Could a Hollywood adaptation do it justice? Who would be best suited to direct?

Could a Hollywood adaptation do it justice? Who would be best suited to direct?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=Q6kVU8uNdic
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

Zack Snyder.

Zack Snyder

kys

Raimi with delToro

No, the gore, dark themes and double-page-spanning scenes are part of it. You can't recreate that properly with film.

Hollywood would never touch it. Way too grimdark and if you remove the grimdark then it won't be Berserk.

Same reason we'll never see a true to source Warhammer 40k live action.

George Lucas.

There doesn't need to be an adaptation. The manga is fine. Fuck off.

>Raimi
Last I checked Berserk wasn't a social commentary on middle-eastern relations.

Is this shit any good? I like only a handful of anime series and movies cos most of them are just for kids or manchildren.

They can't even do Berserk justice with animation

What segment would a movie cover? Just the golden age?

The golden age movies were decent.
I'd even say the third one was good.

Berserk 2016/2017 are horrible garbage though.

Most anime isn't made for children, and manchildren is a meme.

it would be unrecognizable and a generic middle ages action movie with lots of forced references. I mean they probably couldnt even make the weight of his sword look acceptable

>Hollywood
Not gonna happen. GitS bombed spectacularly.

It's going to be a Jap live-action. Filled with cringy out of place Japs. And shitty CGI.

lot of shit used to be grimdark in holywood
alien, predator terminator .. only their sequels have shitty funny things

Actually Berserk wouldn't work too badly with Japs.

Predator had funny things.

>Actually Western fantasy based story wouldn't work too badly with Japs.
Are you that asiancuck who thought Guts should be played by some random DYEL asian fagola?

>2016/2017 are horrible garbage though.
why? imo its good. and better than nothing at all. (but would be beter if they would finish the manga already)

>guts is a 5'8" weak faced japlet who can't even lift the CGI sword
>griffith is a trap
>mildland is no longer white

"no"

yet berserk too, Pluck, retard Casca, the whole kid sidekick jrpg team

>He actually thinks those are grimdark

>Defending 2016/2017

Yeah fuck off. I'd rather have nothing than these turds associated with the Berserk name.

Could, yes, would, no.

>no argument

youtube.com/watch?v=Q6kVU8uNdic

How could it? Main character is a Mary Sue silent protagonist and lore doesn't follow the 3 Act staple of Hollywood.

Could make for a decent anime tho

>griffith is a trap
Yes please.

Every character is supposedly a Mary Sue these days.

>using a max landis memeword
kill urself my man

>GitS bombed spectacularly

i laughed so hard at this.
everyone quoted articles japanese were OK with the white washing.

they never were. people were just told they were.

>Every character is supposedly a Mary Sue these days.

take the hint then

>mary sue is a max landis meme

you know american kids are awake when garbage like this starts showing up

The only Gary stu in Berserk is Griffith and even then there is a lore reason for that.

>one example in a sea of thousands

You showed him.

>character is damaged beyond belief, physically and mentally
>on the verge of death after every fight
>has to rely on the Berserker armor every fight now
Sure sounds like a Mary Sue/Gary Stu

>that pitch of generic garbage

Will it have a Wilhelm Scream in the trailer?
And how many Inception horns?

Go back to capeshit.

there's too many monster dicks and rape for Hollywood

wha.. if there is no rape, then it's not grimdark?

>waaah whitewashing

how can white men even compete?

Are you genuinely retarded?

why do you show me some underage brat's youtube crap ?

The only thing he should be directing is people to their seats.

>waaaaaaah my agenda is falling apart ;((((((

>Same reason we'll never see a true to source Warhammer 40k live action.
Warhammer 40K is a setting, not a story, so you'd have to pick one of the hundreds or thousands of stories that take place in that setting. Also it's always huge scale ridiculousness that would only work as animation.

>good

weebs are more assblasted about it than japs themselves. As per usual, you misinterpreted the culture you pretend to worship.
What a shower of fags.

>white washing
Majors body was always europid. it s a fucking hardware.
A lot of the team member is fucking WHITE in the anime.

yet they jap-washed Togusa, who is the whitest blonde guy there is

>weebs are more assblasted about it than japs themselves

Not really. But keep on believing what polygon tells you

kek you too

So no one is gonna tell me if Berserk is actually good or is just another piece of anime shit?

Here's what I think is good anime:
Akira, Vampire Hunter D, Studio Ghilbi Films, Battle Angel Alita, Dirty Pair Eden, Parika + Satoshi Kon films, Ninja Scrolls, Dominion Tank Police, ODEO 808, Magnetic Rose, Robot Carnival, Wings of Honneamise

Now tell if I can add Berserk to the good anime collection.

>so assblasted he blog posts on Sup Forums and demands people respond to his claims

Bet your parents are proud of you.

Why don't you fucking watch it

Hypocrite cuck.

>what polygon tells you
I'm sorry, I don't speak web 2.0

You have no problem promoting feminism 37.2:2017 edition tho

what? because it isn't animated every pixel?
probably had a limited budget, and it is a cgi shit, like every animation nowadays. but i rarely watch anime, so maybe that's why i thought on it as a style, and not as it's bad cgi. Like when they used still pictures and vibraing backgrounds in the oldtimes...

I started with the movies because the first one is on Netflix. You'll get varying arguments from something with such an old and huge fan base. I think general consensus is:

READ THE MANGA > 90s anime > movies >>>>>>>>>>> 2016/17 anime

I still love the movies even though it's hilarious watching the shit they cut after reading the manga. I've buyfag'd too much because of how much of a bandwagon faggot I've become but...it's shit that I like.

>buying a figurine of a rapist

Berserk is a manga first and foremost
Its very, very good and the art is often breathtaking

The 2016/17 anime adaption is irredeemable trash
The Golden Age movies are okayish
The 90s anime is a 90s anime, take that how you will

>Sup Forums suddenly moralfags

casca was clearly asking for it

Don`t bother. Miura won`t finish it. He will die before.

Is Berserk recognised outside the manga/anime fandom and industry?

Cos there are a few works that are clearly only held up by fans of the medium.

What the fuck are you even saying? It's has shit animation both 2d and 3d.

Make it an HBO series, produced by D&D.

>produced by D&D
oh no

So long as iM@s is a thing Miura will live.

Berserk is not your typical weeb trash with kawaii magic girls and shit like that, if thats what youre worried about.

Is Berserk widely known? I dont think so, its not really suited for the masses.
Is it kept up only througb fandom?
Absolutely not, its kept up by its own merit and deserves every praise it gets.
You need to look beyond all the gore and rape though.

>kawaii magic girls
It literally has a kawaii magic girl.

Well, technically yes, there is a young witch involved.
Shes a far cry away from the magic girl trope though, and the story isnt centered around her.

>and the story isnt centered around her.
It did go to shit when she was introduced though.

can't wait till griffith gets his act together and rapes her in front if guts

Thats just like, your opinion man.
I dont think Berserk ever had a moment where it went to shit storywise.

>adapting something without an ending
no nigga

>Berserk is not your typical weeb trash with kawaii magic girls and shit like that, if thats what youre worried about.

Typical weeb trash also contains tits and violence for the sake of tits and violence.

I'm wary about both.

>Is Berserk widely known? I dont think so, its not really suited for the masses.
A lot of things aren't suited for the masses but they still get recognition.

>You need to look beyond all the gore and rape though.

I'll have a look at the 90s anime first, cos I have a soft spot for 90s anime even though a lot of it was trash in retrospect.

>Typical weeb trash also contains tits and violence for the sake of tits and violence.
>I'm wary about both.
Berserk has tits and violence but it's not akin to a generic fanservice animu. Fighting is tamer, at least in the beginning and fucking is usually disgusting and not all that arousing.

>inb4 edgelords boasting how they fapped to rape

n-n-nice one

you should know that the 90s anime adapts a part of the story that is kinda like an origins story/prequel, with the main purpose of explaining what happened to Guts and why he is the way he is in the main timeline of the story. The anime jumps into that origin story straight ahead and skips the first couple of volumes that introduce you to the world and current Guts.

It also has a really, really great soundtrack.

While i agree with you, i must admit the golden age movies made a real effort to make sure the casca rape scene looked erotic.

it sure as shit didn't feel erotic to me

That's because they hired hentai artists. Like, people who actually make h anime.

Good for you, they still made it look erotic though. Again, the 90s anime did this scene better aswell.

That explains it.

Only underage and manchildren watch cartoons

what is the best possible cast for a movie like Berserk?

posting this in every berserk thread

i think the hannibal man would be good because he's shown he can do a) extreme gore; b) extreme homoerotic bromance

horrible, horrible casting

Griffith as a girl?

Honestly, only Casca works in this, but Rihanna is a shitty actor. Maybe Channing would work for Guts

nice bait

just let brendan become guts, it's the role he needs and I'm sure he can express the pain guts has experienced

I dont know whats worse on that pic, Guts or Zodd

makes the most sense desu

No, it doesn't.

>Not Vin as Skull Knight and The Rock as Zodd
you fucked up
Also >muh rihanna

The only way it could work is if the jew scientists would release their rejuvenation chamber so Rutger Hauer could be young again.

>White
>Dumbo ears
>Weird neck

Rihanna would be a perfect Casca if she could act

>cherrypicked midmovement frame
are you weebs autists? your fuckin teengirl animes aren't better animated either

Dwayne Johnson would be a great Zodd but he refuses to play villains.

how else would you do it?
The only actor I can think of who'd be able to pull fof the male yet femininely beautiful-thing going on with Griffith would be Jared Leto, but hes too old at this point and also has a way too dark complexion.