So out of all 4 Seuss adaptations, which book had the best? This or The Lorax?

So out of all 4 Seuss adaptations, which book had the best? This or The Lorax?

>Inb4 The Grinch or Cat in the Hat
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA no

what? but those were the best.

Grinch cartoon is the only good one.

Sadly, it probably is The Grinch.

Horton if you really want to make me choose. I just love how they made the main character emo

>The Cat in the Hat movie was bad
Pleb get out

I'd put Lorax at the bottom of the list.

Like, below Cat in the Hat. That also sucked but at least it was obviously not trying to be like the book and was just a dumb comedy, while Lorax was really attempting an adaptation but also made some fucking dumb changes.

Grinch cartoon is still a masterpiece.

Cat in the Hat is forgettable. (The cartoon, I mean. No one acknowledges the Myers abortion.)

Lorax loses automatically for having Taylor Swift in the cast.

Horton was pretty good, but it had a few too many "what the fuck was that?" moments that exist for no reason.

Grinch and Butter Battle Book are the best. The last was even Suess's favorite.

Horton Hears A Who was largely forgetable honestly. The Lorax and How The Grinch Stole Christmas were amazing though. The original ones, fyi. The CGI versions are both trash.

I actually love the Myer film and the live action Grinch film too. It could be because I have never read The Cat In The Hat but I enjoyed the live action version as a child.

Live action Grinch is legitimately good. Never understood the hate.

Aside from maybe the little blonde kid who couldn't act her way out of a paper bag and sings like a dying cat, but everything else is aces.

OP here, I should have specified that by The Grinch and The Cat in the Hat I meant the live action films, not the 70's short films.

The old Lorax cartoon is pretty good too actually but the Grinch is still the king babyyy

>The Cat in the Hat

The only scene from that film that Sup Forums will even acknowledges is the "You're not just wrong, you're stupid" bit.

the old Grinch cartoon

God I remember the Onceler fandom.

Call me crazy but looking back on it I'd rather have Tumblr spammed by that rather than by what it's filled with now. Back then the worst thing that could happen to you was either seeing hardcore Onceler porn or getting your posts raided by Superwholock nerds.

Of his books I choose Horton Hears a Who
Namely because of that MILFy Kangaroo

Animated Grinch > Live Action Grinch > Horton > Cat in the Hat > Lorax

Jack Frost is the new Onceler for some reason. I don't get why people like them so much. We need a better looking new, non-Disney CGI hottie already.

I prefer "How Bad Can I Really Be" to "Biggering" in the Lorax. It's got a nice tune, and the latter's a bunch of crooning I could find in a much better form in classic rock.

Green Eggs and EGGS

What a dilemma, as IIRC only Horton Hears A Who didn't have anything before that movie from a decade ago.

Actually, you just reminded me: Horton had a Looney Tunes cartoon. And it was really good.

Horton and Live Action Grinch are the best.

Haven't seen Lorax and live action Cat in the Hat is a sin against God and nature.

I don't know what happened with Jack Frost, but when it came to the Onceler, it basically boiled down to fangirls going "There's a new animated film and only one character is husbando material... LET'S SHIP HIM WITH HIMSELF!"

On an unrelated note, people seem to forget how patrician the 70's Lorax adaptation was. Instead of going full hippy they acknowledged polluting industries give their workers the money they need for their families' survival and just "shutting them all down" is not a feasible answer.

Me too, that meme song is really catchy. Too bad it made the Onceler instantly go from hipster to greedy CEO in the span of just two minutes, though. It made it feel as if they were two completly unrelated characters.

I think Jones fit the Seuss material better than Clampett did. Maybe that's just due to the Grinch cartoon being closer to the general Seuss tone as we know it today, instead of the Pvt. SNAFU stuff, but still, I think the Horton in that short is a bit of the generic doofus type found in some Clampett shorts.