This guy is directly responsible for the death of so many resistance fighters and it's brushed over

This guy is directly responsible for the death of so many resistance fighters and it's brushed over.

He sacrificed almost all of their fleet for one dreadnought and even then it was only by luck they took it down when they had a clear escape. He only gets demoted in on rank which seems to have no effect on what he does.

he then disobeys the new leader leading to the first order getting direct information about the cloaked transport ships. Information they wouldn't have knew about without him sending finn and his mutiny.

He then comes up with a plan to use land speeders to take out the guns but all they did was become targets and get killed off one by one and pulls off without accomplishing anything again.

How is this guy still in the resistance? I know they need fighters but this guy is more than a liability. He is actively a net-negative. He is like the anti-thesis to han solo/luke skywalker in terms of impact for the rebels.

He's a good leader now because he learned to listen to women. May the force - hehe - may the force be with you.

Based latino man, fuck all those women, asians and black

I am losing my mind that dozens of people died because he disobeyed a direct order and no one say anything.

Maybe if his commanding officer had just told him the plan instead of living the entire crew in the dark maybe this would have been prevented.

I bet you’re the guy who made the thread whining about “obvious Disney shills” on Sup Forums lmao

As if Disney would waste their time on a group that doesn’t pay to see movies

No because the reckless white boy won't listen, we need to hide the facts and keep him in the dark.

Yes, he is truly /OurGuy/

Suck my dick, tripfag faggot

who is he? You don't know who the possible traitors are in the crew. He is a soldier. Soldiers follow orders for the most part. He already disobeyed one order and lost all of their force. Why the fuck would he be privy to their most important plan? And even without knowing what she had planned he still managed to fuck it over.

t. disney shill

How about the woman and the alien that had joined him on his mutiny?

If the Dreadnought was not destroyed, it would have blown the Rebel flagship to smithereens instead of giving them a chance at survival
His new leader then acts like she has no plan by being secretive and makes all of the troops believe all she is doing is delaying their inevitable demise, so he tries to come up with his own solution.
They had no choice but to try and use the land speeders, they were fucked either way until Luke showed up.

Poe did nothing wrong the whole movie.

How about at least telling someone considering a mutiny happened than most people on that ship were convinced they were gonna die because of incompetent leadership.

Actually his dreadnought all in ended up saving them all from being killed in the first half hour of the movie, what do you think would've been the first thing the First Order would've done after catching up with them again if they still had that overpowered cannon?

Trip faggot

bullshit PoeIDF, they could have warped away without losing their bombers

And then the First Order would light-speed up their ass and use those cannons they still have on them.

>three pyrrhic victories in one movie

When will star wars fans start to get bored by this?

and be tracked and destroyed by the dreadnought

The whole movie falls apart when realizing poor communication skills is why it mostly went to shit.

>Film is pissing off tripfags
Holy shit maybe I do like this movie...

And what good would that do if your entire fleet is destroyed by a single shot anyways? And this time you can't do jack shit about it because there's a 60 km width monstruosity and more than 6 star destroyers protecting the damn thing.

Yes, but they could have simply lightspeeded one (1) bomber into the Empire fleet, wiping them all out, and gotten away.

>he then disobeys the new leader leading to the first order getting direct information about the cloaked transport ships
To be fair that is all on Finn and Rose being idiots that let themselves stick out like a sore thumb and get captured at the casino, then trusting some random hacker they meet in a jail cell.
Then thinking they can get away putting a box on BB-8 and letting him roll around the enemy base.

As convoluted as the plan originally was, it would have worked if Finn and Rose did it right.

According to this movie, yes, yes they could have.

Which is why that light-speed ramming scene has ruined Star Wars' space combat

>may she force be with you
fixed it for you sweatiepie

>hothead with a heart of gold does dangerous shit to the enemy which risks his life unecessarily
>Retarded hothead that starts a mutiny in his own resistance group and fucks over his own side

The first is how your supposed to do it, but they picked the second.