Why can't Multicultural Nationalism work?

Why can't Multicultural Nationalism work?

Other urls found in this thread:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brazilian_Integralism
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

Multiculturalism is a globalist trend.

"The BRÅ has not released detailed data on rape committed by immigrants since 1996, but according to that report individuals with an immigrant background made up 53% of all rape convictions between 1985 and 1989."

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

That's like asking why isn't their a rainbow colored paint?

To a certain extent it can.

However, if you import shitheads who believe in ideas that are opposite to the foundations of a nation...

It's does.
It just becomes "fuck off, we're full" a few years later.

We invited all the foreigners with a ton of different cultures all to one area where we rally around our own native culture because it's superior. Well that sounds dumb as fuck

There was something similar to this in Brazil called Integralism.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brazilian_Integralism

It can, but it would lead to an inherently inegalitarian society. A culture is not just a funny hat and a folk dance. A culture defines what kind of person you become.

Look at Singapore, a successful multicultural society. The Hindus fix the roads, the Malays clean the houses, and the Chinks are in charge of everything, because that's what happens when you put Hindu, Malay and Chinese culture in free competition with each other.

Multi ethnic may be workable, you identify and integrate with your country. Multiculturalism, never.

At some point the two got swapped around...

It can, it's called Civic Nationalism. A lot of Sup Forums is opposed to it but I think it could work if you entrenched the idea that people of one nation are all Americans, Australians, Brazilians, whatever, first and foremost.

And it's a massive failure because they're against race realism. They actually believed they could create a mutt master race in Brazil.

Imo Trump is the last shot at multicultural nationalism working. The fever dream will die if he fails, and what rises in the ashes will be truly horrifying :)

Because Multicultural Nationalism is a contradiction in terms.
Nationalism is based on a singular, unifying cultural identity -- Multiculturalism is the very opposite of that.

Because it's an oxymoron. It would be actually be a confederation, instead.

Yes but a single cultural identity could be multifaceted. The best example of this is definitely you guys, I mean there are different cultural identities from the New York and New Jersey regions, Mid-West, Southern, East Coast etc but you're all American. The Multiculturalism of the modern day with a capital M isn't the be all and end all.

COSE YOU ALL IDEOTED KIDS

Depends what you define as culture. If you decorate your house a certain way and like certain foods and observer certain holidays that's all fine. But if you can't assimilate to the basics of the society and the government of the country you live in that's a problem.

I read the other day that if Muslim boys refuse to shake the hands of their female teachers in Switzerland they deport them. We need this. Be a Muslim, fine, but if you can't behave like a normal person you have to fuck off back to your sandhole.

Ethnic doesn't work either. Take it from a multi ethnic paradise.

It doesn't work because race is real and a nations IQ matters a lot.
Just because a nigger nation is a nationalist one doesn't mean its going to be successful. Thats because they are niggers.

Because peaceful Multiculturalism is a lie. Only retards or people who've never actually thought about it before think multiculturalism is a good thing or could work.

Having multiple wildly different cultures forced to occupy the same space and expecting anything other than conflict is retarded. RETARDED.

What do you think would happen if the UN forced Israel and Palestine to form a single multicultural state encompassing both territories and called it Israelistine?

That they'd think "oh, we're two wildly different cultures but we're in the same country now so let's peacefully coexist lol."

No.

Where people fuck up is thinking that ethnicity/race equals culture.

You can have white, black, azn, latino, poo in loos, whatever the fuck else all living together harmoniously. AS LONG AS THEY SHARE THE SAME CULTURE.

Because otherwise they'll never, EVER get a long.

Look at France.

Islamic culture thrown into Western European culture and told to get along: BIG FUCKING MISTAKE.

Look at the Middle East: Multiple different sects and cultures all in the same area: UTTER CLUSTERFUCK. But they're the same race.


So, why are globalist shilling so hard for Multiculturalism?

Simple:

Divide and conquer.

And people that have been made to believe one culture = one race and that multiracial societies can't be peaceful are just more useful idiots.

In fact, they're just as useful as the idiots who promote multiculturalism.

Because division is useful to the Globalists.

tl;dr:

Race =/= Culture.
One Culture = Peace.
Multiple races can perfectly well equal peace.
Multiple cultures almost always equal conflict.

It can totally work, it's kind of what the states are suppose to be in America. Every state is suppose to be it's own democracy with it's own way of living. Instead we get bland states with inconsistent rules.

Picture unrelated.

do you mean multiracial?

this user is right

confederation is possible, but not if one of the states is something incompatible like muslim
or globalist kikes

But keep in mind that the US, to whatever degree that it's multicultural, became that way ORGANICALLY. This country was born as a largely white nation, but with African slaves, Native Americans, Hispanics all sort of built right in. Then of course the Asians started making their way over, and all the while the flood of immigration from every European nation. This all occurred as a natural progression in the first two centuries of our existence. Also keep in mind that, for the most part, the people who were coming to this country during that time were doing so out of a desire to BE AMERICAN. The arrived with a will and intention to assimilate. This is the difference between a legal immigrant and an illegal one. The illegal immigrant just wants to be IN America. The legal immigrant wants to be OF America.
Lastly, you have to consider the sheer vastness of this country. It would be impossible to spread millions of people over a massive continent and NOT have unique cultural idiosyncrasies arise from on region to the next. Hell, in my one state alone, there's the Appalachian culture, the foothills culture and the coastal-outer banks culture.

The major problem in certain parts of the world **cough** **Europe** **cough** is that they're trying force arbitrarily what America developed naturally as a product of its origins.
Take a continent with over a dozen different distinct cultures already and then mix in a massive influx of people from a culture that is UTTERLY INCOMPATIBLE with the cultures that already exist, and you have a ticking bomb which, when it explodes, will leave behind nothing recognizable. I'm looking at you, London, Paris, Brussels, etc.

That's also hugely important.

because you can't have a nation with multiculturalism.

A nation relies on a unified people and culture.

Large minorities create conflict.

If you have a 90-95% homogenous population and 5-10% "other", i.e. not of one group, but many different minority groups of 1-2% or less, you have no problems. Maybe on an individual level, but that's inevitable in any society.

The single common denominator in conflict regions throughout the world is "different groups living together". Be it different language, different religion or different ethnicity.
Now important here is, language barriers can easily be overcome. Which is why Belgium kinda works. There is conflict between Flanders and Wallonia, but it's not severe, because it's just language.
Religion is a lot harder to overcome, because that's the nature of it, everyone thinks his is the best and is strongly invested in it. Look at the war in Bosnia. They speak the same language, but are large groups of different religions living together. Or many arab or african countries. It's always Muslims vs. Christians or other religious groups.
And finally, ethnicity or "race". Which is impossible to overcome. Just look at america. They've had niggers living there for hundreds of years, and the black vs. white conflict is still there and worse than ever.

multiculturalism = conflict