>there is nothing wrong with this addition correct same goes for the other 90% of additions
Landon Wilson
There's nothing wrong with "young Anakin" ghost, but you are wrong about TLJ not being dumb.
Kevin Davis
>based rian kys
Elijah Gomez
If you kill enough younglings you can absorb their energy to be a young force ghost
Cooper Bailey
That's not what Anakin looked like when he died, though.
Benjamin Brooks
It's actually is since metaphorically, he died in ROTS.
Justin Turner
Agreed
Still doesn't justify all the shite in TLJ though.
Ethan Howard
That that throws out the entire idea that Vader was redeemed in the end
Nathan Perez
>This is what Anakin looked like when he "died" and became Vader. it actually makes sense. Except it kind of disregards his redemption by Luke since it effectively says young Anakin is what really matters.
Not to mention that it just looks fucking stupid and Hayden looks like a creep there.
Benjamin Allen
luke will be a vengeful spirit, who travels the galaxy and searches for children who in the future might become tainted by the dark side
sometimes he murders unborn children by crushing their skulls inside their mother's womb. that's just what he does.
Landon Bell
This is how Anakin Skywalker looked like when he "died" you dumb fucking faggot.
Xavier Flores
Not really because while Anakin in a sense "died" in ROTS, there's still a part of him left in Vader that Luke managed to bring back.
Thomas Bennett
It's ok for continuity reasons but you're wrong to say Anakin died on Mustafar. He died on the second Death Star.
Jackson Sullivan
No, Ghost Yoda using lightning on the books was insulting, yeah i know Rey took the books, but it's still retarded
Hayden as Ghost Anakin is fine though, it does make sense, still might not have been a good idea for Lucas to include
Ethan Gonzalez
I didn’t hate young Anakin. I DO hate that the Ewok song was taken out. Fuck that shit, it was the perfect song for the end of the film.
Kevin Butler
Why is Kenobi old but Anakin young?
Luke Jackson
isn't kylo himself a "force nexus" (whatever that is supposed to mean)
Benjamin Howard
If you think that looks good you are simply retarded and not worth wasting time on.
Hunter Lewis
>another starshit thread
Gavin Ross
The addition was so that kids who started with the prequels would understand
Andrew Gray
only good post in the thread
Dominic Hill
>Hayden as Ghost Anakin is fine though, it does make sense, still might not have been a good idea for Lucas to include I disagree because Hayden is many people Anakin's so it's make sense why did it.
Michael Bennett
I never said TLJ didn't have issues, but you're pretending other star wars movies don't have the same issues. Its not hard sci-fi, its fantasy. it's more about envoking ideas than being a fucking perfectly solid mathematical equation. if you think otherwise you have autism.
>You told me that Darth Vader betrayed and murdered my father. >Your father... was seduced by the Dark Side of the Force. He ceased to be the Jedi Anakin Skywalker and "became" the Sith Darth Vader. When that happened, the good man who was your father was destroyed. So, what I told you was true... from a certain point of view. its like movies present abstractions and aren't always meant to be taken literally. who would have guessed.
nice argument there, bud
Brayden Campbell
This is what Anakin looked like when he died
When he fell from the light to the dark side, he turned from a white to a black man. It's like poetry.
Zachary Adams
>fucking inanimate object Fucking specist, die in a fire, trees are sentient too
Julian Rivera
>There is nothing wrong with this addition There is, he has a fucking pervy look, he's like "yeah, Luke, I know about your long nights on Hoth thinking about porging Leia, what's a porg? you'll know, in time, my son"
Robert Reyes
>I never said TLJ didn't have issues, but you're pretending other star wars movies don't have the same issues. It does have one serious issue, FEMINIST PANDERING The entire movie is dogshit, same with TFA
Sebastian Roberts
>I never said TLJ didn't have issues, but you're pretending other star wars movies don't have the same issues. Its not hard sci-fi, its fantasy. it's more about envoking ideas than being a fucking perfectly solid mathematical equation. if you think otherwise you have autism Dude, I legit think that OT aren't great as some of their crazy fans think they are and welcomed PT with open arms (and legit love them). ST is just so freaking boring and forgettable with hardly any interesting ideas, this is the problem with them.
Cameron Cox
destroying a science book doesn't make the science disappear from existence. All truths of the universe, like the force, are inherent.
yoda straight up says that the books don't contain anything that she doesn't have access to
Colton Harris
>then you don't know anything That's fine. I don't care to. Fuck star wars is just an overrated kids movie for children and the weaker minded.
Brayden Stewart
>Yoda burning a dead empty tree is insulting How was it insulting?
Jack Allen
Anyone who prefers this to the OT cut is a retard. It's just a fact.
Nolan Martin
should he come back as an old burn victim with no limbs?
the justification for it is that anakin saw his njured self as the result of being vader, and did not view his broken body as being truly him.
SO he reverted to the last time he was truly himself, the young jedi who was the powerhouse/hero of the republic
Christian Phillips
Oh shit the mouse is out in force this morning. Back to the clubhouse Mouseketeers, shoo shoo!
Luke Gray
while you're right about feminism pandering, its not like george lucas has any more moral high ground. he was money hungry and people like david prowse got fucked financially.
singling out something like pandering seems very personally. I don't give a fuck about disney or the force awakens. im talking about the last jedi.
Bentley Smith
no you fucking faggot, just stop editing the original one sebastian shaw was fine
Christopher Cooper
Actually, people like you who hold OT as some kind of sacred thing that can't be touched are the idiots.
John Richardson
>im talking about the last jedi. me too, the entire movie was "sacrificed" for the sake of feminist pandering it's the worst movie of the entire saga I would even say that it's the worst movie I've ever seen
Benjamin Bell
Christfags, when you die what are you going tkook like when you go to heaven? What you looked like when you died?
Josiah Sullivan
also not to mention I dont really see something like animal rights pandering like other people do. the movie obviously plays both sides of the field.
theres a reason that luke isnt just chilling, munching on porgs. his lifestyle is shown as moderate and a gritty reality of survival.
John Gray
Nostalgia. They don't realise star wars has always been shit made for kids and nothing more.
It's not just "shit made for kids" though. It's cheesy mindless sci fi for people of all ages. But some people took the whole thing way too seriously, and practically built a religion out of it, elevating the whole thing way above the actual quality of the series.
Jason Carter
Oh boy, Lucas shills out in full force. >same goes for the other 90% of additions But most of the additions were CGI that clashed with the aesthetics and SFX of the old film. The minor ones (Krayt dragon, R2 hiding behind a rock) aren't bad but do little to nothing to enhance the film. Addition for the sake of addition is garbage filmmaking. By your same (retarded) logic, Obi Wan should appear as Ewan Macgregor. After all, that's when jedi master Obi Wan metaphorically died and replaced by some old hermit named Ben. Wrong. They've always been kid friendly but that doesn't mean they were made strictly for kids. Part of the reason for its success has been the widespread appeal.
Ian Rivera
>Krayt Dragon >not bad dude Obi Wan sounds like he just had the biggest fucking orgasm ever
Robert Walker
>there is nothing wrong with this addition Agreed, I don't mind young Anakin