TFW RWBY will never be more than a 6/10

it hurts bros

Other urls found in this thread:

twitter.com/graymartigan/status/645080269507002368
youtube.com/watch?v=juCVprrmdb4
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

Just wait until a major anime studio gets ahold of the rights, and then a proper version will be made.

I still want Madhouse to animate some juicy Yang tits. And just imagine the legs on Nora...

If anything Trigger would be the ones to do it, they love american cartoons and movies.

Mmmmmm, Nora legs. You know, I think there's a thread on /aco/ that's calling me.

Season 1: 2/10
Season 2: 3/10
Season 3: 7/10
Season 4: 5/10

Apparently new details are coming tommorow about the new blazblue crossover game.

The writing? Yeah, it's going to continue to be a festival of mediocrity, but on the plus side, it looks like the team animating RWBY is getting more competent at animating using Maya. Comparing the released Volume 5 shorts to all of Volume 4 is like fucking night and day, and that's saying something.

it has Korra syndrome, bad writing with good porn

6/10 seems rather generous a score for rwby

Is Ruby the best girl?

she's not even the main character

That sounds like a recipe for disaster. Like when SHAFT got SoreMachi.

>6/10
this is how deluded this fanbase is

>Implying it is even slightly above average.
4/10

Guys that did highschool dxd, that's my hope.

>more than a 6/10
What? I watched a couple of episodes and it was nowhere near above 5/10 with all that awkward animation and very bad voice acting.

The only thing I liked were some of the weapon designs.

if we pretend we arent IGN for a minute and presume that a 5 is truly mediocre, the RWBY is a 4 for being mediocre and unoriginal.

Ruby looks very likeable and fun

>likeable
lol

That is true. It's barely reached 5 overall.

A pure maiden like her is very easy to like.

who is?

It's 0/10 at best. No redeeming qualities. I'm glad Monty is dead.

Miles

Pyrrha

Ruby a qt

Interesting.

>No redeeming qualities
Not even the waifus?

Season 3 was fantastic
RWBY is a masterpiece and I can't wait until it pulls another season 3 and show you butts how great it is

Hate it when fanart looks much better than the actual show.

Are any of the fights even good?

The show is held back by the 15 minutes episodes and really mediocre writing. You can't develop a story or characters over 15 minutes and if you're writing isn't great it's only going to make it worse.
At least the porn is good

you people are you to hard on this show its fucking sad

I think it's hilarious how the best season of the show is a tournament arc, and is only good for the last 4 episodes.
So, basically, you have the hardest possible storyline to fuck up: Add characters, Add a roster, animate fights and you're done. And after that you have what's roughly the only good hour and fifteen minutes of the show.

Good Job, Miles, you can make the writer's equivalent of a frozen pizza.

Jaune, now, it seems. The namesakes of the show have taken a backseat to some asshole nobody but self proclaimed nice guys can sympathize with.

The end was the only good bit. And is a repeat of that really worth sitting through all of the rest of the trash? Probably not. Are we going to do it anyway? Probably.

God forbid multiple characters drive the plot.

What the fuck is RWBY? Is it a color thing? Red, white, blue, yellow?

Red - white - black - yellow
Also the first letter of the names of the sort of/former protagonists. Rwby, Weiss, Blake, and Yang.

Is this shit somehow related to the concept of rhe lanterns?

Nope. It's just aesthetics I guess. Which basically is the whole show. Not much though, just pretty colors on pretty girls that you want to put in pretty pictures. That's probably why it looks so ugly when it moves.

Why is RWBY discussed here and not on Sup Forums?

maybe roosterteeth should dig up montys corpse and dance it around stage to get publicicty

the only reason this shit show has been around as long as it has is because RT has a couple million fans

if this were a real show on tv it would have been cancelled after 6 episodes

It's not anime. It's written and animated By a company in Texas. There is a manga that was made by some Japanese dude, but it's adapted from the show.

This is as much "anime" as Kappa Mikey, Totally Spies, or Code Leoko. In the sense that they aren't.

Does the series at least have cute waifus?

That's it's only redeeming quality. Also the porn.

I think so, yes.

On what planet is RWBY a 6/10?

I seriously can't understand how anyone can watch and enjoy it. The plot is barely comprehensible let alone coherent. The character design looks like they came out of a malware filled free to play mmorpg. The dialogue is either terrible jokes or stilted exposition. And the animation looks like it was done by a highschool student who's just screwing around. I'd be hesitant to give it a 3/10 honestly. It's almost unwatchable.

I get that people just like it for the waifus, but I honestly can't understand how you could stand to sit through a show this bad just for that.

The only person I really gave a shit about is ash BUT this show was always shit

>RWBY is so unoriginal.
>now time to go back to fapping over capeshit reboot 2.0 the re-origining
Don't get me wrong, RWBY has a lot of problems but I have never understood this line of criticism.
If there's one good thing I can say about RWBY, it's that it's at least a brand new IP which puts it well above the avalanche of rehashed shit that gets dumped on people each year in my book. At the very least in aesthetic.

>people always talking about how good Blake's vol 5 character short looks like compared to vol 4
>I literally can't tell the difference.
Do I just have low standards or do I just not have an eye for noticing things like this?

I could tell the difference in the Weiss short but that's only for the super obvious showing off scence of the lighting effects when she used her fire attack.

Volume 3 was an 8/10 for me, IMO. It had actual stakes, deaths, and consequences in a show that is reluctant or out right refuses to have them.

Other scores:
Vol.1: 5/10 I can't give this too much shit because it sets up the series.

Vol.2: 4/10. It had too many short episodes, and it just sets up for Vol.3. The finale was meaningless.

Vol.4: 3/10 despite the improved animation.The plot lingers and stays there for an entire volume.

Those are some fair scores.
I personally might have Vol 4 have a slightly higher score since there were some good moments, but yeah, this is about right.

I'm just saying, if anyone would make an anime of RWBY they'd likely be on board.
Plenty for everybody

yes

I feel like an animated RWBY movie might happen somewhere down the line.
Some side-story or maybe a movie adaptation of the plot of the video game or something.

Considering how popular it is in Japan, I could see it happening.

>maybe a movie adaptation of the plot of the video game
Holy shit the fucking video game was bare bones ass. There was no fucking story at all. All we get were a few snippets of vague allusions to something bigger and nothing else. It'd be nice if they did that because then they can actually give the fucking thing a story. They'd be pretty much free to do whatever the fuck they want and writing a new RWBY story from scratch.

that's very presumptuous to think I like capeshit

I give itb a 6/10 and not a 4, because of the few,FEW, good things about RWBY
>Weiss and Ruby talking with their Teachers about leadership
>Nora and Ren's relationship
>Ozpin and ruby drawing parallels about the battle field and the dance
>Pyrrha's death
>Roman's last scenes until he dies

I don't know man, I'm reaching for what ever I can. I'm just saying a self contained movie story is possible.

I mean like a year ago viz was vauguely teasing "something RWBY" so who the fuck knows.

>All we get were a few snippets of vague allusions to something bigger and nothing else
So just like the show itself?

He's not just driving the plot, it's fucking revolving around him and his dead girlfriend.

My local theater is doing a showing of the premiere episode of Volume 5. I'm debating whether or not to go because no one I know IRL watches RWBY and I want some friends, but also I don't want to go outside and reveal my power level. Also I love Yang.

>My local theater is doing a showing of the premiere episode of Volume 5
What state are you in user?
I didn't even know this was a thing they were doing.

well it might happen since rwby right now is very popular in japan it even has son collaborations with restaurants and a shop in akibahara coming soon.

>jaune is literally more relatable and better MC than ruby

the main 4 are boring but at least the jnpr drama is enjoyable.

rwby has a novel in japan called THE SESSION which is a travel to a island and beach shenanigans with some action that's probably the one they will animate.

Woah, careful man, I almost cut myself on the edge there

I'm going need some sauce on this.

I agree with you wholeheartedly user.

Oh like A-1?

All three of them are in general better people than the main four.

RWBY is un-original in the sense that it basically re-uses about 80% of all popular anime tropes. I remember when the show was in the early stages, Monty was on a podcast and basically said "I forced everyone on the staff to watch a bunch of anime to get ideas".

That and the majority of the weapons are generic and unoriginal in design and function.

Lmao, shit is still shit. It's no better than your seasonal battle harem or isekai shit. Roosterfags are so delusional

twitter.com/graymartigan/status/645080269507002368

Also RWBY is in the next Blazblue game, which should tell you something.

>Weapons are generic and unoriginal.
Nigga what?

This is why team Rnjr is better than team RWBY.

The damn thing its basically a carbon copy of Soul Eater meets Metal Gear Rising with some other unoriginal shonen tropes

>Ruby seems to always get excused for her reckless heroism and idealism by things somehow working out in the end
>finally thought Ruby will face the consequences of her actions by getting her uncle killed
>they struggle with a boss fight against a grimm
>they finally win through a combined effort but qrow's condition keeps getting worse and there seems no hope so it's a bittersweet victory
>oh boy time for some growth for my girl Ruby
>airship outta fucking nowhere to save the day

I legit laughed at that point. After Jaune gave the speech about how Ruby always toughs it out despite every hardship, I thought it was a set-up for Qrow's passing and how Ruby will soldier on but guess not.

They dont even made the 3D models either

...

...

...

...

RWBY Chibi > RWBY

oh Monty...

Is Soul Eater any good?

It's alright as far as shounen go.

I really enjoy it and it one of the few dubs I can bear watch it in english
youtube.com/watch?v=juCVprrmdb4

It sure was doing stuff that wasnt usual part youtube.com/watch?v=juCVprrmdb4 at of the Shonen Jump formula, but yeah since it was published there, it had to still cram those tropes from time to time

>6/10
that's pretty fucking generous don't you think?
if it's honestly got any sort of ok writing/characters/whatever to it why don't they do a fucking book? every iteration of it i've seen either still or in motion is like getting glass thrown in my eyes

You forgot best grill, Frog Witch

If you like Sgt Frog you'll love it.
Which is an odd recommendation I know but it works.

More like Soul Eater, Blazblue, and Final Fantasy VIII (for whatever reason).

Still waiting to see who the jump the shark resurrecting first. Roman, or Pyrrha.

Because Monty was too much of a JRPG fag to not have a resurrection in there somewhere.

The problem is that we alreadu have four main characters who are all driving the plot, and all four of them are seperated right now.
And given how short the episodes are, there really isn't much room for Jaune's personal Arc.

>Final Fantasy VIII (for whatever reason).

It was Monty's favorite game.

>Soul Eater came up with protagonists with scythes and schools that train kids into heroes or whatever
Fuck man, I didn't know that Seraph of the End,My Hero Academy,Sky High and Disgaea 3 ripped off Soul Eater.

The criticism notes are retarded.

they are not exactly heroes and all of those came after of it too.
Now I get you are trying to go for the gotcha moment to perhaps defend to an extend this ripoff that used stolen MMD models then you should have go with Soul Eater trying to act like if it was Bleach or something like that, you had one job you mouthbreather

Wait, are these the real reasons people compare Soul Eater to RWBY? Really?

This