The Gulf Arab model

Why dont more European nations use the gulf Arab model to solve their labour shortage instead of only relying on mass immigration, which rarely works?

>instead of only relying on mass immigration, which rarely works?
It isn't actually supposed to work

slave labour?

Because of human rights, you know

This, it's all a jewish plan to ruin europe so they can lord over the goyim.
Either that, or the people behind it are complete fucking morons.

Malice or stupidity. Maybe both?

You mean like the Saudis, Qatar and the UAE?
But those rely on mass migration. Even to a greater extent than European countries.

Do you mean we should import more workers but also treat them worse?

60% people with malicious intent and 40% dumbasses who don't wanna appear racist AKA useful idiots

Nope, it's Mass """skilled""" immigration and they don't have a chance to ever get citizenship or exploit the welfare state. They get paid double or triple what they'd get in their own countries, with better conditions and paid accommodation.

Overpopulated poor countries get to use their surplus unemployed men to earn them foreign exchange, Rich countries get cheap labor without needing to sacrifice their culture and native demographics, and millions of poor families will be able to survive on remittance that's better than local pay. Everyone wins, except for leftist ideologues.

For those who don't understand it, it's basically
>Foreign immigrants come to work in your country
>If they don't work they get deported
>give them high wages and educational oppurtunities
>don't give them passport
>they work for some 4 years
>your country and they benefit both from it
>no "cultural genocide" or anything

That system worked in the gulf for the reason that they are insanely rich, and have/had low population. Countries with higher population and lower status income would suffer mass unemployment for the locals as a result. Take for example Saudi Arabia where unemployment among the locals is record high and it lead the government to start a "nationalization" program for jobs, and helped grow an anti migrant sentiment among the locals who feel entitled to high paying jobs despite the majority lacking the skills needed to fulfill these jobs. Even for a country that's developed with highly skilled population like Switzerland for example where skilled immigration is high and causing tensions for the locals who complain about being out competed for their jobs by the foreigners who accept lower salaries. Mass "unskilled" immigration works for the west because they don't threaten the middle class jobs - the majority of voters, they are left to compete with lower classes. Mass immigration with no strings attached is bad and can cause havoc upon the society. Mass immigration with strings attached is bad and can cause havoc upon the society, the solution is always in the middle.

Your system is flawed though

It works, so I don't really care

Not for long though, it is not sustainable.

what if they overstay and hide

Doesn't it make the government nervous when the countrys population consists of 10% native Arabs and 90% foreign work slaves?

If mean if they collectively decided to riot they could tear down the entire country.

How? They have American mercenaries at their disposal.

You somehow pointed out the flaw in their system. Overstaying, the guy in this thread is overlooking the length of societal change takes, the majority immigrants in their country are soon to have a first generation born in UAE, then second generation where trouble starts to show, by the third generation then its game over.

>What if people on holiday visas over stay their visit and hide?

Do what any well off country surrounded by shitholes have been doing for ages, invest In a much larger homeland security force. It's better than letting immigrants destroy your culture.

We can’t offer the salaries Arab countries can offer. We’re an export country in tight competition with our neighbors.

we already had that problems. caribean constructors of the canal werent supposed to stay here. well they stayed and now we have beautiful diversity

Why don't you start confiscating passports of foreign worker and can't leave without a exit-visa.ye, go on, do that.

The Saudis are backed by Israel and the USA. They ain't goin nowhere.

The emirates give a lot of designated areas for migrants to do their thing without heavy religious policing.

>instead of only relying on mass immigration
but that's exactly what they're doing nigger, Dubai is only like 25% Arab

>It's the age of human rights, all younger generations should kill themselves and girls should be raped now
I didn't know Wh*toids are such funny people.

Why does this Sup Forumsfuck keep spamming these threads on Sup Forums and why do you all keep responding?