Sullivan
that's why you piss on her in the bathtub
Grayson Cox
Porn is when they show benis in bagina for real.
Ryan Nelson
There is no line between cinema and porn as a film can contain pornographic content just fine.
Carson Campbell
I have autism
Carter Walker
Peeing right after cumming hurts my weewee
Kevin Morris
My ex wanted me to piss inside her while fucking.
It wouldn't come out though and i was scared that forcing it too hard to make me shit myself.