Is Kamala Khan a well written character?

Is Kamala Khan a well written character?

Yes

No

maybe

Can you repeat the question

Sup Forums in a nutshell

Nazi Kamala following in Carol's footsteps when?

In her ongoing, yes. Varies when people besides Wilson are writing her.

Her defining features are being muslim and fanfiction. So, i guess?

>Her defining features are being Muslim
No, not really.

Great counter-argument.

>Ms. Mohammad
>Good
Pick one and only one.

No, her defining character is being a cultural muslim. Only observing the minimum requirements not to get ostracised.

Otherwise known as a good muslim.

good in her own book, varies outside of it

I don't know.

There was no initial argument. What is claimed without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence.
And no, her religion is not really anything that defines her as a person. It may be a selling point, but she is not very religious and openly questioning tradition.
What actually defines her is the commitment to the community and her high standards in terms of justice.

She's only a good character if you can name five cute facts about her.

Well, let's see.
1. She has a winged sloth plushie
2. She gets upset at fanfics about her friends
3. She's a squishy muffin
4. She is preciously conflicted between cultural norms and the sweet allure of bacon
5. She refuses to leave a kitty behind

Any of you guys getting the Kamala Ms. Marvel Omnibus coming out soon?

Can you repeat the question?

...

Sometimes. Just like every other comic character.

1. She's cute!
2. She's a girl!
3. I want to marry her!
4. Kamala!

Her defining feature is wanting to be her hero, and then slowly realizing that's not what she really wants, and becoming her own person.

growing up in a world shaped by the xmen, avengers, etc. is an interesting idea tbhdesufampai. getting thrown into the middle of another civil war all of the sudden and being made an actual avenger kind of fucks that, glad shes getting out of there.

Do the plinkett test.

Describe kamala without saying what she looks like or what her role in the story was.

At the start they did a good job. She was still pretty nerdy without going full meme.

They way they handled her ethnicity too was great. They weren't afraid of showing the bad parts and the hypocrasy of islam and how it can conflict with your life. Her older brother was really interesting cause ever their parents tall him a loser and do not hide their hate and disapointment in him becoming more conservative and how her brother is a huge loser for living an entire life based off faith of islam.

Now though it's just meh secret teen super hero with a bigger push for "LOOK HOW MULTICULTURAL WE ARE!"

Still good for the most part but I think it's lacking the original appeal of it.

She's a second generation immigrant with the baggage that comes with: she's more secular and acclimated than her parents, and has to deal with other side of second generation immigrants in her brother, who has become more religious and counter culture than their parents. This leads her to being slightly distanced from both, because she's not only a teenager but on a different wavelength from her older family members. They all care about her and none are as one sided as they first appeared, but they have different ideals from her when it comes to what they think is right for her (things like her hobbies or love interests and so on) that she has to convince them to get over.

She wants, or wanted (the story has developed past that by now sort of), to be better accepted by her classmates and other Americans her age. The first issue has her dealing with this, with her coming to realize the others she wanted to be a part of weren't willing to meet her halfway when it comes to her personal beliefs, which are still grounded in her foreign heritage that she's unwilling to discard out of hand.

More recently, she's tried to grapple with the fact that her idol has begun to pay more attention to her. She's been selected to work with her, but has begun to see her flaws and the flaws in the system she's trying enact. Currently, she's caught because she jumped in feet first because of her hero worship, but it's conflicting with her personal sense of heroism, which is far more local and interpersonal than her hero. It's important to note Kamala's sense of community and heroism is rooted heavily in being from Jersey, not Ms. Marvel or her personal ethnicity or religion. Her disconnect from Carol's policy's comes from personally knowing the people it's affecting, and so she knows the nuances being washed over.

>hopeful
>enthusiastic
>caring
>ambitious

you missed "i don't know"