Character who mysteriously disappears in season 1

>Character who mysteriously disappears in season 1
>Badass motherfucker living alone north of the wall for fucking years
>Appears for 10 second to save Jon
>Dies

This was so stupid you literally cannot defend it

well he also saved bran and meera but yeah

>Badass motherfucker living alone north of the wall for fucking years
he didn't though, he died and was resurrected as a wight but by the children of the forest not the white walkers

Didn't he leave behind dragonglass in that house too?

So he is confirmed coldhands?

in the show yes, in the books he's confirmed NOT coldhands

So in Benjen Coldhands in the book or what? Because I'll be mindfucked if he isn't. I can't remember, did Coldhands die stopping the Wights from attacking Bran and company?

Why does he look like a zombie?

>living

IIRC he just drops them off at the 3ER's place and takes off. They never say who he is though. Just what's already obvious, that he's a resurrected Night's Watch ranger.

I guess he should have never shown up and never appeared again. That sounds so much better.

surely the weight of Bran, Meera and Benji was more than that of Jon and Benji.

so their weight slowing them down wouldnt have been an issue

>the guy was so cold he turned blue

What kind of cartoon bullshit is this?

...

As he lay dying he had obsidian placed through his heart although this made him a wight loyal to himself not a white walker for some reason
He's rotting

he's half whitewalker dude, it's why he can't go past the wall again

They are just trying to finish the show as fast as possible. Too many characters not enough time and not nearly good enough writers. They didn't really think things though on their planning

what did he feed the horse with=

Because he was about to turn into a wight and the Children of the Forest saved him. So he's like a half-wight.

Couldn't find a better example of deus ex machina

Fucking lazy ass writing, they are the TV show with the biggest budget and still make this crap

Damn this show is retarded

>writers never lie

I bet you think Jon's parents are Brandon and Ashara lmao

Yeah a long ass time ago. Then a loooong absence, and then 10 seconds and dead.

He's appeared twice. Is every here retarded?

Yeah it was pretty fucking stupid.

>No time
I would have accepted "I can't" and left it at that.

>biggest mystery is what happened to him
>two appearances
>not explained what happened to him or what he's been up to
>gets instantly offed by wights in final appearance

so that's why he wasn't an unconscious zombie?

>Jon: Uncle Benjen!
>Audience: Yeah! Uncle Benjen!........ who is he again?

Hey remember that woman with the mask?

Benjen = NK

>living
user...

>implying hes actually dead

never underestimate DABID

>implying he's dead

It was at the end of last season

i just saw this scene and can confirm it is bullshit

>I bet you think Jon's parents are Brandon and Ashara lmao

Eddard Stark + Ashara Dayne = Jon Snow
Rhaegar Targaryen + Lyanna Stark = Daenerys Targaryen
Eddard promises Lyanna
Returns Dawn to Ashara at Castle Starfall
Discovers Jon, trades him for Daenerys
Ashara fakes her suicide, becomes “Septa Lemore”
Smuggles Daenerys to Pentos to be with Ser Willem Darry and Viserys
Joins Jon Connington to raise and train Aegon the Reconqueror

Yeah but D&D have you talking about it now. Success for them

> does Bran ever recognize him
> no
He got out of that one pretty easily, it's Benjen.

What did you expect? He said there was no time.

why couldnt he get on the horse as well?

He's not dead though, what is dead may never die.... or something.

In the books maybe, but in shit show Ashara will never apears.

editors are cute

THERES NO TIME

uncle benjen will return