Did it deserve to win best picture?

...

Yes.
/thread

Master and Commander should've won

No. Mystic river deserved

The other two could have won and it wouldn't be such a problem. Specially Two Towers, which is the best of the trilogy

Yes, a film has never been more prophetic about modern Europe as this

i dont think theres any trilogy that will top LOTR in how good all 3 are

Colors trilogy

Not on its own no, but everyone knows it was it given in recognition of the trilogy as an important, well-crafted whole.

who cares about academy awards?

I will now start to rate them

Yes and no. It's obvious all the awards were held off until the third movie was released. So the awards should be regarded for all three movies. Thats what I think of it at least.

gimmicky ending desu senpai baka

No, once you remove the nostalgia googles you'll realize it's a really shitty movie with terrible effects.

Pretty much this.
Nope.

It’s a fantastic movie. It deserves the win.

First one was the best by far.

Are you fucking retarded? This flick was only given pity awards.

This. The first two deserved it though

i don't remember
what else was on the menu boys?

Zooming out after finishing this was pretty embarrassing. What's the most essential film I haven't seen? I'd go with Wings or Ten Commandments.
It was a tokenistic prize for the trilogy

There it's done