How come comics never took off as a pornographic medium unlike manga in Japan?

how come comics never took off as a pornographic medium unlike manga in Japan?

Other urls found in this thread:

exhentai.org/g/1041744/c201bc69f5/
twitter.com/SFWRedditVideos

capeshit

My guess would be American puritanism mixed with a different cultural perception of the medium thanks to

Too much work. Easier just to do a pic, comic with a few panels, or put the effort into an animation.

It's considered childish, "why watch cartoon porn when you can see real titties."

...

Nips are willing to pay for porn without shame.
On a related note, this doujin has God tier art wtf
exhentai.org/g/1041744/c201bc69f5/

the west doesn't have a doujin culture like japan does.

My dad had a ton of comic porn. Most was more like Vampirella but I remember some old tattoo magazines having flat out comic porn.

What's the original?

No shit sherlock, he's asking WHY it doesn't you dumb fuck.

clearly you never read Alan Moore's favorite furry porn comic

Surprisingly, She tries to get in his pants

American prudishness combined with stricter copyright laws.

>yaoi
Why.

I'm talking about doujin in a broader sense ie self-published material, porn or not. In Japan cometition for any sort of creative stuff is very harsh so getting a whole comic done is a way to get noticed by publishers. In the West a simple portfolio will usually be enough.

This artist did some straight stuff but her gay shit has the best art.

There's tons of porn comics though

I have. I like it, tho it really shows when Reed and Kate stopped working together -- scripts went right down the tubes.

Different mindset in culture. Most Americans during the time saw all animation and comics as "kids stuff" thus the creators appealed mostly to that market. While there are some who do more adult works, the natural response was less exposure due to the fear of response from the general public.

Look at the Teenage Mutant Ninja comics. Didn't really get much attention till the cartoon. And the cartoons are nothing like the comics in a terms of violence and atmosphere. Heck I still get looks of amazement when I tell people that the TMNT comics used to be filled with violence.

On Paper? I mean there's tons online but I think OP is talking about how the nips publish it on paper and distribute it like normal manga.

Probably the same reason OVAs never became popular here either. For whatever reason.

Anyone got the picture comparing japan's hentai industry to american comic porn? It's got Kanye west smoking a stack of cash on the one side and a starving dirty kid on the other.

Because we'll just pirate it. We like porn, we just don't want to pay for it.

It kinda did, maybe not in USA, but Europe is full of pornographic and borderline pornographic comics, specially Italy.

>European porn comics
good stuff.

But we have those here in America. They're called DTV

...

hentai manga got a lot of support early on, largely as the unintended side effect of the Japanese government cracking down on general pornography. This is also true for much of the less conventional hentai (e.g., you couldn't draw dicks, but tentacles got past the censors). Porn consumers in the US never had to move to a drawn medium because photos and videos were always much more available.

>be rightclops
>teen version of your first love wants to jump your pants
>calmly turn her down without showing a hint of interest
>get called out by kitty who watched the whole thing

Scott was so right not even Bendis could make him wrong.

>another "why aren't comics like my shitty japanese cartoons?" thread

It's popular everywhere, but the USA

jesus christ what is wrong with her eyebrows

Working my comic porn, myself; most of you nerds prefer loli looking manga.

If I do some half-ass manga shit it get tons more attention than my regular comic style.

I hate it.

No I will not post art.

Okay, yeah Japan has a huge drawn porn industry but their censorship laws are full on retarded.
>obvious adult only manga
>BETTER PUT FUCKING PIXELS AND BLACK MARKS OVER ALL THE NAUGHTY BITS

its probably garbage so don't bother.

>fishing with such a wide net thanks to AnonGTS and various patreons that I can fill gigs of disk space with my niche fetish material

feels good man.

>Giantess porn
>It basically always amounts to either ALL SHE DOES is get big and naked and if you're lucky maybe she remarks about how horny it makes her

>Pixel and Black Marks
>On manga

I literally can't remember a single instance of this happening in a manga, and in case it probably has more to do with magazine publishing the manga than jap censorship laws, since there are a lot of not hentai manga that get away with a lot more than just showing "naughty bits".

gts is easymode really.

Western artists can't draw beautiful women that don't look like the same hourglass sports illustrated swimsuit model.

Why the fuck are most western porn comics only about incest?

Is that really an issue?
Because you're getting most your western porn comics from a specific site that caters to that niche.

That one's actually pretty okay. It almost reads like a cape book. Not much sex, just giant chicks stopping natural disasters and doing search and rescue stuff.

Playboy comics and sexual cartoons used to be a thing, but were replaced by adult films and magazine nudes. Americans prefer the real deal.

>how come comics never took off as a pornographic medium unlike manga in Japan?
They did, look at all the franco-belgian ones

Y'know, I hope to fuck Incase prints a book sometime. The characters are actually likeable, and it's hot as fuck. It's actually a pretty decent fantasy universe as well. Would be nice to have a hardcopy.

Because that's what you look up. Try using other keywords.

Negging only works on Drunk girls, user.

Black censor bars show up all the time in pornographic manga. Look up literally any porn manga you've read before and it's gonna be censored.

American porn is complete garbage
It's all hello I'm the pizza boy tire shit
Incest tags are really fucking popular but it's all amateur shit, where are the proffessionals? Hell there is a reason story in porn is an old meme, they just cram two hours of shit into a DVD with no context
Best and most creative I have seen is when they do shit like getting some random drunk guy into a van with a pornstar or the efuckt videos with some camera guy treating the girls like absolute crap
No wonder there are soamy pedos around

In spain there were compilations of porn comics from all Europe.

>how come comics never took off as a pornographic medium unlike manga in Japan?
Really?
There's dozens of comic porn sites and for decades there's been porn hardcopy comics.

If anything Western comic porn is way ahead of the curve, Japan has only recently started embracing digitization.

Can you link me that sex image in the bottom panel friend

>surprisingly

He's older, experienced, alpha as fuck, basically an idealized version of her teen crush. It's no wonder she goes for that dong like a moth to a flame, and cyke is alpha as fuck for turning her down

Got ya covered

Comics generally have a more realistic look to the point that many are just tracings of actual porno mags.

Without much stylization you might as well just watch real porn.

Nipland might be behind on digital but their industry is also far bigger
>many

>can take months after show premiers to get even terrible sketches
anyone that's been on Sup Forums for more than 5 minutes knows this isn't true

The animation age ghetto also affected comics which meant naughty content would never be seen on any shelves.

Literally this man

>Hello emotionally disturbed little boy, what do you enjoy doing?
...reading comics I guess...like 99% of boys in this era
>E-GAD! BAN IT ALL!!!!
>I SHALL SAVE THE CHILDREN FROM VIOLENCE AND SEX IN COMICS!

Japan got lucky, censorship just forced them to get creative

No matter how much Marvel throws shit at him. He just keeps getting up, looking at those disgusting baby looking fat bastard and say: "Is that all you have, you pathetic losers? No wonder guys like me used to bully you in High School"

I would totally buy this shit if it had a physical copy. Probably hide it from my family and friend, but I buy it.

user, this is Sup Forums. This is strictly a milf board, mother fucker.

Doujinshi just means "self-published magazine" it's not porn by default. If the west had a scene for that then porn would naturally become a large portion of it like it is in Japan.

DC isn't going to publish porn, just like Shonen Jump doesn't.

Well there are those DC movies that have some continuity between a few.

It's what you look up.

And when some type of porn is niche it'll usually be filled with niche fetishes.

Reason is simple people will pay a lot of niche stuff and you might as well capture an audience will the stuff is still niche.

Or furry shit. High Quality Furry shit.

Weebs made that chart, don't expect them to be tethered to reality

Rightclops is the guy who invites the pathetic loner to parties not out of pity but out of kindness.

But he is comparing manga not anime. And it is true that japanese 2D porn > Western 2D porn

Rightclops was the man that always had your back, making sure nobody puts some weird shit in your drink or when you lose you car keys, he always had the number of a good keysmith.

Western art is revolting, even more so Western porn.

Maybe nowdays but back in day it used as loli board as Sup Forums is.

And those days are over, thankfully. Because fuck that shit, good old big tits are always superior to the fictional and non existent dfc.

very influential, often christian-based parental watchgroups

>Why the fuck are most western porn comics only about incest?
Have you even read hentai?

But everything else is true in that picture. Japan just makes better 2D porn

You get what you pay for and clapistanis don't wanna pay for shit.

>And those days are over, thankfully
Maybe for normalfags who ruined this board.
You cant have loli threads anymore without mod deleting them or normalfags/moralfags shitting the threads

Why is there no impregnation in the few western porn comics we get?

Awwww... is the poor weeb mad that milfs are objectively superior to their sick pedo shit?

Kill yourself, m8.

But there is more variety in hentai. Sure there is alot incest but there is alot other stuff

I like milfs too but when you cant have any other threads than milf then it kinda becomes problem.

Sup Forums can have milf threads and loli threads at same time and nobody complains.
>weeb
Dude, you are on Sup Forums. Of course there is gonna be weeaboos around here

There were pornographic American comics in the 30s and 40s. They were killed off by the CCA. They came back in the late 90s/early 2000s, only to be killed off again by the Internet.

The US comic industry is run by a monopoly that thinks cooties are 4realz.

Spain still seems to have pornographic monthlies.

this

Why are you even on Sup Forums if you get so mad about lolis? Reddit is better place for you

Christians who feel the need to control everyone else's lives because they A) never learned from the Puritans and B) are Americans and in AMERICA we have freedom of religion as long as your religion involves some ambiguous, non-specific love of whatever you think Jesus said

We're on Sup Forums as opposed to Reddit because our idea of humor isn't "*rick and morty quote* XD EPIC REFERENCE BROH." It just happens that Sup Forums, /d/, and maybe /aco/ are about the only places where lolis are tolerated

True. It's sad. Porn makers churn out shitloads of the same shock value garbage because they think it's what everyone wants. Guys see nothing else available and assume it's what they're supposed to be happy with. Humans by nature get bored fast and need more and more new different material, so we go more and more "extreme" but it's nothing new or creative, just louder and more obnoxious.

I just wish there was more cute cheesecake lewds :^(

I think it's still an even split, but a good portion of loliposters are probably baiting.

Incorrect.

Rightclops isn't a bully

You sometimes see posts like
>Brazil 200 million people and doesn't make games
>Indian has 1 billion people and has yet to make any games
and etc.

but the real question is, how come Japan is able to create so much media, almost more than America in a lot of cases?
I mean Japan has so many comics that come out a year, while America a country 3 times the size in population only has a less than 200 series

barely 200 series a year

Japan is highly influenced by American culture since they basically became a colony after World War 2

Americans are terrified of creating something that isn't guaranteed to profit.

yeah i know
but Japan makes a lot of media, while American media is a lot less if you ratio is