My little brother (aged 11) recently announced that he "has always felt like he's a girl" out of nowhere. This came to a complete shock to me as: >He's never acted feminine in any visible way before. >My parents are very traditional and have never forced any feminine behavior upon him
I refused to believe that this was the result of improper upbringing. Myself and my other siblings are completely normal (attracted to the opposite sex and adhering to traditional gender identity and norms).
When he was away at a friend's house, I decided to check his browser history to see if anything online caused this >I see a number of videos from transgender YouTubers >I see the "#ProudtoBe" video promoted by YouTube (below) youtube.com/watch?v=dtCyepuLt8Q
I also ask one of my sisters (aged 13) what his school has taught about transgenderism, since I attended a different school when I was his age. >Transgenderism is now taught as a legitimate part of Sex Ed. >There are at least 25-30 kids in his grade (about 200 students total) who are transgender or gay or some other special snowflake identity >school administration cracks down on any anti-LGBT sentiment from students
His thoughts did not originate from my family - the idea that transgenderism is anything but a mental illness was imprinted by the media and educational system
My parents refuse to accept my little brothers 'announcement', so at least he should be spared destructive hormone treatment and "sex change" operations in the medium term. However, my brother remains adamant in his conviction that he is really a girl and he is currently unmovable on this front. I'm terrified that the left has brainwashed him.
The left is evil Sup Forums. They now prey on children when their hormones are acting up, confusing them, and encouraging them to adopt damaging behavior. We need a ban on LGBT propaganda like Russia has. Free Speech can be damned.
This is just sad desu. You know you couldn't hurt him since he's your brother while you hate what he's doing.
Josiah Sanchez
Beat his ass
Christian Powell
You didn't beat him up enough, this is his way of attracting attention.
Go beat up your bro to show him you care.
William Howard
What you going to then, faggot?
Aaron Johnson
Shame him with shit like this Redpill him against the leftist lies
Jack Hill
This.
Angel Stewart
His brainwashing can be undone Do it before it is too late and he turns out like pic related
Bentley Lopez
bump this is scary
someone i know has a nephew who thinks he's a girl and has a gofundme type thing that saves money that he can use when he's 18 for a sex change operation
your parents need to take control of their child, or it will be irreversible. unfortunately they will probably need a lawyer for when the school calls cps on them, i could see america doing that these days, it's like being gay is a law supported by the state
Anthony Morris
hahaha look at all the people taking pictures
Noah Rogers
...
Alexander Murphy
Treat him like absolute shit.
Chase Wright
...
Easton Kelly
>What you going to then W-what should to he be going, ?
Andrew Moore
...
Alexander Garcia
Purchase testosterone and force puberty onto him. Make sure he can never become a 'girl'.
Angel Long
You have a responsibility to beat this shit out of him and ban him from using the internet.
Juan Martin
...
Jason Turner
...
Gavin Sullivan
>ded
Levi Myers
...
Juan Nguyen
Is beating him up going to do anything but further fuck him up? I don't want him to develop a victim complex around this.
I'm still thinking this through. I don't want to do anything rash that will make the situation worse.
>My parents refuse to accept my little brothers 'announcement' >inb4 he's taken away when school decides to call child services
Andrew Price
He wants attention. You need to show him this is not okay.
Go take him hunting or fishing, go cycling, running.
Do anything physical with him, if he's really mentally ill those activities will help him, and if he's just an attention whore this will sate his apetite for some time.
David Price
...
Brody White
>I don't want him to develop a victim complex You're right. In the past beating him up would be the best solution, but these days he'll get support and sympathy from everyone.
Ryan Roberts
Holy shit lol
Cooper Barnes
My daughter did the same thing around age 15, she grew out of it. Try to remember what you were like when you were that age. Are you the same person now?
Jose Phillips
punch him in the face and take a massive shit on the floor
Just yell out 'I DISAGREE' and then escape when they are crying and flailing jazz hands around
Hudson Moore
Tell your parents to get him to another school, preferably a christian one. Look for an adventist one.
That should be a big step.
Present this carefully and with thought out arguments.
first things first, get him out of that lefty brainwashing environment, or nothing you do will stick.
Bentley Williams
Take him under your wing teach him to be a man take him fishing and hunting take him to MMA classes get him working on cars teach him about racial pride as well
Levi King
show him this OP
Chase Gonzalez
I'll try that out user
I really hope this is just a phase, but I'm extremely worried about what will happen if it turns out not to be.
Anthony Lopez
no not going to click that
Nathaniel Hill
"We studied 77 children who had been referred in childhood to our clinic because of gender dysphoria." "At follow-up, 30% of the 77 participants did not respond to our recruiting letter or were not traceable... and 43% were no longer gender dysphoric." >ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18981931/
"In a study of pre-pubertal male and female children with gender dysphoria followed-up approximately 10 years later, only 27 percent of children with gender dysphoria remained gender dysphoric at follow-up." >ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4345542/
tl;dr: It might be just a phase.
Jaxson Morris
Tell your brother that you respect his decision, but have tour family say they won't support his transition until he is 18 and old enough o realize what the fuck he's saying. Don't by him feminine clothes, don't teach him to play with dollls. If he's still a faggot by the time he's 18, then you should respect your sisters choice to cut off his penis.
Xavier Cruz
...
Colton Ward
Jesus fucking christ this is horrifying. I want out of this shit society.
Cooper Moore
>him Ugh...
Jason Smith
When I was a kid, I was horny as fuck and never thought of being gay.
Christian Thomas
it's like the creepypasta threads on Sup Forums all over again
Aaron Baker
The kid doesn't need to be pumped with drugs...neither estrogen nor pimozide. He just needs to get away from the modern brainwashing. I feel the pimozide connection should have been looked into, but for now it's only one example, and it turned the guy into a bit of a zombie.
Brody Miller
Nice, this should be made compulsory first line treatment
Brandon Sullivan
I just made that mistake couldn't press back button fast enough m8 its fucking grim
Adrian Morgan
We should restart the #ProudToBe dislike raid since they're gaining on the dislikes because of publicity.
Wyatt Wright
Get this plebbit tier shit off Sup Forums Already there's some faggot posting gay porn.
John Rogers
>"has always felt like he's a girl"
No 11 year old talks like that.
He's clearly indoctrinated. You didn't let him visit Reddit, did you?
Austin Lee
i already knew the video, so i remembered the thumbnail
Jackson Foster
Ofc its a fucking phase. A kid would tell and even fucking believe he is a dog at that age. Its the age were they want attention and immitate everything around them to learn and shit.
My advice to op is just dont overexagerate this. Let nature take its course. And by dear god do not let the leftists at school fucking indoctrinate him. They will seek to gratify this choice by giving him treats and shit. Dont let them. Rewarding this behaviour will turn him into a tranny. Just let him get his first erection and protect him from the idealogs in his school.
Nolan Lopez
You're all idiots. You think beating or shaming the child will have anything but negative effects? Y'all know how high transgender suicide rates are; anything like that would probably make him off himself within a year, at most.
>inb4 hurr durr a good tranny is a dead tranny
The boy's eleven fucking years old. Even Sup Forums isn't that much of a monster—at least I hope not.
Caleb Allen
Wtf is this shit
Carson Reyes
I will next time
Julian Robinson
Gender comes from the Latin word Genus, which means birth, because of this, Genus is also where we get the word Generate. Gender describes how a person reproduces or generates offspring. A boy is a person that reproduces using a penis. And a girl is a person that reproduces using a vagina. What those people in class were talking about were actually "Gender Roles", but Gender Roles are influenced by sex hormones. Explain how chromosomes in your DNA determine gender because xx produces Estrogen, and xy produces Testosterone. Tell him he can't be Transgendered yet because he hasn't gone through puberty, and when he goes through puberty then he'll get a lot of Testosterone which will make him more manly. Tell him he might feel like a girl sometimes because his chromosomes haven't started making testosterone yet. Explain what klinefelter's syndrome is, and say that if he has that, then he might be transgendered, but the only way to find out is to got to the doctor. Ultimately, "You're not allowed to be Transgendered until after puberty or going to the doctor." Basically, explain to him what puberty is.
Jace White
bombard him with examples of these people being insane, ugly, lonely and killing themselves. I know he's young but you've got to plant the seed of redpill right now or you'll lose him.
Gavin Cook
>adult male patient with a borderline learning disability presented with cross-dressing
That's just a fancy way of saying "NEET trap".
Blake Jones
Vagina doesn't look like that at all. No wonder they commit suicide even with surgery.
Easton Young
Its Melbourne.
Nathan Perez
I don't know if we have the money.
But if this is ultimately what it takes (and this turns out not to be a phase), I could try to find a part-time job to help fund this while I'm at university.
I don't know how well he'd take that..
Luis Davis
Say "OK" and never bring it up again. Don't give him attention for it, positive or negative. If he starts talking about it, chuckle briefly then carry on like he said nothing.
Like you said, he's young and confused. He wants attention and acceptance, give it to him in other ways than inventing this silliness.
Lincoln Green
>he was memeing on Sup Forums instead of spending time with his brothers You're a cuck
Caleb Baker
See, when I look at this I feel like the kid is being coached to do such things for progressive points on the internet.
When I was that age, I wore many outfits like spiderman, etc but one was a nurses overall, no one in my family made a big deal out of it nor did they assume it meant something more, because it didn't, kids just like to dress up. I worry for these kids futures.
Jacob Howard
Jesus christ people. Let nature take its course. Dont fucking indoctrinate him from young ages (be it tranny or anti trany).
11 years old is the age were kids still do almost anything for attention and out of curiosity. The only thing op should ask is if the school he is at is doing the sjw treatment. Cause if they do than the kid is just saying things for rewards (cause probably the teachers are like you are so brave here have a candy.)
Op promptly investigate how the school acts on such shiut. If they shove your bro propaganda or if he does it for the lols.
Benjamin Flores
...
Blake Martin
>Study based on 1 case >"Just pump your underage brother full of meds. Oh and the second he stops, the shit comes back so he's dependant on the drug for the rest of his life".
Big pharma shill please kill yourself
Nathan Jackson
But some people still think they're dogs, and thus it's not "just a phase" for them. OP can only hope. Odds are though, it is in fact just a phase.
Dylan White
It's public school brainwashing
I saw it first hand with my friends daughter
She talked about girls she knew that started "feeling" they should be boys instead
It's honestly just leftist indoctrination
Christian Murphy
>I also ask one of my sisters (aged 13) what his school has taught about transgenderism, since I attended a different school when I was his age. >>Transgenderism is now taught as a legitimate part of Sex Ed. >>There are at least 25-30 kids in his grade (about 200 students total) who are transgender or gay or some other special snowflake identity >>school administration cracks down on any anti-LGBT sentiment from students
I was on the fence about homeschooling my children, but now you've convinced me.
My sex ed. was only about memorizing girl and boy parts and practicing safe sex, but that is just disgusting.
Tyler Evans
sauce
Jason King
I say, I do not understand why would your brother say something so utterly stupid but there is an important question here to be made:
Why do you care what he considers himself to be? How does it affect you in any way?
Aaron Gomez
As his older brother you've clearly failed in your brotherly duty of beating his ass constantly, now go out there and get to it! Appeasement, the post How do you propose to teach someone that they are wrong without making them know that they are?
Aiden Gomez
Sup Forums celebrated the death of the Bernie baby because of the prents being leftists
Henry Moore
Your brother is so lucky. I wish I had been taught all this stuff much earlier. Now in my late 20s having to deal with the cluster fuck I've developed in my head.
Dominic Walker
Give him the D.
Juan Young
sex education in general was a Marxist plot from the beginning and should not be in schools
what is fundamentally wrong about sex education is that it makes sex something public rather than private; this is true even for the most mild sex education.
sex education should be done by the parents
Isaiah Sanchez
ban gay trans, good looking ones are okay
Easton Long
whose who think they are dogs are probasbly highly traumatised in their childhood. They probably seek to get compasion from being a dog (as dogs are basicly simbols of being loved by their owner and shit).
Also the percentages of furry fags and trannies isnt that high in society so it would be better to let the kid live his life normaly than doing what half of pol recomands(which is basicly the traditional way of indoctrination which is also bad). Let him realise he actually isnt a girl and if shit liek this persists then you got to a Psichologist not to fucking Sup Forums.
Xavier Rivera
But so many parents are fucking retarded, your policy means that a large percentage of children get incorrect and dangerous information
Cooper Lewis
This. Ram his little asshole. Destroy his ass. Dominate him like a true big bro.
Gavin Scott
Anyway, OP. If you meet your brother, tell him that his belief that he's a girl is but a story. His "gender" has no purpose for him, he won't attract anybody with it, therefor he is under delusion. There are only 2 "genders" and gay people are an anomaly because they don't serve a biological purpose. Gender is a reflection of biological imperatives, we have genders because we need to breed, what are the natural genders and sexes? Male and female.
Levi Collins
>at university >Only 7 in whole class, unusually low applications >2 bingenders, ony male one female >Female SJW >Male with genuine autism >SJW indoctrinates another girl, other girl starts saying 'can't even' and identifies as asexual >this other girl comes into class and informs as her younger 15yo sister is dating a trans F>M >Mentions the grandma says 'Is it because she feels sorry for this other person?' >SJW calls her grandma a bitch >All this in a class of 7 >It's out of control
Adam Butler
You're taking this too seriously. Pretty much all children have thoughts like this. The concept of gender really mostly forms when a kid mentally "switches on" and starts forming lasting memories consistently and during puberty. This is why most libcucks are those that had xenoestrogens and other chemicals from prescription medications and too many plastics during childhood/puberty. It clearly interferes with their ability to become functional humans.
Ryan Flores
To be fair, I'm pretty sure at least one of these is a Monty Python reference
Jace Perry
Sure as hell not with physical violence or mental shaming, you twat. A realistic talk would be the better solution, but still might not work; some kids really are irreversibly transgender. Beating and shaming will have the opposite effects as intended, though.
Good point. Forgot about that...
Eli Martinez
Kids love attention. The more they get, the more the behavior is going to be reinforced. Whatever you do, be discreet and don't be obvious that it is related to his trans delusion. >There are at least 25-30 kids in his grade (about 200 students total) who are transgender or gay or some other special snowflake identity
Fuck. I'm 28, we had 2 gay dudes in ~100 kids that were in my grade.
It might backfire. Inducing puberty will stunt his growth. Being shorter will allow him to look more like a girl.
Ethan Mitchell
...
Jaxon Turner
Male bigender is also a furry whose preffered animal of attraction is foxes.
Luis Lewis
you're forgetting that parents had to have sex in order to have children in the first place
if you know enough about sex to have children then you should know what a penis and a vagina is and how to manage arousal
even if parents are stupid in the sense of not being scientifically literate, not knowing the names of the latest diseases, they are in general not nearly as dangerous as socialist educators I can't believe you can even legitimately say that you worry about parents giving children dangerous information, when public schools are literally teaching kids that sodomy is natural, and practically encouraging young girls to throw away their virginities and their modesty
Connor King
...
Matthew Perez
Yeah well when heteros fuck women they are seeking to lose their penis and become a hermaphrodite again before we fell and brought sin into the world so what's the difference. Also things that never happened, OP
Chase Johnson
Around 80% of "trans" children become cis after a few years. For a lot of them it literally is a phase
