>Muslim cartoon is announced that looks suspiciously familiar >Sup Forums defends it as "muh homage" and "muh reference" >Tumblr goes through frame by frame and creates a dozen examples of how the show outright ripped off other series to the point the creator cried out about them being racist
When did Sup Forums being bigger cucks than tumblr?
don't even know what this ripped off I don't even know what this is
Benjamin Cruz
the fuck is a muslim cartoon
Colton Lewis
What the fuck is this shit?
Charles Evans
I haven't even seen this on Sup Forums. You could have let this quietly die on tumblr but you had to bring it up.
Owen King
...
Bentley Adams
I don't browse tumblr, so would you care to share any pics or screencaps?
Daniel Barnes
>not a single thread about it on Sup Forums >OP has insider info from tumblr
Nice try, but looks like you're the villain here!
Ryder Jackson
Emara. It's from the UAE.
Jeremiah Martinez
>Not a single thread about it on Sup Forums lurk moar
Christopher Hernandez
>Shitskins can't into creativity Color me surprised.
Grayson Morris
Like only 1 scene looks like a rip off to me.
Hunter Morgan
I shouldn't fucking care about a shitty muslim cartoon, move along.
Samuel Johnson
the first, maybe the second everyone else is just posing
Charles Howard
fucking kek, they fell for it hard
Luke James
>by THAT guy Figures I didn't see it!
Justin Myers
They're muslims, who gives a fuck?
Jose Howard
What would you call the setting or atmosphere of this cartoon? I really love it.
Adam Moore
Shit
Ayden Scott
Sup Forums stopped caring when they heard >mudslime
Lucas Hughes
Are you being serious right now? >Avatar copied off DBZ now because they're shooting fireballs and it looks like Goku doing a Ki blasts or Kamehameha >Godzilla is a ripoff of KingKong because they're both giant monsters >War and Peace is a rip off of Lolita because things happen in them It looks like something made as a joke if anything. The bottom pic with the girl swinging her hands up is "Copying a pose?" How far reaching can you get?
Colton Perez
I dunno anons, it looks pretty cute to me, but I like brown girls in cartoons so I'm biased
Wyatt Russell
You have to go back.
Matthew Howard
>If I made thinks broad and vague enough that makes it a rip off
Right The issue is if it was any one thing it wouldn't be a problem, but several examples (and I didn't even post all of them) makes it an issue, that's way too many concidences.
John Robinson
It looks more like a cartoon and not like Atla is more like a chibi style, why should we allowed here it?
Jeremiah Stewart
>STILL DEFENDING IT
HAHAHAHAHA
Tyler Harris
Except for the first and the fifth, they don't look that similar.
Carson Roberts
Some of the examples are huge stretches, but many seem legit. They need to remove the ones that are stupid and only keep ones with a high chance of being plagiarized.
Blake Scott
>The issue is if it was any one thing it wouldn't be a problem, but several examples (and I didn't even post all of them) makes it an issue
But you've literally only posted one example.
Nathan Perez
>Clearly drawing inspiration from several things at once >IT COPIES THEM REEEEE
Don't see how Tumblr can call people out on copying shit.
Samuel Campbell
Top left is a rip-off, everything else is literally just poses. There's nothing here to get excited about.
Landon Adams
The obvious ones reinforce the "stretch" ones.
Jaxson Turner
>Muslim cartoon >Female protagonist I mean, at least they actually gave her a hijab this time unlike Kamala, still seems odd.
Dominic Williams
I see six.
Eli Adams
I see one scene
Christian Taylor
You never heard of Pakistanimation?
Jaxon Stewart
>Tumblr gets pissy when someone has a few references to several other show >Most tumblr comics are basically complete rip offs of Adventure Time or Steven Universe, only even less offensive
Luke Evans
Animators do "homages" and take inspiration from other animators all the fucking time, what's the big deal? Aside from one or two of the screenshot comparisons, they really don't seem similar enough for there to be a problem.
Adam Martin
>tumblr is one person
The fact these people are calling out a muslim should show they're not the average tumblrite SJW
Luke Rogers
Shouldn't this belong in Sup Forums? Middle Eastern animation and all that.
John Butler
They should really embrace their roots instead of going for a waifu style thing. Have a new Saladin or something with a cool sword that fights robot infidels.
Xavier Thompson
You think Sup Forums would allowed this on there? Hilarious.
John Perez
I will still never understand why SJW's defend Muslims when Muslims are basically the hyper concentrated and purified form of everything they despise.
Adrian Hernandez
Because SJWs are not anti-racism or anti-homophbia or anti-misogynist, they are literally just anti-western civilization.
Once you realize that, their logic makes a lot more sense.
Blake Nguyen
ITT: OP is such a huge faggot that I don't even have a proper reaction image to adequately express his level of faggotry.
Gavin Rogers
Get your eyes checked.
Josiah Diaz
There's a difference between fan stuff and actual commercially produced content. Though the rise of Patreon definitely muddles things.
Ryan Collins
Unless they're outright tracing animation then I don't see anything wrong here
Lincoln Scott
tumblr would cry about anything and would over react like crazy
Jack Young
Once again, their Muslims, are you gonna go bitch about Lucky Pie next?
It's kinda expected that they're gonna rip off shit.
Matthew Moore
Go try it.
William Reed
Yeah, they probably would.
Lincoln Smith
So, do we have a full episode to work from, or send to the R34 people, or is OP just being a hyperbolic windbag?
Logan Brown
>Sup Forums doesn't even want series from China and Korea >Thinking they're going to accept middle-eastern shit
Jonathan Butler
you have to nail the anime look 100%. for example, the kings avatar is a Chinese animation and yet it's treated like anime to the point you can get away with talking about it on Sup Forums
Ayden Green
Looks more like billy hatchit with glasses
Ryder Lee
Sup Forums is a terrible board, t.b.h.
I blame the mods who are selective in when to enforce the rules.
Jaxson Wood
That's not gonna happen.
William Hall
>You have to literal trace to rip someone off
That's a new one.
Dylan Murphy
most of the "rip offs" have almost nothing in common though
Luis Allen
holy shit Sup Forums dont you have traps to whoreship you closet fa gs . i swear you are like furrys at this point , yall fuckers are everywhere. "uuuhhhh its muslim so its shit" This shit is funny to me. you freak out in joke and excitment when a show does a jojo reference but turn into salty shits when its from people you dislike . >"still defending kek" why do i even bother , like furrys you will continue to to poisen everything and make nazi "recolors" of characters cuz you are the NEW furrys now .
Justin Diaz
I don't have an issue with the cartoon but you're just shitposting, stop.
Jayden Johnson
>top left Haha holy shit that's bad >top center That's just a facial expression >top right Common cliche for anyone wearing glasses. Actually the glare makes it more cliched than the comparison pic >bottom left Cliched "dark monster with round white eyes", not sure how that's a knock off of anything specific. >bottom center Falling from a side view is a knock off now? Even her legs are positioned differently. Maybe in motion it looks closer? >bottom right Probably the only image that could be legit called a homage, though that's already a damaged argument here.
The show probably has more ripoff examples than that one scene, but tumblr (and Sup Forums?) is dragging down their argument by including every "maybe" they can not unlike when they start making conspiracy theories about anyone they don't like be it Trump or Hillary.
Try again with better examples, that first screen comparison is enough to make me believe there is worse cases of tracing to be found.
Christian Lewis
We call them Sup Forumsutistic for a reason.
The worst part is mods won't let people talk about Chinese animation on Sup Forums, but they'll let Weebs post thinly veiled anime and manga threads most of the time. I remember a user getting a warning for making a Chinese cartoons thread.
Juan King
maybe the first scene is like that, what a waste of trips
Aaron Reyes
>Common cliche for anyone wearing glasses. Actually the glare makes it more cliched than the comparison pic To be fair it's not as clear with a screenshot, the entire five seconds of animation is basically the same but mirrored.
I suggest everyone checks out the videos of the images shown before coming to a conclusion.
Oliver Foster
>Can talk about this Middle East shit here >Can't talk about Korean stuff here
Some bullshit.
Nicholas Fisher
I never visit Sup Forums, so I didn't know.
Kayden King
>This cartoon is HORRIBLE and doesn't deserve any exposure, that's why I'm going to start a thread about it on Sup Forums with a really baity subject. Take that philistines!
Gabriel Collins
>Why aren't you outraged about this? Tumblr is outraged, why aren't you?
First picture is indeed a rip off (Or reference, i don't care), the rest are just anime poses, who cares?
It reminds me of when everyone was calling Pacific Rim an evangelion rip off becouse it had giant robots, its fucking stupid and only stupid people would actually believe it
Jaxson Russell
It's annoying, too.
Can't discuss any Korean web comics on Sup Forums.
Xavier Ross
That sure is a bunch of generic anime stuff.
Levi Bell
Ha, thought is was going to be a situation like that. Somebody outta make a gif/webm version.
Brayden Martin
I'm gonna put together a caparison video real quick just for the discussion.
Zachary Gutierrez
post more examples
Jayden Adams
Nice get
Doesn't that show with the fat kid and the jewel girls do this a lot too? I remember there being a thread a long time ago where the we're showing the references to Evangelion
They like Gainax/Trigger. I tried saying this before, but no one saw it.
Matthew Butler
Butthurt Turkroach detected.
Christopher Collins
>Watching cartoons produced by heathens when you could be reading the bible and reflecting on your place in God's plan As I'd expect of those degenerates at Tumblr, desu
Henry Gonzalez
The overall product looks original and fun, I don't care that it takes inspiration from a few Chinese cartoons as long as it doesn't outright trace over them.